Two Decades in Solitary
By John Eligon - The New York Times
September 22, 2008
He is one of New York’s most isolated prisoners, spending 23 hours a
day for the past two decades in a 9-by-6-foot cell. The only
trimmings are a cot and a sink-toilet combination. His visitors —
few as they are — must wedge into a nook outside his cell and speak
to him through a 1-by-3-foot window of foggy plexiglass and iron
bars.
In this static existence, Willie Bosket, 45, seems
to have gone from defiant menace to subdued and empty inmate.
It was 30 years ago this month that a state law
took effect allowing juveniles to be tried as adults, largely in
response to Mr. Bosket’s slaying of two people on a New York subway
when he was 15. He served only five years in jail for that crime
because he was a juvenile, sparking public outrage. But shortly after
completing his sentence, Mr. Bosket was arrested for assaulting a 72-year-old
man.
He once claimed to be at “war” with prison
officials. He said he laughed at the system and claimed to have
committed more than 2,000 crimes as a child. He set fire to his cell
and attacked guards. Mr. Bosket was sentenced to 25 years to life for
stabbing a guard in the visitors’ room in 1988, along with other
offenses, leading prison authorities to make him virtually the most
restricted inmate in the state.
Now Mr. Bosket, who has gone 14 years without a
disciplinary violation, does mainly three things: read, sleep and
think.
“Just blank” is how Mr. Bosket described his
existence during a recent interview at Woodbourne Correctional
Facility, about 75 miles north of Manhattan. “Everything is the same
every day. This is hell. Always has been.”
He is scheduled to remain isolated from the general
prison population until 2046.
Mr. Bosket’s seclusion is part of a bigger debate
over the confinement of troublesome inmates and the role of the prison
system. Some say that Mr. Bosket’s level of seclusion is draconian,
that he should be given an opportunity to rejoin the general
population.
“He is a very dangerous person; he’s killed people,”
said Jo Allison Henn, a lawyer who helped represent Mr. Bosket roughly
20 years ago when he fought unsuccessfully to have some of his
restrictions removed. “I’m not saying he should be released from
custody entirely, just the custody that he is in. It is beyond
inhumane. I don’t think that too many civilized countries do that.”
But proponents of Mr. Bosket’s restrictions say he
has proved to be something of an incorrigible danger to prison guards
and other inmates and cannot be trusted in the general population. He
is evaluated periodically, meaning he could rejoin the general prison
population before 2046, said Erik Kriss, a spokesman for the State
Department of Correctional Services.
“This guy was violent or threatening violence
practically every day,” Mr. Kriss said. “Granted, it has been a while,
but there are consequences for being violent in prison. We have zero
tolerance for that.”
From 1985 to 1994, Mr. Bosket was written up nearly
250 times for disciplinary violations that included spitting on guards,
throwing food and swallowing the handle of a spoon, according to
prison reports.
Few, if any, of the state’s current inmates have
been in disciplinary housing longer than Mr. Bosket, said Linda Foglia,
a spokeswoman for the corrections department.
Mr. Bosket says he wakes up at 7:15 every morning
and gets a visit from a counselor at 8. At 9, he gets his first of
three doses of medication for asthma and high cholesterol, he said.
Lunch comes at 11:30, followed by more medication at 1 p.m. and 5 p.m.
He is entitled to three showers a week. Other than
one hour of recreation a day, also solitary, he may leave his cell
only for medical visits and haircuts. The recreation area measures 34
feet by 17 feet, surrounded by nearly 9-foot-high walls with bars on
the top. Mr. Bosket said he was chained to a door during his
recreation time and could not walk more than six feet, but corrections
officials disputed that account, saying he was allowed to roam freely
during his hour like other inmates.
And while other prisoners in isolation are escorted
to a visiting room when they have guests, he must stay in his cell,
speaking through the plexiglass.
Most of his waking hours, he said, are spent
reading books, magazines, newspapers and anything else he can get his
hands on. His favorite magazine, he said, was Elle.
“It’s very colorful,” he said. “It keeps me up to
date on technology and the world.”
Mr. Bosket has long been known as a paradox, a man
of charm and extraordinary intelligence but also of inexplicable fits
of rage.
“It was like a terrifying metamorphosis when this
spark within him went off, and you could see the rage in him building,”
said Robert Silbering, a former prosecutor who tried Mr. Bosket for
the subway murders. “I never have seen anything like that before or
afterward.”
The killings led Gov. Hugh L. Carey to sign a law
allowing people as young as 13 to be tried as adults for murder. Mr.
Bosket said he saw it as something of an honor that he could
drastically change a justice system that he said made him a “monster.”
“If I’m the perfect example, then I’ve been taught
well,” he said.
At the sight of a recent visitor, Mr. Bosket
cheerfully nodded and, revealing a small gap between his front teeth,
gave a friendly, “Hi, how’s it going?”
He spoke with the aura of a professor, using
deliberate gestures and emphasizing the ends of many words. He often
spoke in metaphors and used stories and quotations to explain his
philosophies.
As he contemplated his words, Mr. Bosket often
folded his right arm across his bulging stomach and lay the fingers of
his left hand across his mouth and nose. He sometimes rocked in his
chair.
Despite his bleak situation, Mr. Bosket refused to
concede defeat: “I’m not broken down and never will be.”
His life has always been empty, he said.
“I grew up with nothing,” he said. “I was born with
nothing. I still have nothing. I will never have nothing. Forty-five
years of living the way I have lived, I like ‘nothing.’ No one can
take ‘nothing’ from you.”
Mr. Bosket, who has spent all but two years in some
form of lockup since he was 9, also said he had formed a “breastplate”
from a lifetime of incarceration.
“I’ve become so callous to the poking of the sword
that, literally, instead of bleeding to death, the blood was drained
and I became absent of concern, void of emotions, cold — plain cold to
the degree that not much affects me anymore,” he said.
Yet Mr. Bosket did hint at something of a life of
suffering.
“If somebody came to me with a lethal injection,
I’d take it,” he said. “I’d rather be dead.”
His change from vicious to quiescent, Mr. Bosket
said, was a calculated move. Growing up in Harlem, Mr. Bosket said,
his heroes were revolutionaries like Huey Newton and Assata Shakur. He
said he believed blacks needed to use violence to survive in the 1970s
and ’80s.
But in 1994, he said, he sensed a change in society.
“Blacks don’t need to go and attack to get their message across,” he
recalled thinking.
He said that he also wanted young people to see
positive in his life, and that continued violence could be
counterproductive.
“I don’t believe at this point it’s strategic for
me to be aggressive or violent,” he said. “I’ve made my point.”
“I’m not proud of a lot of the things I’ve done,”
he added.
Mr. Bosket’s sister, Cheryl Stewart, 51, said her
brother had expressed remorse in letters.
“What was done was wrong, and if he could redo it,
he wouldn’t do it again,” she said. “He knows what was done was wrong
and is just sorry for what all has went down.”
Though she corresponds with her brother, Ms.
Stewart said she had not visited him in 23 years because it was
difficult to see him so confined. Mr. Bosket is lucky to receive more
than two visits a year.
Adam Mesinger, a television and movie producer,
said he had visited Mr. Bosket seven times over the past four years
and is shopping a script for a movie about Mr. Bosket’s life. He said
that Mr. Bosket had always been warm and open with him and that he
would consider him a friend.
“I have no fear of him,” Mr. Mesinger said. “I
don’t think he would ever harm me. I don’t think he ever really wants
to harm anybody.”
But not even Mr. Bosket would say that his days of
violence are behind him.
“When you’re in hell,” he said, “you can’t predict
the future.”
I Won't Kill, I'll Just Maim
By Richard Behar - Time.com
Monday, May. 29, 1989
Once he has been locked up, a homicidal maniac has
limited opportunities. He can spend the rest of his life in prison, or
he can be put to death by the state. But Willie Bosket Jr. is not your
everyday homicidal maniac. A self- described "monster," he is
intelligent, well read and sophisticated. At least three books are
being planned to memorialize his life story. He has at his disposal a
"spokeswoman" to handle inquires from the media and Hollywood. He is
only 26 years old, and in the view of many people he is the best
possible argument for instituting capital punishment in New York State,
which currently lacks the death penalty.
He is also the most burdensome inmate of the
state's prison system. For him alone authorities have built a special
dungeon at the upstate Woodbourne Correctional Facility, where Bosket
is scheduled to spend the next 31 years in solitary confinement. (For
the remainder of his life, if he behaves himself and stops assaulting
his guards and quits hurling feces and food at them, he may be moved
into more conventional quarters.) His room is lined with Plexiglas,
and three video cameras track him constantly. He is so prone to commit
mayhem that when a visitor calls, Bosket is chained backward to the
inside of his cell door. When the door is swung open, there is Bosket,
pinned to the bars like a specimen in a bug collection.
What did Bosket do to deserve such barbarous
treatment? Plenty. He was 15 when he shot to death two New York City
subway riders (BABY-FACED BUTCHER! cried the headlines). In the eleven
years since then, he tried, while briefly out of prison, to rob and
knife a 72-year-old half-blind man. He has also stabbed a prison guard,
smashed a lead pipe into another guard's skull, set his cell on fire
seven times, choked a secretary, battered a reformatory teacher with a
nail-studded club, tried to blow up a truck, sodomized inmates, beat
up a psychiatrist and mailed a death threat to Ronald Reagan. Bosket
claims to have committed 2,000 crimes by the time he was 15.
To a visitor, Bosket plays the cunning Mr. Charm.
He is handsome, slightly built at 5 ft. 9 in. and 150 lbs., articulate
and witty. He has 200 books in his cell and converses easily about the
works of Dostoyevsky and B.F. Skinner. "I'm really a loving and caring
person," he protests. "I hunger for knowledge. My pain and suffering
have stroked my ability to be intellectual. If the system wasn't so
quick to incarcerate me as a child, I could have become a well-known
attorney. I could have been a Senator."
Instead, he says, he is a "political prisoner"
embarked on a "revolutionary struggle" aimed at killing anyone who
represents oppression. In New York, one of the few states that still
prohibit capital punishment, legislators are yet again debating the
death penalty. The monster is unimpressed. "Willie Bosket is gonna
keep striking," he says. "If they / bring back the death penalty, I
won't kill. I'll just maim. I want to live every day I can just to
make them regret what they've done to me."
What "they" did to him began, he says, when he was
a boy, the product of a broken home in New York City's Harlem. By nine,
he was a chronic and violent troublemaker. When he was given mental
tests, he threatened to set fire to the hospital ward and kill a
doctor. The tests showed that Bosket was suffering from a severe
antisocial personality disorder. His helpless mother had him sent to a
reform school, where he began to emulate his father.
Bosket never met his father, but the parallels
between the two men are dramatic. Each had only a third-grade
education, was sentenced to the same reform school at nine, went on to
commit double murders, and displayed a superior intelligence. The
father's goals, however, were different: he studied hard and became
the first convict in history to be inducted into the Phi Beta Kappa
honor society. After his release from prison in 1983, Bosket Sr. found
work as a university teaching assistant.
His rehabilitation was short-lived. In 1985 he was
arrested for molesting a six-year-old child. Later, after a shoot-out
with police during an escape attempt, Bosket Sr. shot and killed his
girlfriend and then blew his brains to pieces. This has given Bosket
Jr. food for reflection. "I can say with all conviction that genetics
has played a role in what I am. But what I learned from my father's
life was never to conform to the system, never to forgive, as he did."
The "system," he adds, became his "surrogate mother."
Bosket has now filed a suit against his surrogate
mother, charging cruel and unusual punishment at Woodbourne. He is
also angry because the authorities have ignored an eight-page
handwritten letter in which Bosket volunteered himself for study as a
way to help prevent future Boskets. "It's all just theater to Willie,
and we try not to give him a stage," says Thomas Coughlin III, New
York's commissioner of correctional services.
But Bosket still finds ways to attract attention.
While en route to court last month, he kicked a guard who was removing
a leg manacle and then shouted to photographers, "Did you get that
picture? Did you get that on film?" That act was reminiscent of the
time last year when Bosket plunged a makeshift 11- in. knife into the
chest of a guard, in full view of a newspaper reporter Bosket had
enlisted to write his life story. The guard was critically injured but
recovered. "Sensationalism sells newspapers," the baby-faced butcher
blithely explains, "and the system responds to violence."