Leonski confessed to the crimes and was convicted and
sentenced to death at a United States Army general court-martial on July
17, 1942. General Douglas MacArthur confirmed the sentence on October
14, 1942 and a Board of Review upheld the findings and sentence on
October 28, 1942. General Court-Martial Order 1 promulgated Leonski's
death sentence on November 1, 1942.
In a departure from normal procedure, on November 4,
1942, MacArthur personally signed the order of execution (in future
executions, this administrative task would be entrusted to his Chief of
Staff, Richard Sutherland). Leonski was hanged at Pentridge Prison on
November 9, 1942, only the second American serviceman to be executed
during World War II.
Leonski's counsel, Ira C. Rothgerber, attempted to
win an external review, even from the U.S. Supreme Court, but was unable
to do so. Rothgerber kept the issue alive after the war, and Leonski's
case contributed to the development of the Uniform Code of Military
Justice (UCMJ).
Leonski was temporarily interred at several
cemeteries in Australia. His remains were eventually permanently
interred in Section 9, Row B, Site 8 at Schofield Barracks Post Cemetery,
in a portion of the facility reserved for general prisoners who had died
in military custody.
Fictional portrayals
Leonski, Edward Joseph (1917 - 1942)
By Peter Pierce
Australian Dictionary of Biography
Leonski, Edward Joseph
(1917-1942), soldier and murderer, was born on 12 December 1917 at
Kenvil, New Jersey, United States of America, sixth child of Russian-born
parents John Leonski, labourer, and his
wife Amelia, née Harkavitz. The family moved to East 77th Street, New
York, during Edward's infancy. Leaving junior high school in 1933, he
took a secretarial course and finished in the top 10 per cent of his
class. He held several clerical jobs before working for Gristede Bros
Inc. Superior Food Markets. When called up for military service on 17
February 1941, he left behind an unhappy family: a mother mentally
unstable, two brothers with prison records and a third in a psychiatric
hospital.
While stationed with the 52nd Signal Battalion at San
Antonio, Texas, Leonski began to drink
heavily, preferring such concoctions as whisky laced with hot peppers;
he displayed his strength by vaulting on to bar counters and walking
along them on his hands. About this time he tried to strangle a woman.
The American authorities failed to comprehend the problem that they
shipped to Australia in January 1942.
Arriving in Melbourne in February,
Leonski was quartered at Camp Pell, Royal
Park. He resumed his ferocious drinking and allegedly attempted to rape
a woman in her St Kilda flat. Drunkenness led to thirty days in the
stockade, but release was followed by another binge. On 3 May Mrs Ivy
McLeod was found murdered in the doorway of a shop next to the Bleak
House Hotel, Albert Park. Melbourne newspapers immediately dubbed it a 'Brownout
Crime'. The unpopular wartime reduction of street lighting helped
Leonski to commit two more murders
undisturbed: of Mrs Pauline Thompson outside a city boarding house on 9
May and of Mrs Gladys Hosking in Royal Park on the 18th. All three were
throttled; all were older than the killer; and, though their genitals
were exposed, none was sexually assaulted.
Efficient detective work and the evidence of a
soldier in whom Leonski had confided led to
his arrest on 22 May. Sensitive to relations with its American ally, the
Curtin government decided—after consultation with Britain and in the
face of some strenuous opposition—that Leonski
could be tried by a United States court martial. Following some dispute,
he was declared sane, and was tried and found guilty on 17 July. Fair
haired and of middle height, Leonski was
powerfully built, boyish in appearance and cheerful in demeanour. He
gave no explanation for his crimes, other than to say of one of his
victims, 'I wanted that voice. I choked her'.
Held in the city watchhouse, he corresponded with a
woman at Eltham, learned Oscar Wilde's 'The Ballad of Reading Gaol' and
became a communicant of the Catholic Church.
Leonski was hanged at Pentridge prison on 9 November 1942. His
remains were finally buried in a military cemetery in Honolulu. Albert
Tucker's painting, 'Memory of Leonski' (in
his 'Image of Evil' series, 1943), is privately owned;
Leonski was also the subject of a novel by
Andrew Mallon (1979) and of a feature film, Death of a Soldier
(1986).