A thorough search of Fayette law
enforcement and court records showed no hint of trouble at the
Hilderbrand household at 215 Lofty Eagle Lane in north Fayette County.
But a triple murder and a suicide were in the family's future.
Authorities say ex-Fayetteville
antique dealer Michael Hilderbrand, Sr., shot and killed his wife, her
daughter and their son in their new South Carolina home last month and
was stalking his ex-wife near the nation's capital when he was spotted
by police and chased. He killed himself before police could capture him,
authorities said.
The family left Fayette in
August 1999 and moved to Greer, S.C., about three hours northeast of
Atlanta, where problems began to crop up earlier this year. The deadly
series of events began Monday, March 5.
Claiming her husband, Michael,
was verbally abusive and threw her around, Sandra Hilderbrand obtained a
protective order at 4 p.m. Monday afternoon, March 5, to keep him away
from her and her daughter, Caitlin, 8, and their son, Michael Jr., 5,
according to court records and news reports.
At 7:45 p.m. that same day,
police believe, Hilderbrand parked his black Jeep at the rear of the
home, drowned the family dog in the pool, then let himself into the
Dillard Road home and shot to death his wife and the children.
The next morning, Tuesday, March
6, Hilderbrand told officials at his stepdaughter's school and his son's
daycare that the children were sick and wouldn't be back until Friday.
Before noon that day, police said, Hilderbrand bought a 9mm handgun from
a gun shop in Greer and drove to Herndon, Va., near his ex-wife's
apartment in Reston, Va. Police believe he intended to make his ex-wife
murder victim number four. After checking into a motel there, police
said, Hilderbrand drove to a pistol target practice range.
The crime scene at the
Hilderbrands' home was discovered when Sandra's attorney, Henry J. Mims,
became concerned about the family's whereabouts. Sandra had been
scheduled to meet with him Tuesday, but she never showed up.
Mims contacted the Sheriff's
Department, and deputies went to the family's home Tuesday evening, but
found nothing suspicious.
But during a second visit to the
home in the early hours of Wednesday, March 7, deputies found the family
dog drowned at the bottom of the swimming pool. That discovery triggered
a search of the house, where the bodies of Sandra, Caitlin and Michael,
Jr., were discovered.
Hilderbrand had been long gone
by that time, and deputies went to search the antique store in downtown
Greer. Upon entering, they discovered a heavy smell of gas, and the area
was evacuated.
After the gas was cleared away,
it was determined that Hilderbrand had gone to the store and turned on
the gas, leaving several six-inch candles burning in the shop.
Authorities said he wanted to blow up the store, and it was estimated
that had the gas caught fire, it would have created an explosion "enough
to destroy a whole city block."
Virginia police were later
notified that Hilderbrand might be coming to the area to locate his ex-wife,
and that's why he was spotted by authorities there. The ensuing high-speed
chase, three days after the killings, ended when a police car bumped
Hilderbrand's vehicle, causing him to crash into a wall near Dulles
International Airport.
As officers approached,
Hilderbrand shot himself with the 9mm pistol.
In court documents seeking the
protective order, Sandra had described her husband as "very unstable and
violent at times."
She also claimed that he failed
to take his medicine that had been prescribed to treat his bipolar
disorder, a mental illness involving episodes of serious mania and
depression in severe mood swings.
The family had lived in Fayette
County a short time, from 1997 to 1999, in a two-story home in the
Foxhall Farms subdivision off Ga. Highway 92 north. They sold the home
in August 1999 for $184,000, a $20,000 profit, according to courthouse
deed records.
Other than the home, the only
remaining local link to the Hilderbrands is artwork that Michael
Hilderbrand painted on the exterior of the couple's abortive antique
shop at 342 N. Glynn St. in Fayetteville. According to city records,
Puppy's Antiques maintained a business license for just one year.
The 3,000-square-foot open shop
area, adjacent to The Citizen's offices and just off busy Hwy. 85, was
refurbished for the antiques trade, but domestic trouble between
Hilderbrand and his wife ended the venture before it ever opened to the
public.
But when the family moved to
Greer, they opened up another antiques store under the same name.
Sandra Hilderbrand confided in a
customer at the Greer store one day that her husband was causing
problems. Shirley Phillips told The Greenville News that Sandra knew her
husband was going to kill her.
"She told me that if she filed
papers, he would kill her," Phillips said. "It was almost like she was
resigned to it. That's what's so sad. It was almost like 'I know what
he's going to do.'"
Phillips said she told Sandra to
be careful, but Sandra said she already had secured the services of an
attorney. She had begun divorce proceedings in the fall.
In fact, family members told The
Greenville News that she had planned to escape the area and take the
children to Oklahoma to live near friends and family. Sandra had made
arrangements to move to Guthrie, Okla., before a friend lost contact
with her after the Hilderbrands' phone number changed. That was a
regular occurrence with the family, said Anneliese Herren of Guthrie,
Sandra's best friend.
"Every time I would leave a
message [on the answering machine], he would erase it," Herren said. "She
was not allowed to keep in contact with anybody."
Hilderbrand would also
confiscate mail sent to his wife, Herren added.
"He intercepted everything," she
said.
Sandra even called her brother
several days before the murders and told him something was wrong, "but
she wouldn't leave," Joanna Cosetti, her sister-in-law told the
newspaper.
Mims told The Greenville News
that he had become afraid of Hilderbrand while representing Sandra, so
much so that he purchased a gun to carry and protect himself should he
ever be attacked.
