Murderpedia has thousands of hours of work behind it. To keep creating
new content, we kindly appreciate any donation you can give to help
the Murderpedia project stay alive. We have many
plans and enthusiasm
to keep expanding and making Murderpedia a better site, but we really
need your help for this. Thank you very much in advance.
DeBardeleben was the second of three children. He had
a younger brother named Ralph and a younger sister whose identity is not
publicly known. By the time he was an adult he had grown to stand six
feet tall. In 1945, when James was only five years old his family moved
to Austin, Texas. His father who was serving in the U.S. Navy was then
shipped out to the South Pacific for nine months. In 1949, his family
moved to Kentucky for a short while before relocating to Frankfurt,
Germany but after a year his family moved again.
Adult
life
In 1956, at the age of sixteen it is reported that
Michael first physically assaulted his mother, it is unknown what
sparked this violent encounter. On September 8 that year, at the age of
sixteen, he purchased two handguns and ammunition with a friend. Later
that month he was arrested and convicted for his first felony,
possessing a concealed firearm. This arrest was the first of many that
followed including arrests for sodomy, attempted murder and kidnapping.
In the Spring of 1957 he was expelled from Peter
Schuyler High School and did not seek to pursue any formal education. In
October that year, he enlisted in the U.S. Air Force and was stationed
at the Lackland Air Force Base in Texas. Only after a year of being in
the air force he was court-martialed for disorderly behavior and was
sentenced to spend two months in the base stockade and have his wages
forfeited.
He later met Charlotte Weber who was seventeen at the
time he started courting her. In March of 1960 he impregnated Charlotte
and on June 9 the same year, married her. On December 12, 1960 he
successfully fathered a daughter, Bethene. Afterward Charlotte became
pregnant again with another child but was forced by Michael to give it
up for adoption. In August of 1961, his brother Ralph committed suicide
for unknown reasons.
Mall passing case
In the early 1980s, Secret Service agents were
investigating a string of counterfeiting cases in which a man was
determined to be entering a mall with a wad of counterfeit $20 bills,
making a small purchase at each store in the mall, and receiving most of
the remainder in legitimate cash as change. DeBardeleben was identified
as the suspect in these crimes, and a national manhunt ensued.
At the time of his arrest, more wads of counterfeit
$20 bills were found in his car, each with a label stating the city in
which it would be used. His counterfeiting operation was also discovered,
along with evidence of sex crimes.
DeBardeleben was convicted of multiple crimes and is
currently serving a 375-year sentence at Leavenworth Prison in Kansas.
The DSM-IV cites DeBardeleben as an example of
antisocial personality disorder.
James Mitchell "Mike" DeBardeleben
At the time that the first bill was identified, the
Secret Service was not overly concerned about apprehending the forger of
the bills. By the end of 1980, however, DeBardeleben had passed over
$30,000 worth of notes discovered in 38 states.
In 1982, DeBardeleben
managed to pass over $130,000 worth of counterfeit bills in 44 states.
His counterfeiting was increasing, and he became the top priority of the
Counterfeit Division. Because of his method of passing bills, he was
dubbed "The Mall Passer."
With the help of store employees in Kentucky,
Minnesota and Colorado, the Secret Service was able to complete a
composite sketch of the man known as the "Mall Passer." These
individuals described the Mall Passer as 5' 9" to 5'10" tall and 160 to
170 pounds.
In addition, they claimed he had black hair with a receding
hairline, wore dark frame eyeglasses and was approximately 30 to 35
years old. The composite sketch was distributed to Secret Service Field
Offices in areas where the Mall Passer was known to have passed his fake
bills. Agents then distributed the sketch to all the malls in the area
in an effort to raise the public's awareness regarding the Mall Passer.
While the Secret Service was distributing the sketch
to malls, they were also learning more about the modus operandi of the
man known as the Mall Passer. Agents learned from mall employees who had
interactions with the Mall Passer that he was typically well-dressed,
and ascertained that he employed disguises such as fake beards,
mustaches and wigs. He also avoided male and older female clerks,
seeking out young women and girls who he could distract through
conversation while they rang up his low-priced purchases.
Apprehending DeBardeleben
On May 25th, 1983, the hard work of the Secret
Service paid off. DeBardeleben entered a mall in Knoxville, Tennessee,
and purchased several small items. Store clerks, who had been alerted
earlier by the Secret Service, called mall security, who then notified
the Secret Service. By the time DeBardeleben realized that he had been
identified as the Mall Passer, it was too late him to flee – he was
immediately arrested.
In custody, DeBardeleben refused to answer any
question, admit to any crime or discuss any of the counterfeiting
charges that were being brought against him. The main objective of the
Secret Service at this point was to locate his printing plant. Agents
returned to the mall with car keys found on DeBardeleben and a search
warrant in hopes of discovering some clue as to where the location of
the Mall Passer's plant was.
When the Secret Service agents opened the trunk of
DeBardeleben's car, they realized that the man they had apprehended as
the Mall Passer was involved in crimes much more serious than
counterfeiting.
However, the full extent of these crimes could not even
begin to be comprehended until later, when agents in Washington, D.C.,
located a storage unit DeBardeleben had rented. Hopeful about locating
DeBardeleben's printing plant, Agents Dennis Foos and Greg Mertz
discovered evidence of crimes so heinous that thoughts of those crimes
would haunt them for the rest of their lives.
Among the items located by the Secret Service were
homemade audiotapes and photographs of sex-slayings, and a "death kit"
containing handcuffs, shoelaces, chains, K-Y jelly, and worse – a
woman's bloody underwear. Agent Foos knew that they had uncovered a
criminal beyond the usual investigation capabilities of the Secret
Service in investigating.
He contacted the Federal Bureau of
Investigations, hoping for guidance or help in piecing together the
evidence and locating the victims. However, because of the nature of the
investigation the FBI was reluctant to help. Investigations typically
start with a victim and investigators work towards finding the offender.
In this case, the Secret Service had the offender, evidence of crimes,
but no known victims yet.
Agents Foos and Mertz then set up a database on an
Apple II computer, similar to VICAP, the database used by the FBI to tie
crimes together, and began compiling lists of crimes and victims in the
areas DeBardeleben was believed to have been preying. Eventually, the
Secret Service Agents came up with a list of victim names and crimes
that fit the evidence.
The Victims
The actual number of victims of DeBardeleben's will
never be known. Unlike most criminals of his ilk, DeBardeleben refuses
to acknowledge guilt or brag about any of his crimes. However, the
Secret Service believe that he had been preying on women for eighteen
years prior to his arrest. Considering that Ted Bundy, whose killing
spree lasted only five years and resulted in the deaths of somewhere
between 28 to 100 women, the number of women DeBardeleben is believed to
have preyed on is staggering.
On September 3rd, 1978, in Delaware, DeBardeleben
kidnapped Lucy Alexander. He repeatedly raped and sodomized her, forced
her to perform fellatio on him, and then released her in an isolated
area.
On February 4th, 1979, he kidnapped Elizabeth Mason, repeatedly
choked her and banged her head on a wall until she lost consciousness,
then left her for dead.
On June 1st, 1979, DeBardeleben kidnapped Laurie
Jensen, took her to his home, and for 24 hours, raped and sodomized her,
forced her to perform fellatio on him, forced her to masturbate herself
using an oversized dildo for him, demanded that she call him "Daddy,"
and took pictures and audiotaped her throughout the entire ordeal. He
then released her a few blocks from her home.
On November 1st, 1980,
once again DeBardeleben found another victim, Dianne Overton. However,
she managed to fight him off and escaped before he could harm her. After
his failure to successfully victimize Overton, on November 12th, 1980,
he kidnapped Maria Santini, stripped her and tied her hands and feet,
took pictures of her in provocative poses, and then dumped her in the
woods.
On April 27th, 1982, DeBardeleben kidnapped real estate agent
Jean McPhaul. Her body was later found in an attic of a new home, lashed
to a rafter by a ligature on her throat. She was fully clothed and had
two puncture wounds to the heart.
In addition to victimizing numerous strangers, Secret
Service agents were able to piece together DeBardeleben's personal life
and discover five wives whom had all suffered similar horrors to the
ones suffered by the women he kidnapped. Agents believe that
DeBardeleben "practiced" his fantasies on his wives, prior to acting
them out on the women he kidnapped. DeBardeleben's third wife, when
interviewed in court for the cases against DeBardeleben, testified that
to him, "all women were whores, sluts, tramps. They asked for what they
got." (Michaud, 1994).
However, the object of DeBardeleben's most malicious
thoughts and fantasies, was his fourth wife, Caryn. Among the evidence
found by the Secret Service, was a detailed description titled "Script/Scenario"
written by DeBardeleben describing conversations he would have with her
while torturing her.
He wrote, "1 – Tell me all about the pain:
necessary? Why? Describe it: details, more details… how does it feel – I
don't know, it's not happening to me!! Convince me that you like it! 2 –
Tell me how you feel humiliated, degraded… 3 – … Tell me how you like
for me to bite your tits, slap your face, bite you in the ass, make loud
surprise noises. 4 – Bite or cigar or whip at moment of ejaculation. 5 –
Hair: pull as mane: say "arf," "bow wow," "neigh." 6 – Say original
statements." Of Caryn, DeBardeleben wrote, "She never really loved me…"
and "I don't want to kill Caryn – I want to punish her…" It was apparent
to the agents that Caryn was the source of DeBardeleben's anger and
hatred towards women.
The Evidence and the Charges
By the time investigators were done piecing together
the evidence against DeBardeleben, he faced eleven indictments,
including two for murder, in nine states. Among these indictments were
six charges for counterfeiting in various states; sodomy, robbery and
armed criminal action in Missouri; kidnapping charges in Connecticut;
and a federal kidnapping charge in Baltimore. Investigators had worked
long and hard, applying forensic techniques to tie DeBardeleben to the
crimes they believed he had committed.
To start with, the Secret Service re-printed copies
of the photos from the negatives taken from DeBardeleben's storage unit.
It was apparent that DeBardeleben had cut the photographs to remove
parts of his body that appeared in them. The agents needed to prove that
the male body parts appearing in these photographs were DeBardeleben's.
An FBI Forensic Photographic Analyst suggested that DeBardeleben could
be tied to the photographs by comparing pictures of distinguishing marks
such as moles and scars on DeBardeleben's body to distinguishing marks
on the man in the photograph. To do this, the agents needed to secure
known photographs of DeBardeleben.
Under federal court order,
DeBardeleben was forced to submit to body photographs. These photographs
proved DeBardeleben was the man found in the photographs of the sex
slaying that were gathered with the evidence from his storage unit.
Next, agents took handwriting samples to compare to
the notes and diaries found in his storage unit. The samples were then
sent to a handwriting expert. The handwriting expert based his opinion
on the details of particular letters, the height of different letters,
and the slant of the writing. These samples were compared to each other
by a handwriting expert who determined they were written by the same
individual.
Last, DeBardeleben was ordered to give head and pubic
hair samples. These samples would be compared to the samples taken from
his known victims during forensic examinations after they had been
victimized. Hair samples are compared under a microscope.
Some of the
identifying characteristics forensic scientists were looking for are the
way in which pigment particles are shaped and distributed, and the
precise color of the hair. Forensic scientists were able to conclude
that the hair samples taken from DeBardeleben matched those on some of
the victims believed to be his.
The Trials
DeBardeleben was tried and convicted based upon the
forensic evidence, victims' testimony and witnesses' identification in
six separate cases for counterfeiting, kidnapping and assault. He
received a total sentencing of 375 years.
The other states involved in
the indictments of DeBardeleben decided to forgo lengthy trials, due to
the fact that by the time DeBardeleben would be eligible for parole, he
will be 100 years old.
Since DeBardeleben was imprisoned, he has spent
his time corresponding with other serial killers such as Ted Bundy, and
putting together numerous appeals. He has been moved from prison to
prison based on his various complaints, including fear of harm by other
inmates.
DeBardeleben still refuses to acknowledge his crimes and claims
that the Secret Service manufactured their evidence against him in an
effort to build their case. The Secret Service Agents, jury members,
judges and investigators involved in this case, believe that
DeBardeleben's crimes are unsurpassed to those of any other known
individual.
"When you work hard to do something right, you don't want to forget it."