Murderpedia has thousands of hours of work behind it. To keep creating
new content, we kindly appreciate any donation you can give to help
the Murderpedia project stay alive. We have many
plans and enthusiasm
to keep expanding and making Murderpedia a better site, but we really
need your help for this. Thank you very much in advance.
Roger Coleman, her brother-in-law, had access to
the house and immediately became a suspect. Coleman had a prior
conviction for Attempted Rape. Coleman, who worked in a mine, had
reported to work that night but had left when his shift was
dismissed.
The victim had broken fingernails, cuts on the
hands, and a dark, dusty substance on her body. The autopsy report
recorded wounds to her chest and throat with a knife. Initial and
subsequent DNA testing connected Coleman to the crime scene.
Coleman consistently maintained his innocence,
convincing Time Magazine to run a cover story days before his
execution. Coleman took and failed a polygraph test administered by
the State shortly before his execution.
Coleman's case drew international attention as
the well-spoken inmate pleaded his case on talk shows and in
magazines and newspapers. Time magazine featured the coal miner on
its cover. Pope John Paul II tried to block the execution. Then-Gov.
L. Douglas Wilder's office was flooded with thousands of calls and
letters of protest from around the world.
Coleman's attorneys argued that he did not have
time to commit the crime, that tests showed semen from two men was
found inside McCoy and that another man bragged about murdering her.
"An innocent man is going to be murdered tonight," the 33-year-old
said moments before he was electrocuted on May 20, 1992. "When my
innocence is proven, I hope America will realize the injustice of
the death penalty as all other civilized countries have."
A former prosecutor in the case said the results,
while not surprising, were a relief. "Quite frankly, I feel like the
weight of the world has been lifted off of my shoulders," Grundy
attorney Tom Scott said. "You can imagine, had it turned out
differently, (the other prosecutor) and I certainly would have been
scapegoats."
Prosecutors said a mountain of other evidence
pointed to Coleman as the killer: There was no sign of forced entry
at McCoy's house, leading investigators to believe she knew her
attacker; Coleman was previously convicted of the attempted rape of
a teacher and was charged with exposing himself to a librarian two
months before the murder; a pubic hair found on McCoy's body was
consistent with Coleman's hair; and the original DNA tests placed
him within a fraction of the population who could have left semen at
the scene.
Four newspapers and Centurion Ministries, a New
Jersey organization that investigated Coleman's case and became
convinced of his innocence, sought a court order to have the
evidence retested. The Virginia Supreme Court declined to order the
testing in 2002, so Centurion Ministries asked Warner to intervene.
James McCloskey, executive director of Centurion
Ministries, had been fighting to prove Coleman's innocence since
1988. The two shared Coleman's final meal together cold slices of
pizza just a few hours before Coleman was executed. I now know that
I was wrong. Indeed, this is a bitter pill to swallow," McCloskey
said, describing Thursday's findings as "a kick in the stomach" and
adding that he felt betrayed by Coleman.
Death penalty proponents welcomed the results.
"Stop the presses it turns out that rapists and killers are also
liars," Michael Paranzino, president of a group called Throw Away
the Key, said in a statement.
Death penalty opponents praised
Warner's decision to order the testing but warned that Coleman's
case does not mean the death penalty is infallible. "Obviously, one
case does not in any way reflect on the correctness of the other
1,000 executions we've had in the last 30 years," said Peter Neufeld,
co-founder of the Innocence Project. "Other governors should take
their lead from Governor Warner and do post-execution testing in
their cases, because … there's no reason not to it's all about
getting to the truth."
Associated Press writers Sue Lindsey in Roanoke
and Michael Felberbaum and Zinie Chen Sampson in Richmond
contributed to this report.
Wikipedia.org
Last
Statement:
"An
innocent man is going to be murdered tonight. When my innocence is
proven, I hope Americans will realize the injustice of the death
penalty as all other civilized countries have."
— Roger Keith Coleman, executed in Virginia on May 20, 1992
Gone, but not Forgotten
It’s been 13 years since the
State of Virginia executed Roger Coleman for the rape and murder of
his sister-in-law, but he’s still the darling of the anti-death
penalty faction because they’re convinced he was innocent.
Virginia has successfully
fended off media attempts to pay for DNA testing that might
establish once-and-for-all whether or not he had anything to do with
sexually assaulting and killing Wanda Faye Thompson McCoy.
“DNA testing is without a
doubt a very powerful tool, but it is a tool for the living,” said a
spokesman for the state Attorney General, after a group of
newspapers pressed the former Virginia governor to allow the
testing. “Roger Coleman was and is guilty of the rape and murder of
Wanda McCoy. All the repeated histrionics by various lawyers won’t
change that.”
Hours before he died in the
electric chair, Coleman failed a polygraph exam, but some of his
supporters point out that the timing and stakes involved might have
rendered the test meaningless.
His case had been appealed and
argued all the way to the United States Supreme Court. In all, the
case was reviewed 12 times in litigation.
In typical media
oversimplification, the press pointed out the state’s “rush to
judgment” despite the fact that it took 11 years for Coleman’s
appeals to work their way through the system.
Bradley D. McCoy, 21, and his
wife, Wanda Fay McCoy, 19, lived outside Grundy, Virginia in a
rented house. They had no children. Wanda was not employed; her
husband was a parts clerk for United Coal Company, working the
second shift from 3:00 p.m. to 11:00 p.m. On March 10, 1981, at 2:15
p.m., McCoy went to work, leaving Wanda at home alone.
McCoy testified that about
9:00 p.m. he telephoned Wanda “to see if she was okay.”
At the end of his shift, McCoy
arrived home about 11:15 p.m. Entering his home, he saw that the
coffee table had been moved, there were “slight drips of blood on
the floor,” and the light and the television were on. Going to the
back bedroom, where a light was on, he found his wife lying on her
back on the floor. Her hair was pulled over her face, she had a
wound in her chest, and there was blood beside her head. Her arms
were stretched behind her head and her legs were lying straight out
and apart.
Coleman’s wife was Wanda’s
younger sister and the Colemans lived in the home of Coleman’s
grandmother, which was a five-minute walk from the McCoy house.
Dr. Thomas D. McDonald, the
medical examiner, made a superficial examination of Wanda, confirmed
that she was dead, but did not move her pending the arrival of a
State Police special investigating unit. She had a large cut to her
neck and two puncture wounds in her chest. Dr. McDonald determined
that the cause of death was the “slashing wound to the throat.” The
body was still warm, rigor mortis had not set in, and Dr. McDonald
estimated that Wanda had died about 10:30 p.m., or within 30 minutes
before or after that time.
At daybreak, police measured
the depth of Slate Creek, located 75 to 100 yards from the McCoy
house, at 10 to 12 inches. The creek depth is important because the
clothes Coleman wore that night indicate he waded through that
particular creek.
The pathologist who conducted
the autopsy found two foreign hairs in the victim’s genital area. He
submitted these samples of her pubic hairs, blood, swabs from her
mouth, hands, vagina, and rectum, and her underwear to the state
crime lab.
Coleman was a coal miner. The
statement he gave to police was exculpatory, purporting to account
in detail for his time on the night of the killing. He said he left
his home at 8:30 p.m., left a local convenience store at 9:05 p.m.,
went to work when he learned that his shift at the mine had been
terminated, and arrived at 10:50 p.m. at a bathhouse in town where
he took a shower and changed his clothes before returning home.
Coleman agreed to supply
samples of his blood, head hairs, pubic hairs, and saliva. These
were taken to the Bureau of Forensic Science.
Elmer Gist, Jr., a forensic
serologist employed by the Commonwealth of Virginia Bureau of
Forensic Science, testified that he made an analysis of the items
delivered to him. He said the two apparently foreign hairs found in
Wanda’s pubic area were, in fact, not those of the victim but were
consistent with pubic hair samples taken from Coleman. Gist
concluded that these two hairs came either from Coleman or, by a
possible but unlikely coincidence, from some other person of the
same race whose hair had the same color, diameter, general
configuration, and microscopic characteristics.
Coleman was a secretor, one
whose “blood type factor” is present “in semen, saliva or other body
fluids,” but 80 percent of the population are secretors. Coleman had
Type B blood, a rare type possessed by only 10 percent of the
population. Wanda’s blood was type O, a type which 40 percent to 45
percent of the population have; her husband’s was Type A.
From Gist’s examination of the
vaginal specimen taken from the victim’s body he found that semen
had been deposited in her vagina by a secretor with Type B blood. He
also determined that a bloodstain on Coleman’s blue jeans was made
by Type O human blood. Gist found blood on one of Coleman’s knives
but not in sufficient quantity to enable him to determine whether it
was human or animal blood. According to Gist, Coleman’s blue jeans
were wet from the bottom of the legs to a height of about 12 inches.
They were dirty and had “blackish stains on the upper legs in
particular.” Photographs of the victim depicted a very dark, fine
substance on her hands.
There was a jailhouse snitch
who testified, as well.
Roger L. Matney, a convicted
felon, testified that when he had been incarcerated in the same cell
block with Coleman in the county jail, Coleman had described for him
the killing and rape. According to Matney, Coleman drew a diagram of
the McCoy house and said he and another man were in the house and
after the victim’s husband called her about 9:00 p.m., Coleman’s
companion cut her and she began to scream.
Coleman told Matney the two
men took the victim to the bedroom and both raped her. The knife
“was supposed” to have been hidden under Black Watch Bridge. Coleman
began to say something about a paper towel when the conversation
ended. (Other evidence of the Commonwealth showed that a paper towel
was found near the victim ’s body).
Elmer T. Miller, a forensic
scientist, testifying for the defense, said that from his
examination of swabs received from Dr. Oxley he determined that the
very dark, fine substance found on the victim’s hands was soil and
particles of plant material, not coal dust.
Shortly before 11:00 p.m. on
March 18, 1982, the jury found Coleman guilty of capital murder.
Brenda R., 36, testified as a
witness for the Commonwealth during the penalty phase. She described
an attempted rape committed by Coleman on April 7, 1977.
Coleman, whom she had never
seen before, was admitted to the house when he asked for a drink of
water. After some conversation, Coleman pulled a gun and forced her
to tape her daughter’s hands and feet and place her in a child’s
rocking chair. Coleman then walked Mrs. R. at gunpoint upstairs to
the bedroom where he ordered her to undress. Seizing an opportunity
to escape when Coleman went for his gun, Mrs. R. ran downstairs,
picked up her daughter, and fled from the house and screamed for
help. As neighbors came to the rescue, Coleman ran away. The entire
episode lasted approximately ten minutes, according to Mrs. R. and
throughout this time Coleman “never really raised his voice,” which
she described as “[v]ery cold.” She recalled, “It was just like, do
it or die.”
For that crime, he was
sentenced to serve three years in the State penitentiary.
Coleman’s appeals in state
court went nowhere, and his federal appeals were just as
unsuccessful.
Under Chief Justice William H.
Rehnquist, the Supreme Court put strict new limits on the ability of
state inmates to present habeas corpus petitions in federal court.
Coleman’s case itself helped
Rehnquist in his quest to speed the process. On a 6-3 vote in the
case of Coleman vs. Thompson, the high court said that if a defense
lawyer errs in a state court — in this instance, by filing a late
appeal — the inmate may not get a further hearing in the federal
courts.
Because of that ruling,
federal judges were under no obligation to grant Coleman a hearing
on the “newly revealed evidence.”
The so-called new evidence was
a DNA test that put Coleman in a group of less than 0.2 percent
population that could have committed the crime. The defense claimed
the test was misinterpreted.
However, a week before
Coleman’s execution, U.S. District Judge Glen W. Williams said that
the new evidence did not convince him that Coleman was not guilty.
Shortly before he was
executed, Time Magazine put him on its cover and the Washington Post
argued that he would be executed because he was “too poor to hire a
good lawyer.”
Was Coleman innocent? A dozen
of his peers believed beyond a reasonable doubt that he was not. The
justice system reviewed his conviction over and over and found that
his arrest, trial, conviction, and sentence were within the bounds
of the U.S. Constitution.
There’s absolutely nothing
wrong with opposing the death penalty and wanting to change the law.
The problem is relying on half-truths and mistaken assumptions to
point out the unfairness of the system. Anti-capital punishment
forces could do a lot better than Roger Coleman if they need a
poster child.
MarkGribben.com
At the end of his shift, McCoy drove home in his
car, arriving about 11:15 p.m. Although Wanda usually left the porch
light on for him, no outside lights were shining when he knocked on
the door; Wanda usually kept both the storm door and the wooden
front door locked. Receiving no answer, McCoy opened the storm door,
which was unlocked, then opened the front door with his key, and
entered the living room. He saw that the coffee table had been
moved, there were "slight drips of blood on the floor," and the
light and the television were on.
He called for Wanda but heard nothing. Going to
the back bedroom, where a light was on, he found his wife lying on
her back on the floor. Her hair was pulled over her face, she had a
wound in her chest, and there was blood beside her head. Her arms
were stretched behind her head and her legs were lying straight out
and apart. She appeared to be dead; McCoy did not touch her. He
found no signs of forced entry into the house.
McCoy telephoned his father, Max McCoy, known as
Hezzie, who lived 400 to 500 yards away, and told him that Wanda had
been killed. McCoy turned on the porch light, initially waited for
his father, but after a few minutes ran to meet him. After Hezzie
called the sheriff's office at 11:21 p.m., McCoy and his father
returned to McCoy's house, looked at the body but did not touch it,
and met the police officers who began to arrive.
McCoy said that Coleman's wife was a younger
sister of Wanda's, that the Colemans lived in the home of Coleman's
grandmother, which was a five-minute walk from the McCoy house, and
that on the night before Wanda's death the Colemans stopped by the
McCoys' but only Coleman's wife came into the house. Sergeant Steven
D. Coleman, of the Buchanan County Sheriff's Department, arrived
about 11:25 p.m. accompanied by another officer. He tried to check
Wanda's neck for a pulse but found it "so badly torn up" that he
could not do so. There was a large gaping hole in the front of her
neck; a pool of blood was around her head.
Other local and state law enforcement officers
promptly came to the McCoy house to assist in the investigation.
Randall S. Jackson, Chief of Police for the Town of Grundy, arrived
about 11:27 p.m. He observed what appeared to be bloodstains on the
floor and wall of the living room, and "tracks of blood, where
something had been dragged" through the hallway and into the bedroom
in which he found Wanda's body. Jackson felt her wrist, which was "very
warm," but found no pulse. He sent an officer for Dr. Thomas D.
McDonald, the medical examiner, and arranged to secure the premises.
At daybreak, Jackson measured the depth of Slate Creek, located 75
to 100 yards from the McCoy house, at 10 to 12 inches.
Dr. McDonald, who lived nearby, arrived at 11:35
p.m. He made a superficial examination of Wanda, confirmed that she
was dead, but did not move her pending the arrival of a State Police
special investigating unit. Wanda was lying on her back, partially
clothed, with her panties around her left ankle, arms over her head,
and legs extended. She had a large laceration of the neck and two
puncture wounds in her chest. Dr. McDonald determined that the cause
of death was the "slashing wound to the throat." The body was still
warm, rigor mortis had not set in, and Dr. McDonald estimated that
Wanda had died about 10:30 p.m., or within 30 minutes before or
after that time.
A neighbor testified that when she took the trash
out of her house about 10:30 p.m. she saw the porch light burning at
the McCoy residence. The Commonwealth offered color photographs
showing the scene of the crime and different views of the victim's
body. Over Coleman's objection, the trial court admitted 14 of the
photographs after excluding two as repetitious and one as
inflammatory.
The victim's body was removed to Roanoke where
Dr. David W. Oxley performed an autopsy on March 12. Dr. Oxley
testified that death was caused by a "slash wound" of the throat
with cutting of the "right carotid artery, jugular vein and larynx."
He also found two stab wounds in the chest. One, measuring 1 1/4
inch by 1/16 inch, with a depth of 4 inches, had penetrated the
heart and lung. Because there was little or no hemorrhaging from
this wound Dr. Oxley concluded it had been inflicted after death.
The other, measuring 1 3/4 inch by 1/16 inch, also with a depth of 4
inches, had penetrated the liver; Dr. Oxley was of opinion that this
wound was inflicted after death or close to the time of death.
He described the neck wound as a single cut, two
to three inches in depth without "hesitation marks," leading from
the right side of the neck to the left and downward. Dr. Oxley found
two foreign hairs in the victim's genital area. He submitted these,
samples of her pubic hairs, blood, swabs from her mouth, hands,
vagina, and rectum, and the panties found wrapped around her left
foot, to Elmer Gist, Jr., a forensic scientist.
Out of the presence of the jury, the trial court
conducted a hearing on the admissibility of statements made by
Coleman on March 11 and 12 to Jack E. Davidson, Special Agent with
the Virginia State Police, one of the investigating officers.
Davidson testified there were several suspects, including Coleman,
whose activities police were "exploring at that particular time." He
and another officer went to Coleman's grandmother's residence on
March 11 and asked Coleman "if it was all right, if he could talk to
us." According to Davidson, Coleman said "sure," and the interview
was conducted, beginning at 12:32 p.m., as the two sat in Davidson's
car; the other officer remained at the house.
Davidson explained that he did not give Coleman
Miranda warnings because the suspect was "not in an accusatory
status" but was "in an investigative status." Davidson said Coleman
was not under arrest and was free to go at any time. The officer was
unable to record his interview because of a malfunction of the
equipment, but he made notes of Coleman's statement. Coleman was a
coal miner, employed by T J and M Coal Company.
His statement was exculpatory, purporting to
account in detail for his time on the night of the killing. Thus, he
said he left his home at 8:30 p.m., left the Speedy Market at 9:05
p.m., went to other listed places at specified times before and
after finding that his shift at the mine had been terminated, and
arrived at 10:50 p.m. at the bathhouse in town where he took a
shower and changed his clothes before returning home. When Davidson
asked Coleman for the clothes he wore that night, Coleman turned
over to him a plastic bag of clothing and a knife. In the bag was a
pair of dirty blue jeans; the bottom 10 to 12 inches of each pants
leg were wet. Davidson had the clothing delivered to the Bureau of
Forensic Science in Roanoke.
On March 12, Davidson interviewed Coleman again.
Davidson testified that Coleman was still a suspect, but was free to
leave if he wished to do so, and was not given Miranda warnings.
Davidson told Coleman that he had investigated the mine site and
found there was no water there to get his blue jeans wet. Coleman
then said when he took a shower at the bathhouse, he probably laid
his blue jeans down and water from the shower got them wet.
Subsequently, Coleman relinquished another knife to Davidson.
Coleman was arrested on April 13. Over Coleman's
objection, the trial court ruled the statements of March 11 and 12
were admissible because Coleman gave them when he was neither under
arrest nor in a "custodial interrogation situation" but instead was
free to leave; Miranda warnings, therefore, were not required. A
portion of one of the statements relating to polygraph examinations
was excluded.
On March 13, Davidson testified, he met Coleman "at
his in-laws' residence" and asked if he would consent to a search
for body fluids and hair. Davidson said Coleman agreed and, after
being informed of his constitutional right to insist upon a search
warrant, signed a consent authorizing a warrantless search of his
body. The consent permitted removal of any property "or body fluids."
Davidson testified that Coleman also consented to
have samples of body hair taken. Over Coleman's objection, the trial
court ruled, on the basis of Davidson's uncontradicted testimony,
that Coleman had consented to a search of his body and that all
items taken in the search would be admissible. Davidson stated that
samples of Coleman's blood, head hairs, pubic hairs, and saliva were
taken and mailed to the Bureau of Forensic Science.
Elmer Gist, Jr., a forensic serologist employed
by the Commonwealth of Virginia Bureau of Forensic Science,
testified that he made an analysis of the items delivered to him by
Dr. Oxley and the investigating officers. He said the two apparently
foreign hairs found in Wanda's pubic area were, in fact, not those
of the victim but were consistent with pubic hair samples taken from
Coleman.
Gist concluded that these two hairs came either
from Coleman or, by a possible but unlikely coincidence, from some
other person of the same race whose hair had the same color,
diameter, general configuration, and microscopic characteristics.
Gist testified that Coleman was a secretor, one whose "blood type
factor" is present "in semen, saliva or other body fluids," and that
80% to 85% of the population are secretors. Gist determined that
Coleman had Type B blood, a rare type possessed by only 10% of the
population. Wanda's blood was Type O, a type which 40% to 45% of the
population have; her husband's was Type A.
From Gist's examination of the vaginal specimen
taken from the victim's body he found that spermatozoa had been
deposited in her vagina by a secretor with Type B blood. He also
determined that a bloodstain on Coleman's blue jeans was made by
Type O human blood. Gist found blood on one of Coleman's knives but
not in sufficient quantity to enable him to determine whether it was
human or animal blood. According to Gist, Coleman's blue jeans were
dirty and had "blackish stains on the upper legs in particular."
Photographs of the victim depicted a very dark, fine substance on
her hands. Charles Crabtree, owner of the Speedy Market, testified
that Coleman came into his store on March 10 about 8:00 p.m. and
stayed about ten minutes.
Gary Scott Stiltner testified that on March 10 he
was scheduled to work his regular 3:30 to 11:30 shift but had not
gone to work. About 10:15 or 10:20 p.m. Coleman came to his trailer
in Boyd's Trailer Park, where he and his wife, Sandra, and infant
daughter lived, and asked for the return of a tape which Stiltner's
wife had borrowed. Upon receiving the tape, Coleman departed. Sandra
K. Stiltner recounted an incident that occurred on Friday, March 6.
Shortly after her husband went to work that
afternoon, Coleman stopped by her trailer and discussed tapes with
her and a neighbor. During a brief interval when they were alone,
Coleman asked her what she liked to drink and offered to get her
whatever she wanted, but she declined and left to join other
neighbors. Sandra Stiltner also testified that when Coleman stopped
by for his tape on March 10 she glanced at a clock and noticed that
it was 10:20 p.m.
Roger L. Matney, a convicted felon, testified
that when he had been incarcerated in the same cell block with
Coleman in the county jail, Coleman had described for him the
killing and rape of the victim. According to this witness, Coleman
drew on a newspaper a diagram of the McCoy house and said he and
another man were in the house and after the victim's husband called
her about 9:00 p.m., Coleman's companion cut her and she began to
scream.
Matney believed Coleman said the other man was "Danny
Ray." Coleman told Matney the two men took the victim to the bedroom
and both raped her. The knife "was supposed" to have been hidden
under Black Watch Bridge. Coleman began to say something about a
paper towel when the conversation ended. (Other evidence of the
Commonwealth showed that a paper towel was found near the victim's
body).
Elmer T. Miller, a forensic scientist, testifying
for the defense, said that from his examination of swabs received
from Dr. Oxley he determined that the very dark, fine substance
found on the victim's hands was soil and particles of plant
material, not coal dust. Other witnesses for the defense testified
to times and places they had seen Coleman on the night of the crimes.
Kermit Stiltner said he saw Coleman at the Speedy
Market about 8:00 p.m. and talked with him 10 or 15 minutes. Johnny
L. Stiltner, a night watchman at T J & M Coal Company, who also
regularly drove miners to the mine, saw Coleman in work clothes at
Breeding's Store about 9:25 p.m. and told him Coleman had been "laid
off" his job which normally began at 9:30. Coleman followed Stiltner
to the mine, "got his stuff," and left between 9:30 and 9:45.
Ronald G. Perkins, second shift foreman at T J &
M Coal Company, saw Coleman about 10:00 p.m. when he came to the
mine for his boots and hat. Coleman was wearing blue jeans, which
the witness did not think were wet. Philip VanDyke, who worked at
another mine, met Coleman at the mouth of Looney's Creek about
10:10. They talked for 10 to 15 minutes and parted company about
10:25 to 10:30.
Other evidence established that from the mouth of
Looney's Creek it was approximately four miles to the McCoy's *41
neighborhood and eight miles to Boyd's Trailer Park, the McCoy
residence being approximately halfway between the two. VanDyke
clocked in at his mine across the creek at 10:41. Gary Owens saw
Coleman alone in his truck near the Gary Scott Stiltner trailer
between 10:00 and 11:00.
Coleman's wife, Patricia, 17, testified that
between 8:00 and 8:30 on March 10 her husband left for work from his
grandmother's house where they were living. She did not recall when
he came home but he explained that he had returned early because he
had been "laid off." The night before the murder, she and Coleman
drove to the McCoys' house. Patricia returned some recipes to her
sister while Coleman remained in the truck. The Colemans often
visited the McCoys and "a couple of times" stayed with Wanda when
her husband was at work.
Garnett M. Coleman testified that Coleman was her
grandson but she and her husband had adopted him when he was 14 and
he had lived with her nearly all his life. According to her, Coleman
left to go to work on March 10 about 8:30 and returned about 11:05.
She said that she "got mixed up" when she first told one of the
investigating officers Coleman came home at 11:30. Coleman, 23,
testified in his own defense. He described the events at Boyd's
Trailer Park on March 6.
That day, he said, he and David Keller got off
work about 6:30 or 7:00 a.m., went to the trailer of Keller's
brother, Tom, and spent the day drinking. Several of them went to
the Stiltner trailer and in the company of Sandra Stiltner listened
to tapes, including one Coleman brought from his truck. After 30 to
45 minutes, Coleman departed, forgetting to take his tape.
Coleman's testimony about his activities on March
10 closely followed the statement he gave to Special Agent Davidson
on March 11. Coleman said he left home at 8:30, drove to the Speedy
Market, got a box there, talked to Crabtree and Kermit Stiltner, and
left about 9:05. He drove to the mouth of Looney's Creek, arriving
at 9:10, but his transportation to the mines had already left. He
drove on to Breeding's Store, where he found the "man trip" (vehicle
used to transport workers to the mines) stopped.
Johnny Stiltner and David Keller were there;
Stiltner told Coleman his shift had been laid off. After five or ten
minutes Coleman drove back to Grundy but remembering that he had
left his mining equipment at the mine, he turned around about 9:25
or 9:30, and drove to the mine site, arriving about 9:45 or 9:50. He
*42 talked to Perkins, the second-shift foreman, Johnny Stiltner,
and David Keller. Leaving the mine site about 10:00 he met VanDyke
on the road. At the mouth of Looney's Creek they talked for 15 or 20
minutes. Coleman said he looked at his watch for the exact time only
at 8:30 when he left home and about 9:05 when he left the Speedy
Market. All other times to which he testified were estimated.
Coleman said he drove to Boyd's Trailer Park to
see Tom Keller but when he discovered the lights were out at
Keller's trailer he went to the Stiltner trailer and retrieved **870
the tape he had left there. It was then about 10:40 to 10:45.
Coleman drove to the bathhouse in Grundy, arrived about 10:50,
showered, left about 11:00, and was at home about 11:05. His pants
probably got wet when he threw his work clothes on the floor of the
shower.
He said the blue jeans he had been wearing that
evening were the pants he had worked in the two previous evenings.
He acknowledged that on March 11 he told Davidson that he probably
got his pants wet at the mines. He conceded that in going from the
mouth of Looney's Creek to Boyd's Trailer Park and then to
thebathhouse he passed the McCoys' residence, but he denied having
stopped there or having murdered or raped Wanda McCoy. He found out
about the crimes when Peggy Stiltner, his wife's sister, came to his
grandmother's house after midnight.
Coleman denied having made any admission to
Matney or any other inmate of the jail. He said he had heard some
details of the crime from his wife's family. He related to inmates
what he had learned, that the victim's throat had been cut, she had
been stabbed twice, she only had her socks on, and a paper towel had
been found. According to Coleman, his uncle, who apparently got the
information from Randall Jackson, told him about the towel. On
cross-examination Coleman acknowledged that he knew Bradley McCoy
worked the second shift.
Later in his testimony, when he was asked how
Type O blood got on his blue jeans, he replied that the cat at his
house might have scratched someone there, or that someone at the
mine the night before might have been cut. Coleman was then shown a
picture of the victim depicting blood on her right leg and was asked
whether the blood on the left leg of his pants had not actually come
from the right leg of the victim. An objection to this question was
overruled; Coleman answered in the negative.
Coleman said the blood found on one of *43 his
knives was from squirrels he had killed in September or October.
Coleman said "[i]t seemed like ... [the officers] came just about
every other day, sometimes every day, for three or four days in a
row," he was willing to talk with them, and he cooperated because he
was "trying to clear" himself "so the police would gon on and find
who did this."
The Commonwealth called two rebuttal witnesses.
Patricia Coleman said she was not aware the cat had scratched anyone
in such a fashion as to cause blood to get on her husband's blue
jeans; Randall Jackson denied having told Coleman's uncle about a
paper towel found at the scene of the crimes.
Shortly before 11:00 p.m. on March 18, 1982, the
jury found Coleman guilty of capital murder. On the next morning,
Coleman's motion to set aside the verdict on the ground the evidence
was insufficient was denied. The sentencing phase of the trial
followed promptly.
Brenda F. Rife, 36, testified as a witness for
the Commonwealth. She described an attempted rape committed by
Coleman on April 7, 1977. On that date, the witness stated, because
of flooding several days earlier, electric and telephone services
were cut off and all the schools were closed. As she was a school
teacher, she remained at home with her six-year-old daughter after
her husband left for work that morning. Coleman, whom she had never
seen before, was admitted to the house when he asked for a drink of
water.
After some conversation, Coleman pulled a gun and
forced her to tape her daughter's hands and feet and place her in a
child's rocking chair. Coleman then walked Mrs. Rife at gunpoint
upstairs to the bedroom where he ordered her to undress. When she
refused, he ripped open the bathrobe she wore, threw her on the bed,
and got on top of her. She struggled, scratched the intruder on the
neck, and attempted to dissuade him from his purpose. Seizing an
opportunity to escape when Coleman went for his gun, which he had
laid down, Mrs. Rife ran downstairs, picked up her daughter, and
fled from the house. Coleman ran after them and attempted to pull
them back inside but in the ensuing struggle Mrs. Rife seized his
weapon, threw it under the porch, and screamed for help. As
neighbors came to the rescue, Coleman ran away.
The entire episode lasted approximately ten
minutes, according to Mrs. Rife, and throughout this time Coleman "
never really raised his voice," which she described as "[v]ery
cold." She recalled, "It was just like, do it or die." The
Commonwealth introduced a certified copy of Coleman's conviction for
the attempted rape of Brenda Rife. He was sentenced to serve three
years in the State penitentiary by order entered July 29, 1977, by
the Circuit Court of Buchanan County.
The defense called two ministers as witnesses.
Thomas F. Bradley, a jail chaplain, visited Coleman six days a week
during the period of three months prior to trial when Coleman had
been incarcerated in jail in Bristol. Bradley stated that his
communications with Coleman were privileged. Contrary to the
recommendation of his attorneys, Coleman declined to waive the
privilege and asserted that he did not want to appear to be "using
the Lord" in any way. The minister testified that he believed
Coleman was sincere in his religious convictions.
Michael Trent, minister of Little Prater Church
of Christ, had known Coleman since he was about nine years old but
had not had "a good connection with him" during the past ten years.
He had come to know him personally after Coleman was incarcerated.
Coleman decided to be baptized about a month after he was first
confined and, at his request, Trent baptized him in jail. Coleman
pursued Bible study in jail; Trent believed he was sincere. Coleman
testified again in his own behalf. He said that after the jury found
him guilty it made no difference whether the penalty was death or
life imprisonment, that "[i]t's up to the Lord now, anyway."