Murderpedia has thousands of hours of work behind it. To keep creating
new content, we kindly appreciate any donation you can give to help
the Murderpedia project stay alive. We have many
plans and enthusiasm
to keep expanding and making Murderpedia a better site, but we really
need your help for this. Thank you very much in advance.
Melanie
Jane SMITH
Same day
Lee-Anna
Shiers, her four-year-old nephew Bailey, two-year-old niece Skye,
her partner Liam Timbrell and their 15-month-old son Charlie all
died as a result of the blaze
By Mike Horney - Independent.co.uk
May 8, 2013
A woman who murdered five members of a family, including three
young children, when she set fire to her neighbour's pushchair,
was jailed for at least 30 years today.
Alcoholic Melanie Smith, 43, started the devastating blaze
because she was angry the pushchair had been left in a shared
hallway close to the front door of her flat.
Lee-Anna Shiers, 20, her four-year-old nephew, Bailey, and
two-year-old niece, Skye, were trapped in their upstairs flat and
died in the arson attack in North Wales on October 19 last year.
Firefighters managed to rescue Ms Shiers's 15-month-old son
Charlie and his father Liam Timbrell, 23, but they died in
hospital.
Smith, who lived in the flat below the victims in Maes y Groes,
Prestatyn, was found guilty of five counts of murder by a jury at
Mold Crown Court last Tuesday.
Smith wept as the sentence was passed by trial judge Mr Justice
Griffith-Williams.
The judge told Smith that at first it seemed unlikely that a
mother-of-five with no previous convictions could set fire to a
house with people in it.
But after hearing the evidence he said he was satisfied that
Smith set fire to the pushchair.
He said Smith was motivated by jealousy due to her faltering
relationship with Stephen Clarkson, whom she accused of cheating
on her with a woman called Samantha Schofield - a woman she hated.
"That hatred, which was all the more intense because of your
drink problem, took over your life," the judge said.
Smith was convicted last Tuesday of five counts of murder and
one count of making threats of arson after the jury of seven women
and five men reached 10-2 majority verdicts following 15 hours of
deliberations.
Smith had been increasingly angry with Ms Shiers, accusing the
young mother of being a noisy and untidy neighbour, her trial was
told.
Witnesses said Smith had been heard complaining about Ms Shiers
leaving the pram in the hallway and leaving cigarette ends around
the front door area.
On the night of the fire, Smith was drunk and started the blaze
"in a rage" after hearing Ms Shiers and Mr Timbrell having sex
upstairs.
The court was played a harrowing 999 call in which Mr Timbrell
shouted: "Oh my God, oh my God, we're going to die."
The jury was told that Mr Timbrell later told rescuing
paramedics that "it was arson" and "it was Mel" and said he heard
Smith shouting through the letterbox that she was going to burn
the house down.
The judge said that while her relationship with Mr Clarkson
remained "uneasy" Smith "took out" her "unhappiness" on Ms Shiers.
"And she became the focus of your attentions," he said.
The court heard that Smith was a "very tidy person".
"You resented any mess she made," Mr Justice Griffith-Williams
said.
The inconvenience of the pushchair in the hallway, cigarette
ends dropped by the front door, and noise coming from upstairs all
became "issues which grew out of all proportion".
The judge said that on that Friday evening Mr Clarkson wanted
"little to do" with the defendant and went home to sleep.
Smith, who, the judge said, was "certainly affected by
alcohol", purchased a takeaway to eat alone at home.
The judge told her: "My belief is that at that moment you were
probably a very sad woman and it was the sound of Lee-Anna and
Liam's love-making from the flat above that overwhelmed you.
"Bitterly resentful of their happiness, you went outside and
set fire to the pushchair. It follows that you acted on impulse
and so this was not a premeditated act.
"My belief is you did not know Bailey and Skye were there but
that reduces your culpability only marginally because you were
clearly indifferent to the presence of others in the flat
upstairs.
"When, contrary to what you had intended, the fire spread to
your flat, you escaped, probably by the back door, shouting at
Steven Clarkson to get him to follow you.
"The setting-fire to the pushchair was an act of exceptional
wickedness, almost unparalleled in its consequences.
"For those who had to hear the evidence of the 999 calls, the
horror of those moments in the flat upstairs as Lee-Anna and Liam
faced the awful inevitability of their imminent deaths will be
forever etched on their memories.
"Understandably the knowledge of the manner of their deaths has
added to the overwhelming grief of their families, all the more to
those who rushed to the house in the hope they could help.
"I have had regard to the contents of the three victim
statements. Each witness wrote eloquently of the effects upon them
and their families of their losses.
"That grief will not have been mitigated by any meaningful
remorse on your part. You continue to portray yourself as a
victim, blinding yourself to the sufferings of the real victims in
this case and failing to at least acknowledge that it was your
deliberate act which started the fire."
'She should rot in hell': Ex-husband's fury
as arsonist who wiped out a family is convicted of five murders
Melanie Smith set fire at neighbours' home
after long-running argument
Lee-Ann Shiers and boyfriend Liam Timbrell
killed alongside three children
Alcoholic Smith had history of making vicious
arson threats while drunk
By Liz Hull - DailyMail.co.uk
May 1, 2013
A woman who started a fire which killed five
members of the same family – including three children under five –
was facing life in jail last night after being convicted of
murder.
Melanie Smith, 43, set fire to a baby’s
pushchair because she was fed up with it being outside her front
door.
But the blaze spread into a devastating inferno
which ripped through the first-floor flat in Prestatyn, North
Wales, last October.
It trapped and killed Lee-Anna Shiers, 20, her
partner Liam Timbrell, 23, their baby son Charlie, 15 months, Miss
Shiers’s nephew Bailey, four, and niece Skye, two.
Jobless Smith, who lived in the flat below, was
yesterday convicted by a 10-2 majority of five counts of murder,
making her one of the most prolific murderesses in modern British
history. She will be sentenced next month.
Her ex-husband, Paul Smith, said the killer
‘deserves to rot in hell’.
Smith collapsed in tears at Mold Crown Court
after the jury returned their verdicts. She sobbed ‘Oh my God, no’
when the first verdict of murder was returned.
The victims’ relatives in the packed public
gallery gasped ‘Yes!’ when the foreman announced the verdicts.
The jury was told that as the fire took hold,
Mr Timbrell was heard in the background of a 999 call screaming:
‘Oh my God, oh my God, we’re going to die.’
Despite being badly burned, Mr Timbrell managed
to tell police that he heard Smith shouting through the letterbox:
‘I’m going to burn your house down.’
After the case, Lee-Anna’s parents Joy, 45, and
Peter, 64, told of their relief. Mrs Shiers said: ‘I am overjoyed.
'I am sorry for her family because we have
always got on well with them. All our family are so happy at the
verdicts.’
Her husband added: ‘Nothing will bring them
back but we have at least seen justice served. There is a big hole
in our lives and how do we fill that hole? It is just impossible.’
The Daily Mail can reveal that Smith had a
history of cruelty to her own children.
She stubbed cigarettes out on her baby son’s
forehead, hacked off her toddler daughter’s blonde hair, scalded
her with boiling water and locked her in an understairs cupboard
as punishment.
Mr Smith, 51, said she inflicted terrible
cruelty on the three children they had together, before abandoning
them aged three, two and nine months.
He said: ‘She destroyed my family years ago,
and by setting fire to that house she’s ruined the lives of so
many other people.
'The sentence is totally deserved and none of
us ever want to see her again.
‘She was an appalling mother to her own
children, and now she’s done this to these other kids.
'It’s horrific. That evil woman deserves to rot
in hell.’
Born in the seaside town of Prestatyn, Smith
was 17 when she married Mr Smith. Over the next few years they had
three children.
Mr Smith said his ex-wife resented being tied
down to three young children and regularly mistreated them.
One of Smith’s daughters, Charlotte, now 23 and
a mother of one, said: ‘It shocked me to know what she’d done, but
it’s not out of character.
'She was cruel to us as kids, so why shouldn’t
she be cruel to other kids years later?
‘She was a mother from hell to me – and she
still is. Spending the rest of her life in prison won’t come close
to what she deserves.’
Mr Smith added: ‘I shudder when I think that
Melanie will probably spend the rest of her days in prison, but
she’s brought it on herself.
‘She’ll go down in history as a notorious
killer.’
Killer's history of crazed arson threats
ahead of murder
Self-confessed alcohol 'binger' Melanie Smith
had a 'propensity' to make drunken threats to burn people's houses
down 'with their children inside'.
Mold Crown Court was told of numerous occasions
when Smith threatened to set fire to property and how in the six
weeks before the fire she stepped up her campaign of threats
against Lee-Anna Shiers.
In late 2007, Smith was barred from the
Victoria Hotel in Prestatyn for being 'loud and argumentative',
the court was told.
In April 2008 Smith and her boyfriend Steven
Clarkson were again refused service at the pub by the landlady.
Smith's response was to say: 'I'm going to
f****** torch this place', and to storm out of the door in a
temper, the court heard.
The court heard Smith 'hated' Samantha
Schofield, whom she claimed had been having an affair with
Clarkson.
In August 2012 Smith 'trashed' Mr Clarkson's
car while it was parked outside Ms Schofield's house.
The windscreen wipers were bent back, the wing
mirrors kicked out of position and pink milkshake thrown at the
windscreen.
Around 20 matches were also strewn around the
road outside Ms Schofield's house and a matchbox was found beneath
Mr Clarkson's car.
Smith then had two conversations with Ms
Schofield's sister, Amy, in which she said she was 'going to set
fire to Sam's house'.
Smith said that she had nearly set fire to the
house but was 'too drunk to ignite the matches'.
When it was pointed out to her that Ms
Schofield had children living with her who 'had done nothing
wrong', Smith replied: 'I'm not finished with Sammy yet and I
can't make any promises.'
On September 1 2012, Smith told Ms Shiers's
friend Stacey Brady that she was going to 'make Lee-Anna's life
hell'.
The court heard Smith was 'ranting' about her
throwing cigarette butts and shouted up at Ms Shiers: 'I am going
to set your house on fire with you and your kids in it.'
On September 5 Ms Shiers' brother, Michael,
called to see his sister and she told him that when the defendant
was drunk she made threats to burn her house down, saying: 'I have
threatened to burn someone else's house down and I will do the
same to you.'
The manager of the Vegas Bar in Rhyl, Yvette
Giblin, told police that on October 13 she heard the defendant
rowing with Clarkson.
She claims Smith said in a raised voice:
'You're shagging the woman upstairs. I will burn the house down
with her and the kids in it.'
On October 18 2012, Smith told her friend
Pamela Handley she was going to 'torch or bomb' her landlord's
flat and that he was not going to get any money from her rent.
On the morning of October 19, Smith went to
Chantelle's hair salon where hairdresser Sophie Griffiths noticed
she smelled of alcohol and was complaining about her flat.
She said it was too small and that she did not
like her neighbours or landlord, adding: 'To be honest, I wish
they'd burn it to the ground because the council would have to put
me up then.'
'OH MY GOD, WE'RE GOING TO DIE': VICTIM'S
HARROWING 999 CALL
One of Melanie Smith's victims made a harrowing
999 call from the burning building and was heard shouting: 'Oh my
God, oh my God, we're going to die.'
The jury in her murder trial heard a recording
of Liam Timbrell's call to emergency services, in which he said:
'Help, help. Someone has put it on purpose. We're inside the
flat.'
Mr Timbrell, the only person from inside the
flat who could give an account of the fire, later told rescuing
paramedics that 'it was arson' and 'it was Mel from downstairs'.
He was very badly burned but became alert and
awake, and said: 'Babies, are the babies okay?'
He then added: 'I heard a woman shouting in the
street.'
Asked by the paramedics what he meant, he
replied: '"I'm going to set fire to the house" - yes, yes I heard
this woman shouting she was going to set fire to the house.'
Mr Timbrell repeatedly said 'Mel did it,' and
told a police community support officer: 'She was shouting through
the letterbox, "I'm going to burn your house down."'
Asked if he recognised the voice, Mr Timbrell
said 'Yes', adding: 'It was Mel from the downstairs flat.'
She deliberately set pushchair alight because she was angry it
had been left in shared hallway
By Paul Keaveny - Independent.co.uk
April 30, 2013
A "drunk and jealous" woman has been found guilty of murdering
five members of the same family, including three young children,
in a devastating blaze following a row about a pram.
Melanie Smith, 43, deliberately set fire to a pushchair because
she was angry that it had been left in a shared hallway, Mold
Crown Court heard.
The court was told she carried out the "terrible and wicked deed"
because she was "drunk and angry", disillusioned with her
boyfriend, very unhappy in her flat and jealous of the woman who
lived upstairs.
Lee-Anna Shiers, 20, her four-year-old nephew, Bailey, and
two-year-old niece, Skye, died in the arson attack at their home
in Prestatyn, North Wales, on October 19 last year.
Firefighters managed to rescue Ms Shiers's 15-month-old son
Charlie and his father Liam Timbrell, 23, from the first-floor
flat but they died in hospital.
Smith, who lived in the flat below the victims in Maes y Groes,
Prestatyn, was found guilty of all five counts of murder by a jury
of seven women and five men today.
Smith appeared to collapse into the security guard on her right as
the first of the 10 to two majority verdicts was returned after
almost 15 hours of deliberations by the jury.
As the remaining guilty verdicts were announced by the jury
foreman, she bowed her head and looked to the floor.
In addition to five counts of murder, she was also convicted of
one count of making threats of arson.
In the public gallery on a balcony above the courtroom there was a
short outburst of "No", seemingly from a member of Smith's family.
Relatives of the victims were then heard to be crying as others
shouted: "Yes."
Trial judge Mr Justice Griffith Williams told the court he wanted
"time to reflect" before passing sentence.
He told Smith her life sentence was fixed by law, but she would be
brought back to the court on May 8 when she will be told the
minimum term.
The defendant clung on to the arm of a security guard as she was
led down to the cells and appeared to have difficulty walking.
During the three-week trial, the jury heard that Smith, an
alcoholic mother-of-five, has been increasingly angry with Ms
Shiers, accusing the young mother of being a noisy and untidy
neighbour.
Smith was also heard complaining to others about Ms Shiers leaving
the pram in the hallway and leaving cigarette ends around the
front door area.
Ian Murphy QC, for the prosecution, told the jury that on the
night of the fire, Smith was drunk and started the blaze "in a
rage" after hearing Ms Shiers and Mr Timbrell having sex upstairs.
The court was played a harrowing 999 call in which Mr Timbrell
shouted: "Oh my God, oh my God, we're going to die."
The jury was told that Mr Timbrell later told rescuing paramedics
that "it was arson" and "it was Mel from downstairs" after he said
he heard her shouting through the letterbox that she was going to
burn the house down.
Mr Murphy said Smith had a "propensity" to threaten people by
saying she would burn their houses down "with their children
inside".
The court heard that Smith made a string of similar threats to Ms
Shiers in the weeks before the fire.
She also threatened to "fire bomb" her landlord's home and burn
down the house of Samantha Schofield, whom she accused of having
an affair with her boyfriend Steven Clarkson.
Smith, who claimed in court that she once had counselling for
being obsessively tidy, denied the allegations and said 21 of the
prosecution witnesses, including a firefighter and a police
officer, were lying and plotting against her.
She said only a "sick and evil person" would threaten to start
fires in houses with children inside.
Prestatyn fire deaths: Murder trial jury
sent home until Monday
The jury at Mold Crown Court in the case of
Melanie Smith, who denies five charges of murder, will continue
deliberations after the weekend
WalesOnline.co.uk
April 26, 2013
The jury in the trial of a woman accused of
starting a house fire which killed five members of the same family
has been sent home for the weekend.
Melanie Smith, 43, is alleged to have set fire
to a pushchair because she was angry that it had been left in a
shared hallway.
Lee-Anna Shiers, 20, her four-year-old nephew,
Bailey, and two-year-old niece, Skye, died in the alleged arson
attack at their home in Prestatyn, North Wales, on October 19.
Firefighters managed to rescue Ms Shiers’
15-month-old son, Charlie, and his father, Liam Timbrell, 23, from
their first-floor flat but they later died in hospital.
Smith, who lived in the flat below the victims
in Maes y Groes, Prestatyn, denies five counts of murder.
The jury at Mold Crown Court retired to
consider their verdicts at 9.36 a.m. this morning.
The Judge Mr Justice Griffith-Williams told
them that they were under no pressure of time.
At 2.30 he called them back into court and
released them for the weekend, telling them that they could resume
their deliberations on Monday morning.
The jury had previously heard that Smith
carried out the “terrible and wicked deed” because she was “drunk
and angry”, disillusioned with her boyfriend and very unhappy in
her flat due to the untidiness of Ms Shiers.
Cross-examining Smith, Ian Murphy QC, for the
prosecution, said: “I suggest to you that it was very easy for you
to carry out this terrible, wicked deed of setting fire to the
pushchair with a lighter.”
Smith replied: “That is crazy. You are twisting
things.”
Mr Murphy also accused Smith of using her
boyfriend, Steven Clarkson, to establish a false alibi.
He said Smith got into bed with Clarkson after
setting fire to the pram so she could then pretend to be a victim.
Mr Murphy said: “It was started deliberately by
you and you in effect stage-managed your exit from the property.”
During the trial Smith denied the allegations
and said that 21 witnesses in the case who said they had heard her
making threats to burn down people’s houses were lying.
Prestatyn fire trial latest: Judge tells
jury to 'put aside sympathy and pity'
Mr Justice Griffith-Williams sums up as the
trial of Melanie Smith - who denies murdering five people - comes
to an end
By Kelly Williams - DailyPost.co.uk
April 25, 2013
A judge has today told a murder trial jury to
put aside "considerable sympathy and pity" for a family's
"incalculable loss" when deciding whether Melanie Smith killed a
young couple and three children in a blaze.
The honourable Mr Justice Griffith-Williams
told the seven women and five men to "make up your own minds about
where the truth lies in this case."
Smith denies murdering Lee-Anna Shiers, 20, her
partner, Liam Timbrell, 23, their 15-month-old son, Charlie and
Lee-Anna's two-year-old niece Skye Allen, and her brother Bailey,
four.
The 43-year-old is accused of starting the
fatal fire in Maes y Groes, Prestatyn last October by putting a
naked flame to Charlie's pushchair in the communal hallway.
The judge said the victims were "trapped in
what must've been absolute moments of terror," but reminded the
jury to disregard feelings of compassion when reaching their
verdict.
"It is your view and only your view of the
evidence that matters. You must consider it objectively and
dispassionately and above all, apply common sense," he said.
He told them to review all evidence and examine
the central issues in the case considering the closing arguments
of the prosecution and defence.
"Your verdict must be based on the evidence,
all the answers you need can be found in the evidence and you must
not speculate about what evidence there might've been."
Referring to the jury's questions as to why
they were unable to hear evidence from Smith's partner, Stephen
Clarkson, Mr Griffith-Williams said the prosecution and defence
are able to decide what witnesses they want to call in the case,
and added: "Speculating about what evidence he (Clarkson) might've
given would be a profitless exercise. All that is required is an
objective assessment of all the evidence and the issues in the
case."
He told the jury they must decide to whether to
acquit Smith or find her guilty murder or manslaughter based on
legal guidelines, and said: "You must consider the credibility and
reliability of witnesses and decide who is to be believed."
The judge will complete his summing up of the
case this afternoon.
It is likely the jury won't retire to begin
their deliberations until tomorrow.
Pictured for the first time: Mother of five
who denies murder of five members of same family in house blaze
she herself described as 'beyond evil'
Melanie Smith, 43, accused of torching
pushchair in anger because it was parked in shared hallway
Claims all witnesses in the case, including
police officer and a firefighter, were 'in it together'
She tells court: 'I would never burn anyone.
You have got to be beyond evil to do something like this'
Lee-Anna Shiers, 20, her nephew Bailey, four,
and niece Skye, two, all died
Son Charlie, 15 months, and his father Liam Timbrell died in
hospital later
By Simon Tomlinson and James Tozer
April 23, 2013
A mother accused of murdering five people by
setting fire to a pushchair outside their front door said that the
person who started the blaze was ‘beyond evil’.
Melanie Smith, pictured for the first time
arriving at court yesterday, denied killing the three children and
two adults because she was fed up with the buggy being left
outside her own front door, adding that she was ‘not that kind of
person’.
Lee-Anna Shiers, 20, her son Charlie, aged 15
months, Miss Shiers’s nephew Bailey, four, and niece Skye, two,
died in the fire at the first-floor flat in Prestatyn, north
Wales. Miss Shiers’s partner, Liam Timbrell, 23, died in hospital
a fortnight later.
Mold Crown Court has heard that Smith – a heavy
drinking, jobless mother of five who lived in the flat below –
started the fire after a row with Miss Shiers over the pushchair.
Smith, who lived in the flat below the victims
in Maes y Groes, Prestatyn, denies five counts of murder at Mold
Crown Court.
Under cross examination from Ian Murphy QC, for
the prosecution, Smith denied that she was a murderer.
Mr Murphy said Smith, an alcoholic, had been
'drunk and angry' at Ms Shiers and had told numerous friends that
she intended to burn her house down with children in it.
Mr Murphy said: 'I suggest to you that it was
very easy for you to carry out this terrible, wicked deed of
setting fire to the pushchair with a lighter.'
Smith replied: 'That is crazy. You are twisting
things.'
Mr Murphy accused Smith of using her boyfriend
Steven Clarkson to establish a false alibi.
He said Smith got into bed with Clarkson after
setting fire to the pram so she could then pretend to be a victim.
'Once you started that fire, you then started
your great big lie, by suggesting you are an innocent victim,' Mr
Murphy said.
Smith said: 'That's wrong.'
Mr Murphy said: 'It was started deliberately by
you and you in effect stage managed your exit from the property.'
'No chance,' Smith replied.
Mr Murphy added: 'After six weeks or more of
threats to torch or burn their property with children inside,
that's exactly what you did.'
Smith denied this, leading Mr Murphy to add:
'And you did so with deadly intent and to deadly effect.'
Smith said: 'No, that's not true. I'm not that
kind of person.'
During her trial, which started on April 10,
the court was played a harrowing 999 call in which Mr Timbrell
shouted: 'Oh my god, oh my god, we're going to die.'
The jury was also told that Mr Timbrell later
told rescuing paramedics that 'it was arson' and 'it was Mel' and
that he had heard Smith shouting threats about burning the house
down that night.
Mr Murphy said Mr Timbrell had heard Smith's
'easily recognisable voice'.
'He heard what he was later to tell other
people. He heard from you your deadly threat. I am going to set
fire to the house,' Mr Murphy said.
Smith, wearing glasses and with blonde hair
tied back, responded: 'I didn't say anything like that. Someone
has taken them all away and I am getting the blame for it.'
'He said, 'it was Mel', because he heard you,'
Mr Murphy said.
Smith replied: 'No.'
Mr Murphy said Smith was 'drunk and angry' on
the night in question.
Angry about her relationship with Mr Clarkson,
whom she had accused of cheating on her, and angry at Ms Shiers
for leaving the pushchair in the hallway, being noisy and being 'a
scruffy dirty bitch', the court heard.
He said Smith set the fire 'in a rage' after
hearing Ms Shiers and Mr Timbrell having sex upstairs.
Mr Murphy said: 'You told the jury that you
heard Lee-Anna making love upstairs. Is that what prompted you to
go and set this fire?'
Smith said: 'No it was not.'
The court has heard from a number of witnesses
who claim to have heard Smith making drunken threats to burn
peoples' houses down 'with their children inside' and Mr Murphy
said the defendant had a 'tendency' to do this when she was drunk.
Smith denied ever setting any fire or making
threats and added: 'I would never burn anyone. You have got to be
pretty sick and crazy and beyond evil to do something like this.'
Mr Murphy then asked her if she thought all the
witnesses in the case were lying and she responded: 'Yeah they
are. Everybody wants justice and they are all looking at me and I
am innocent. I have done nothing.'
Mr Murphy said it was Smith's intention to
'kill everybody in the upstairs flat' and said Smith knew Ms
Shiers regularly had more than one child staying over.
Smith replied: 'I don't think so. I would never
ever harm anyone in that way. What I have heard in court, I am
distraught myself. God knows what the family is going through.'
The trial continues.
By Sam Masters - Independent.co.uk
April 22, 2013
A woman accused of starting a fire that killed five members of
the same family living above her today told jurors she had never
wished any harm on the family.
Appearing before Mold Crown Court, Melanie Smith, 43, said anyone
who started fires was "screwed in the head".
Smith, who lived below the family in Prestatyn, north Wales, is
accused of deliberately starting the fire by torching a pushchair
because she was angry it had been left in a shared hallway by the
family upstairs.
Lee-Anna Shiers, 20, her nephew Bailey, four, and niece Skye, two,
died in the alleged arson on October 19.
Firefighters managed to rescue Ms Shiers' 15-month-old son Charlie
and his father, Liam Timbrell, 23, from the first-floor flat but
they later died in hospital.
Giving evidence Smith repeatedly denied ever making threats to
start fires. She said she did not ever suspect her boyfriend of
having "an affair" with Ms Shiers and denied ever having a problem
with the pushchair being left in the communal hallway. Stephen
Riordan QC, defending Smith, asked her about Charlie.
The self-confessed alcoholic replied: "He was a gorgeous little
boy."
Mr Riordan asked her whether she had "wished any harm" on the
baby, to which Smith replied "never".
Smith, who had been barred from numerous pubs in Prestatyn for her
drunken behaviour, repeatedly denied making drunken threats to
burn peoples' houses down. She said: "I wouldn't have it in me. I
wouldn't do it anyway."
She said that on the night of the blaze she "was hysterical".
When she was outside she told jurors she had heard cries of "we
can't get them out".
The court has heard this month that Mr Timbrell said to paramedics
that "it was arson" and "it was Mel".
Smith denies five counts of murder. The trial continues tomorrow.
BBC.co.uk
April 22, 2013
A woman accused of killing five members of a
family offered to take a lie detector test to prove she was not a
murderer or arsonist.
Mold Crown Court heard Melanie Smith, 43, claim
she was in bed when a fire began which killed her neighbour
Lee-Anna Shiers, 20, nephew Bailey, four, and niece Skye, two, in
Prestatyn.
Ms Shiers' partner Liam Timbrell and
15-month-old son Charlie died later.
Ms Smith denies murder and threatening to burn
down another woman's home.
he prosecution claim that Ms Smith set fire to
a pushchair in a communal hall following arguments with Ms Shiers
who lived in the upstairs flat.
Giving evidence at the start of the third week
of her trial, Ms Smith denied making earlier threats to commit
arson, and repeatedly claimed that prosecution witnesses, who said
that she did, were lying.
In police interviews played to the court, Ms
Smith said: "I am not an arsonist and I am definitely not a
murderer.
"I definitely did not start the fire in the
flat. Give me a lie detector test. I will pass everything."
Ms Smith said she shared a takeaway meal with
her partner and went to bed. She told the court she had drunk 10
alcoholic drinks on the day of the fire.
Ms Smith claimed she heard the television in
the upstairs flat and her neighbours in bed.
The court heard Ms Smith was woken by thick
black smoke. She and her partner escaped through the bedroom
window.
In the police interviews Ms Smith told
detectives she was hysterical and was outside in her underwear and
was given a blanket to cover herself while her partner got onto a
flat roof at the back of the premises with other people to try to
help the family above escape.
She also denied previously shouting at Ms
Shiers in the street, allegedly saying she was going to "burn her
and the kids".
Ms Smith told police there had been differences
between the pair about the pushchair in the hall and rubbish left
outside but that they had made up and apologised to each other.
'Pointing the finger'
"Everyone is pointing the finger at me. On my
kids' lives I never did anything to that flat. That is from the
bottom of my heart. I would not do that to my worst enemy," she
said.
She also denied starting the fire just to scare
someone or through frustration, adding: "I have five children of
my own."
Ms Smith said she was alcohol dependent, but
did not drink every day.
She said she was a binge drinker, but she was
not in the middle of a binge when the fire took place, and that
she had drunk 10 alcoholic drinks during the day.
Ms Smith said she had no previous convictions
but she had been cautioned on one occasion. That was for stabbing
her partner with a fork when she said he rubbed crisps into her
hair and she thought he was going for her.
The court had previously heard that the fire
which ignited the pushchair had been deliberately started by
somebody holding a flame against it.
Ms Smith said the front door was never locked
and anyone could have walked into the hallway and done it.
She also denies a charge of making an earlier
threat to burn down the home of an alleged love rival, Samantha
Schofield.
The trial continues.
Prestatyn death trial told fire drove back
rescuers
BBC.co.uk
April 16, 2013
Neighbours who tried to rescue a family from a
house fire were driven back by heat and smoke, a murder trial
heard.
Lee-Anna Shiers, 20, her partner Liam Timbrell,
23, their 15-month-old son Charlie, and two of his cousins died in
the blaze in Prestatyn, Denbighshire.
An-ex police officer tried to get in via a rear
window and another neighbour opened the front door but both were
driven back, Mold Crown Court heard.
Melanie Smith, 42, who lived in the flat below
Ms Shiers, denies murder.
As well as Ms Shiers, her nephew Bailey, four,
and niece Skye, two, died in the blaze.
Former policeman Peter Bailey, a neighbour,
said in a statement read to the court that he was watching TV with
his wife on the evening of 19 October 2012.
He heard banging noises and his wife shouted
that the house over the road was on fire.
"I went outside and saw that the front door of
the house was well ablaze. There were loads of people in the
street with black acrid smoke pouring out of the house," he said.
The front door was "a ring of fire" with black
smoke billowing out, the court heard.
"The heat was intense with the fire raging, it
was well under way," he said.
Mr Bailey said that he ran round to the back of
the house and climbed onto a flat roof.
He climbed to the top of a ladder brought by a
neighbour with the intention of getting into the flat but as he
put his hand to the window he "felt the heat" coming from inside.
He said: "There was no way I could get in."
'Whoosh sound'
The jury heard from another neighbour Joe
Shelley who was on his way to meet friends when he heard woman's
voice shouting: "We cannot get out."
He said he opened the front door of the house
and was surprised how much fire there was there.
He said: "I thought of going to try and help
but, in the time I thought that, flames came towards the door and
spiralled upwards."
The flames made "a massive whoosh sound" as
they came out of the front door, he told the court.
The court heard Mr Shelley rang for the
emergency services and began to describe what he was seeing.
He said that after running home for a torch, he
had returned to the fire and saw a man inside the property saying
he could not get close to the window.
The jury then listened to a recording of his
999 call in which he told how people were unable to get break a
window to escape.
He was heard to say: "I don't think that they
will be able to breathe much longer."
Ms Smith denies five charges of murder and also
denies a charge of making an earlier threat to burn down the home
of Samantha Schofield.
The trial continues.
Prestatyn fire death trial: Melanie Smith
'made threat'
BBC.co.uk
April 11, 2013
A woman accused of starting a fire which killed
five members of a family had previously threatened to burn down
the home of a love rival, a jury heard.
Melanie Smith, 42, who lived in the flat below
the family in Prestatyn, Denbighshire, denies five murders.
Witness Samantha Schofield said she had been
warned that Ms Smith had threatened to burn her house down.
The prosecution at Mold Crown Court claims she
started the blaze in a row over a pushchair. The trial continues.
Lee-Anna Shiers, 20, her four-year-old nephew
Bailey and two-year-old niece Skye died in the blaze in Maes y
Groes, Prestatyn on 19 October.
Firefighters managed to rescue Ms Shiers'
15-month-old son Charlie and his father, Liam Timbrell, 23, from
their first-floor flat but they both later died in hospital.
The defendant wrongly believed that Miss
Schofield, the mother of two young boys, was having an affair with
her partner Steve Clarkson, Miss Schofield told the court.
She added: "The night of the fire, it shouldn't
have been that house, it should have been my home.
"People were telling me, my sister told me -
Mel said she was planning to burn my house down.
"But I didn't think she was capable of doing
it."
The prosecution has said Ms Smith deliberately
set fire to a pushchair because she was angry that Ms Shiers had
left it in a shared hallway.
The jury was previously told that the family
made desperate appeals for help while trapped in their first floor
flat.
Mr Timbrell made a 999 call in which he shouted
"help, help, someone has put it [the fire] on purpose, we're
inside the flat".
The court was told that one neighbour opened
the flat door and could see flames and the porch was thick with
smoke.
During Thursday's evidence, Miss Schofield said
that about six weeks before the fatal fire she had allowed Mr
Clarkson to stay at her home when he had temporarily split up with
the defendant.
She had got up one morning and found that his
car had been vandalised and matches were left around the vehicle.
Questioned by Ian Murphy QC, for the
prosecution, she said: "There were about 20 or 30 matches on the
driveway and some more matches still in the box.
Not reported
"Some were still live and others had been
burned.
"I left the matches on the ground but picked up
the box and put it in the bin."
Miss Schofield said she had not seen who did it
but later that day her sister, Amy, said Ms Smith had told her
"she planned to burn my house down".
Asked by Stephen Riordan QC, defending Ms
Smith, why she had not reported the matter to police, she said she
did not think she was capable of it.
Mr Riordan suggested Miss Schofield "hated" Ms
Smith for accusing her of having a relationship with Mr Clarkson.
"As soon as the fire happened, and you knew the
defendant had been arrested, you went to the police to make it
worse for her," he said.
Miss Schofield said: "No, I thought, 'Oh my
God', I went to the police because I wanted to help."
They jury had earlier visited Maes y Groes to
see the remains of the property.
They also heard evidence from the landlady of
the Royal Victoria pub in Prestatyn.
Norma Vaughan said that in 2008 Ms Smith, who
had been banned from the pub, returned and made an arson threat
when she was refused entry.
Prestatyn fire: Melanie Smith accused of
murdering five family members
BBC.co.uk
April 10, 2013
A neighbour has been accused of killing five
members of the same family by deliberately starting a fire in a
row over a pushchair.
Melanie Smith, 43, denies murdering the two
adults and three young children in the blaze at a flat in
Prestatyn, Denbighshire, last October.
The defendant set the fire deliberately due to
a dispute over where a pushchair was left, Mold Crown Court heard.
She was said to be jealous of Lee-Anna Shiers,
who lived in the flat above.
Ms Shiers, 20, her nephew Bailey, four, and
niece Skye, two, died at the scene. Her 15-month-old son Charlie
and partner Liam Timbrell, 23, were rescued but died later in
hospital.
The court heard how Ms Shiers' pushchair, left
in a shared hallway downstairs, had annoyed Ms Smith.
On the night of 19 October last year, the
pushchair was set on fire deliberately with a naked flame, the
court heard.
The jury was told that the family made
desperate appeals for help while trapped in their first floor
flat.
Mr Timbrell made a 999 call in which he shouted
"help, help, someone has put it [the fire] on purpose, we're
inside the flat".
Neighbour Joe Shelley made a 999 call when he
heard a voice, which he believed was that of a woman, saying "we
can't get out".
Prosecuting barrister Ian Murphy QC said that
Mr Shelley opened the flat door and could see flames 2-3ft
(0.6-0.9m) high and the porch was thick with smoke.
He stepped back as he heard a 'whoosh' sound
and the flames came towards him, pushing him back.
In Mr Shelley's 999 call, the sound of Mr
Timbrell fruitlessly trying to smash the window from the inside
could be heard in the background.
He could be heard to shout: "Oh my God, oh my
God, we're going to die".
Ms Shiers also called her father on her mobile
phone and said: "Dad, there's a fire downstairs. I can't get out."
The court was told he and his wife drove to the
house to find the front porch door "blazing in flames".
The defendant's partner Steve Clarkson was seen
climbing out through the rear ground floor window yelling:
"There's kids upstairs, get the kids."
Ms Smith was seen on the far side of the road
with a blanket around her.
Mr Clarkson asked her how many children were
there and she replied: "How the f*** do I know? She has everyone
up there."
The jury was told that firefighters used a
ladder and a small axe to break a window in the upstairs flat to
rescue Mr Timbrell.
They also found Ms Shiers and the children in a
bedroom, handing care of them to the ambulance service.
Threats
After he was rescued, Mr Timbrell insisted that
Ms Smith was responsible for the fire.
He asked one neighbour if the babies were ok
and said that the electricity went off as he was at the window
trying to call 999. The family were plunged into darkness.
He told the neighbour: "I heard a woman
shouting in the street 'I am going to set fire to your house'. It
was Mel, she said I am going to burn the house down."
He also told a paramedic "It was arson, she did
it, Mel did it" two or three times.
A police community support officer spoke to him
and Mr Timbrell said: "She was shouting through the letter box 'I
am going to burn your house down'."
Asked if he recognised the voice, Mr Timbrell
said: "Yes, it was Mel from the downstairs flat."
The prosecution said Ms Smith had been drinking
heavily that day and had been angry and hostile towards Ms Shiers
over the previous two months.
Mr Murphy alleged that on a number of occasions
Ms Smith had made threats that she would "set your house on fire
with you and [your] kids in it".
It was claimed she was particularly angry with
Ms Shiers' habit of leaving the pushchair in the hall, being noisy
in her flat and being untidy, such as leaving cigarette ends
around the front door area.
He also said that Ms Smith appeared jealous of
Ms Shiers and had accused her partner of having a sexual
relationship with her.
Mr Murphy told the jury of five men and seven
women that it was an allegation for which there seemed to be no
basis at all.
Ms Smith denies five counts of murder and one
charge of making a threat to destroy or damage property by
threatening to burn down a house in September.