Murderpedia has thousands of hours of work behind it. To keep creating
new content, we kindly appreciate any donation you can give to help
the Murderpedia project stay alive. We have many
plans and enthusiasm
to keep expanding and making Murderpedia a better site, but we really
need your help for this. Thank you very much in advance.
By Gary Craig, Rochester (N.Y.) Democrat and
Chronicle
November 11, 2008
ROCHESTER, N.Y. — Serial killer
Arthur Shawcross, convicted of murdering 11 women in New York state
between 1988 and 1990, died Monday evening, state corrections
officials said Tuesday
Shawcross, 63, was taken to the
Albany Medical Center on Monday, according to Department of
Correctional Services spokesman Erik Kriss. He was serving a sentence
of 250 years to life for the murders. Ten of his victims were from
Monroe County, N.Y. and the 11th was killed in Wayne County, N.Y..
Shawcross' three-month trial in
the Monroe County slayings was considered the biggest and most
complicated murder trial in county history.
The trial was televised gavel-to-gavel,
as the New York law then allowed. The luridness of the case, coupled
with the television coverage, drew big audiences.
The prosecutor, then First
Assistant District Attorney Charles Siragusa, is now a federal judge.
He said people would frequently approach him outside court to talk
about the case.
For the prosecution, he and
others dissected Shawcross' entire life so they would be prepared to
challenge an attempted psychiatric defense.
Siragusa said he and others
tracked Shawcross' school records back to the second grade and also
accumulated all of his records from previous military service.
"By the time the trial came
around, I probably knew more about Arthur Shawcross than he knew,"
Siragusa said today.
Shawcross did not testify
during his trial, but jurors watched videotapes of him being
interviewed under hypnosis by defense psychiatrist Dr. Dorothy Lewis.
He switched in and out of a high-pitched woman's voice and told Lewis
he had once been a cannibal in medieval England.
In sometimes graphic detail, he
described incestuous relations with his sister as a child and wartime
atrocities and cannibalism in Vietnam. In the most dramatic passage,
he appeared to relive an episode in which he was sexually abused by
his mother. He told Lewis his mother's voice told him to kill his
victims, and that she "helped him" strangle and mutilate one of the
women.
But in videotaped interviews
with prosecution psychiatrist Dr. Park Dietz, Shawcross said he never
heard voices or had different personalities. Dietz argued that
Shawcross was faking mental illness to avoid being sent to prison.
The jury deliberated only 6 1/2
hours before convicting Shawcross in December 1990.
He later pleaded guilty in the
Wayne County killing.
Two books have been written
about Shawcross' crimes.
Shawcross, a native of
Jefferson County, came to Rochester June 29, 1987, after killing two
children in Watertown in 1972 and serving time in prison. Residents of
Binghamton and the Delaware Count communities of Delhi and
Fleischmanns ran him out.
On July 13, 1987, a senior
parole officer in Rochester decided that local police officials "should
be told" of Shawcross' "presence in the community, but not regarding
his criminal background." The next day, Rochester, Brighton and
Irondequoit police were told that Shawcross had settled in the city.
On July 10, 1997, Shawcross
married his longtime sweetheart, Clara D. Neal, at a Sullivan County
Correctional Facility ceremony. Neal said in 1994 that Shawcross'
previous wife, Rose of Oneonta, Otsego County, had delivered him
divorce papers on his birthday that June.
An uproar ensued over the issue
of conjugal visits.
He then created controversy in
1999 by giving paintings and poems to people outside prison, who then
marketed them on the Internet auction site eBay. Shawcross was given
two years solitary confinement for profiting from the paintings. He
appealed and got the time reduced to nine months.
After criticism in 2001 for
allowing Shawcross to sell his artwork at its annual inmate art show,
the state Department of Correctional Services in 2002 eliminated the
show and banned the sale of art produced in prisons.
The "Corrections on Canvas"
show had been staged for 35 years in the Legislative Office Building
in Albany. Inmates bought their own art supplies and kept half the
proceeds from their sales, with the other half going to the state
Crime Victims Board.
Shawcross painted mostly muted
pastel works that depicted scenes with butterflies and winged horses
for the 2001 show. A portrait of the late Princess Diana was among 10
sketches and paintings by him that sold for as much as $540 each.
The
Arthur Shawcross Story: Sins of the Flesh
by
Patrick Bellamy
Art
Imitates Life
By his own
admission, Arthur Shawcross has been obsessed by sex for as long as
he can remember. Like many other pubescent boys he conducted
various sexual experiments, but for Arthur, it became more than just
idle curiosity. He claims that from age seven, he frequently
masturbated and had oral sex with both male and female friends.
Years later, he bragged to psychologists that he had also had sex
with a sheep, a cow and a horse and had even killed a chicken in the
process of trying to have sex with it. He would also claim that his
aunt Tina was responsible for his sexual habits because she "forced"
him to perform oral sex on her, which, he says accounts for it being
his preferred method of sexual contact. He also claims that when he
was fourteen, he had sex with his twelve-year-old sister Jeannie, an
accusation she strenuously denies.
Another favourite story is that
his mother sodomised him with a broomstick when he was a child but
that story is also suspect. Whatever the reasons, be they real or
merely the fantasies of a twisted mind, the pursuit of sexual
gratification came to play a major role in the life of Arthur Shawcross, and eventually led to him becoming one of the most
depraved and brutal serial killers in history.
Arthur John
Shawcross was born in the early hours of June 6, 1945 at the U.S.
Naval hospital in Kittery, Maine. He was two months premature. At
the time of his birth, his mother, Bessie, was just eighteen and his
father, Corporal Arthur Roy Shawcross was twenty-one. Two weeks
after the birth, Bessie took baby Arthur and moved to Watertown, New
York to live with her sister-in-law until Arthur Snr. had completed
his military service.
By 1958, the
family had built a small house in a rural area six miles northwest
of Watertown near the town of Brownville. Three other related
families soon settled in the same area, which became known as "Shawcross
Corners." This extended family, including thirteen children, lived
a normal, happy existence. Young Arthur, on the other hand, was
beginning to show the first signs of abnormal behaviour, especially
after his little brother Jimmy was born. He became a chronic bed
wetter and was still talking like a baby until he was six. The
following year, he started running away from home, which family
members dismissed as merely a ploy to gain attention.
By the time
he was eight, other behavioural problems began to surface. He
seemed to hate children younger than himself and teased them until
they cried. He became obsessed with his sister Jeannie and ignored
his other sister and younger brother. He invented imaginary friends
and spoke with them in strange voices. His classmates constantly
teased him and called him "Oddie," which would send him into a
rage. By and large, Arthur was a loner whose "weird" behaviour made
it hard for him to mix and communicate with others and he would
often be seen sitting alone in an empty classroom while his peers
were outside playing. Curiously, his grades were above average but
a school nurse remembers him as being "a troubled boy," who
constantly ran away from home and often carried an iron bar on the
bus to threaten other children with.
By the time
he entered the third grade, Arthur's behaviour deteriorated as did
his grades and he was given a series of psychological tests, which
indicated that his behaviour was due in large part to his feelings
of inadequacy and rejection and a growing hostility that he felt
towards his parents, particularly his mother. Regardless of the
results, he was later promoted to the fourth grade where he stayed
for two years. During this time, he ran away yet again and was
picked up at the Canadian border.
By the time
Arthur was nine, the atmosphere at home was no better than the one
at school, especially when Arthur's mother found out that Arthur
Snr. had another wife and son in Australia. Relatives believe that
from that time on, his mother became a different woman who flew into
jealous rages at the mere mention of another woman and raged
constantly at Arthur Snr., who became quiet and withdrawn as a
result. Arthur Jr. did his best to stay out of her way by
retreating to his Grandmother's house at every opportunity.
As the years
passed, Arthur grew increasingly violent and would often beat up the
neighbourhood children and became well known for his explosive
temper. He also began breaking into houses and stealing from local
businesses and lighting fires. On one occasion, after falling into a
river at a family picnic, he complained of sore legs and was given
brain scans and a battery of other tests to determine the cause.
The tests revealed nothing. His family later agreed that it was
just one more attempt to gain attention.
Becoming
increasingly withdrawn and antisocial, Arthur fell further and
further behind with his schoolwork until, in the eighth grade, he
was a full three years older than his classmates. Arthur didn't
seem to care; he had become a true outcast.
By his mid
teens, he was still wetting the bed and had almost completely
withdrawn into his own private little world. He spent hours walking
in the woods talking to himself and was often observed yelling at
inanimate objects and beating the undergrowth with a stick as if in
torment from unseen demons.
By the time
he was fourteen, Arthur claims that he was regularly having oral sex
with his sister Jeannie and his cousin Linda. He also claims that
he had another relationship with a young girl who lived nearby and
was caught by her brother while performing oral sex on the girl.
The brother supposedly threatened to tell their parents unless
Arthur performed oral sex on him as well. It was at this time that
Arthur's craving for sex became insatiable and he continued to have
oral sex whenever the opportunity presented itself. Curiously,
Arthur never described any acts of penetration during this period,
which could indicate that he was unable to sustain an erection from
an early age. That year also marked the period when Arthur claims
to have first associated violence with sex. It began after he was
walking home from school and was picked up by a man in a red
convertible who supposedly held him by the throat while performing
oral sex on him. When Arthur failed to reach orgasm, the man anally
raped him and dropped him near his house. From that time on,
Shawcross claims that he could never reach orgasm without inflicting
pain on himself.
The
following year he was arrested for breaking into a Sears department
store but was given probation because he hadn't removed anything
from the store. For the next few years, Arthur wandered aimlessly
through life until, at the age of nineteen, he married for the first
time. The union lasted less than three years and produced a son.
In 1968 Arthur was conscripted into the army and began a tour of
duty in Vietnam. It was to be an important turning point in his
life; he was about to learn how to kill.
The
Making of a Monster
Just prior
to his posting, Arthur married his second wife Linda Neary after a
brief courtship. Arriving in Vietnam, he was assigned to a unit in
Pleiku as a supply clerk. One of his duties was to arrange for the
distribution of ammunition which entailed travelling to the outlying
units by helicopter. It was at that point, he later told
psychiatrists, that he started going out on "fire missions" with
various forward companies. Initially, he claims, he was shocked by
the violence but soon found that he craved the danger of going into
the jungle alone looking for the enemy and eventually became what he
referred to as a "predator."
On one such
mission, Shawcross claimed he encountered two Vietnamese women
hiding guns in a hollow tree and shot one of them and tied the other
to a tree. The woman who was shot was still breathing when
Shawcross cut her head off and put it on a post for the Viet Cong to
find. He then cut off a section of her thigh and roasted it over a
fire and ate part of it. Afterwards he had oral sex with the other
woman and raped her before shooting her in the head and butchering
her body. He became an expert sniper and claimed that he fashioned
a silencer out of a rubber nipple from a baby's bottle, which
allowed him to pick off the enemy without giving his position away.
Even if such a device were effective, it would only be good for one
shot, which brings to mind the question of how he was able to obtain
a ready supply of rubber nipples in the jungles of Vietnam.
By his own
admission, Shawcross became an "animal" in Vietnam and found it
difficult to control the violent urges that drove him to rape and
kill. The enemy weren't the only victims of his sexual rages as he
also claims to have attacked several Asian prostitutes, some as
young as eleven.
When he
returned home to Watertown in 1969, he was a changed man, for the
worse. He was continually agitated and found it hard to relax.
After visiting his mother he went to see his wife only to find that
she had spent all the money that he had been sending home and was
seeing another man. Soon after, when he was transferred to Fort
Sill Oklahoma to serve out the remainder of his term in the Army,
Linda went with him. It was at this time that Shawcross began to
experience violent flashbacks and nightmares and began to beat
Linda, which led him to consult with an Army psychiatrist. The
doctor suggested therapy and a period in a mental hospital to try
and stabilise him but Linda, being a Christian Scientist, was wary
of doctors and hospitals and refused to sign the commitment papers.
Without
therapy, Arthur's mental state began to decline and he became
increasingly irritated with Linda and her family, usually over their
adherence to their religion, which he saw as nothing more than
witchcraft. In April 1969, Arthur vented his frustration by setting
fire to a local paper mill and later in the year, the cheese factory
where he was employed at the time. He was later arrested and
convicted on two counts of arson and sentenced to five years in
prison. He served the first six months of his sentence at Attica
prison where three black inmates allegedly raped him. Shawcross
claims he later extracted revenge by beating and raping each of his
attackers in separate incidents and was transferred to Auburn prison
to serve out his sentence.
In 1971, he
was given early release when he saved the life of a prison guard who
had been clubbed during a prison riot sparked by racial tensions
within the prison. He returned to Watertown to "start a new life,"
having been divorced by Linda while he was in jail. His stay in
prison did little for his already fragile mental state and by the
time of his release he was in a highly agitated frame of mind and
ready to do further damage to anyone or anything that took his
fancy.
Death of
the Innocents
In an
attempt to settle into a normal routine, Arthur took a job at the
Watertown Public Works Department as a handyman and married a third
time. His new wife, Penny Nichol, was a school friend of his sister
Jeannie and had two children from a former relationship. Shawcross
claims that up to this time, he was still having a sexual
relationship with Jeannie and that she had introduced him to Penny
because she had fallen pregnant to her boyfriend and couldn't
continue their relationship.
By his recollection, after five
months, the relationship with Penny seemed to be going well and at
one stage she fell pregnant but later miscarried. Sometime later,
he claims that the marriage came under threat when Penny's father
accused Arthur of sexually assaulting Penny's younger sister.
Shawcross said he denied the allegation but from that time on,
Penny's parents spent a great deal of time around the house watching
him. What makes both the miscarriage and the alleged assault
interesting is the fact that, by his own admission, Shawcross was
incapable of maintaining an erection or ejaculating making the
possibility of him fathering a child very difficult. Secondly,
regarding the assault, during his interviews with Dr. Joel Norris
for the book "Arthur Shawcross: The Genesee Killer," he seems
confused wether Penny's sister is named Rose or Jill.
One thing is
known to be fact; Arthur Shawcross spent a great deal of his spare
time fishing in the creeks and rivers around Watertown. As a
result, he came to know many of the town's children and often shared
the same spots with them. One of his regular fishing companions
was ten-year-old Jack Blake and on one occasion, Arthur had gone to
the boy's house to ask Jack's mother Mary if Jack could go fishing
with him. According to Mary, when she refused, Arthur was polite
and agreed that she had made the right decision.
Four months
later, on the morning of June 4 1972, Jack went out to play near the
Cloverdale apartment block where Shawcross lived and never came
home. Later that night, while out looking for her son, Mary Blake
knocked on Arthur's door to ask where her son was. He told her that
he hadn't seen him since that morning. The truth of the matter was
that Shawcross had taken Jack into the woods and after stripping him
naked and forcing him to run through the woods, had caught him and
sexually molested him before finally strangling him and battering
him about the head. Later Shawcross would admit to removing the
boy's heart and genitals and eating them. Although Shawcross was a
suspect in the boy's disappearance, no action was taken due to lack
of evidence.
Three months
later, while the police were still searching for Jack Blake,
eight-year-old Karen Ann Hill was found dead under a bridge near
Black River, she had been raped, mutilated and strangled. When a
police investigation revealed that Hill and Shawcross had been seen
together earlier the same day, Shawcross again became a suspect.
After they received another report that Shawcross was seen eating an
ice cream at the bridge near where the body was found, the police
picked Arthur Shawcross up and took him in for questioning.
He was
interrogated at police headquarters for a full day before he
surprised police by asking them in front of his defence attorney,
"What's going to happen to me if I tell you something?"
After
several more hours of interviews and plea-bargaining, Arthur
Shawcross pleaded guilty to the manslaughter of Karen Ann Hill. He
was later convicted and sentenced to twenty-five years in prison.
To this day, he has never been charged with the murder of Jack Blake
even though he later admitted to the rape and murder and showed
police where he had dumped the body. He later told prison
psychiatrists that he had returned to the gravesite on several
occasions to have sex with the corpse.
A Model
Prisoner
Arthur
Shawcross began his second jail term in the New York Penitentiary in
Green Haven. For the first eight years he spent much of his time
protecting himself from the other inmates who considered
child-killers the lowest form of life. His record shows numerous
reports of fighting, minor stealing offences, lighting fires and
refusing to leave his cell. Eventually he began to settle into
prison life and behave himself until finally he was considered to be
a "model prisoner."
During his
incarceration he claims that he tried to tell the prison's
psychiatrists that his problems were a result of the Vietnam War but
they refused to listen. One of the first psychiatrists to examine
him, Dr. Albert Dresser, did not consider Shawcross a "psychological
risk." His report shows that he did not perceive any evidence of
delusions, hallucinations or sensory deceptions in his patient
Arthur Shawcross.
Some months
later, in October 1973, another prison psychologist, Dr. J. R,
McWilliams, also examined Shawcross and carried out a series of
tests including the Bender Motor Gestalt test and the Wechsler Adult
Intelligence test but found no evidence of any neurological
impairment. What he did find was that Arthur suffered from fits of
deep depression and "relied heavily upon fantasy as a source of
satisfaction."
His final entry in the case file was that he
considered Shawcross, "seems to be a normal individual who knows he
has done wrong and would like to help himself get back on the right
track for his eventual return to society." Curiously, an unknown
person crossed out the reference to "normal person" in the
McWilliams report and wrote the words "a psychopathic killer" above
it in pencil.
In 1976, Dr.
Michael Boccia examined Arthur and found that he had not come to
terms with the severity of the crimes that he was being punished for
and constantly blamed others for his problems. In his opinion,
Shawcross had not requested the first examination to deal with his
mental problems; he had done it merely to impress the parole board.
The following year, the "model prisoner" had taken courses in lock
smithing and horticulture and began preparing for his General
Equivalency Diploma. With more than a touch of irony he also began
working with mental patients as a counsellor.
In June
1977, yet another prison psychiatrist, Dr. Haveliwala gave him
another psychological examination and found that although he had
adapted readily to prison routine, he had a schizoid personality,
was antisocial and had a distinct personality disorder. In
addition, Haveliwala wrote "This man does not show a good degree of
evidence of successfully resolving or working out his psychosexual
conflicts."
Two more
years passed and yet another report was tendered which described
Shawcross as, "a person of abnormal character traits with
psychosexual tendencies. It must be noted that the above-mentioned
complications tend to be chronic in duration."
Basically,
what most of the doctors were trying to say was that under normal
circumstances, Arthur Shawcross was a passive individual but when
subjected to stress he became a slave to his inner sexual drives and
was unable to prevent himself from giving them full reign.
Regardless of these and other unfavourable psychological reports,
Arthur continued to "improve himself" in prison and by 1985 had
completed his high school education and enrolled in college courses
at Penn State University. A parole report during the same period
further stated that Shawcross "exhibited a belligerent reaction
representing a foreboding potential for a possible re-enactment of
his tragic behaviour." The report went on to further criticise the
prisoner for his disdain for the prisons Sex Offender Program and
displaying his "fury" during the parole interview.
Incredibly,
despite the numerous psychological reports to the contrary and the
parole boards own misgivings, Arthur Shawcross qualified for early
release in March 1987 and was deemed to be "fit to re-enter
society." After his release, Robert T. Kent, his parole officer in
Binghamton County wrote to his superiors, "At the risk of being
melodramatic, the writer considers this man to be possibly the most
dangerous individual to be released to this community for many
years." They were to be prophetic words indeed.
On the
Prowl
When
Shawcross was released he was placed in the Binghamton area as the
officials and residents of Watertown had made it plain that they
didn't want him there. He had also been maintaining a "pen-pal"
relationship with a woman named Rose Walley and indicated that he
would go and live with her and probably marry her. His parole
conditions, among other things, required him to restrict his
movements to Broome county, observe an 11pm to 7am curfew, refrain
from partaking of any alcoholic beverage and not to have contact
with anyone under the age of eighteen and stay away from schools or
any other place where children were present.
Learning
that he would be placed in their area, the Binghamton parole
officers asked the question that the parole board should have
considered before his release, if he had to have such strict parole
conditions, why release him in the first place?
His stay in
Binghamton only proved to be a short one when the residents objected
to his presence and he was given approval to move to Delhi, New York
where he moved into Rose Walley's apartment. Shortly after he moved
in however, the residents of his new community got wind of his
presence and he was asked to leave. He appealed to the parole board
and was sent to live in the basement of the Baptist church in Delhi
until suitable accommodation could be found. He and Rose later
moved to Fleischmanns, New York and moved into a large house and
Arthur obtained work with a local building contractor.
Within a
matter of days, he was recognised in the local post office and later
that night an angry mob led by the town's mayor assembled outside
his house and demanded that he leave the area. In the following
weeks, Shawcross and Walley were bounced around from one area to the
other until finally they were given an apartment in Rochester, New
York. Eventually, according to Shawcross, he tired of the parole
boards interference and he and Rose got their own apartment and new
jobs and settled into their new surroundings. The job that Arthur
got was at a company called "Bognia's" where he was employed to pack
salads in boxes.
His life
seemed stable enough until Christmas 1987 when he asked his family
to come to Rochester to meet Rose and they refused. His mood
darkened when his sister informed him that the family had visited
her in Virginia and told her how they had returned the Christmas
present that he had sent them. He became angry and ranted about how
his family didn't want him and went out on his bike and rode for
miles until he cooled down. Shortly after the Christmas incident,
he started a relationship with another woman named Clara Neal and
often borrowed her car. For a year he maintained both
relationships, explaining to Rose that he was just being nice to
Clara so she would lend him the car.
On one
particular evening in February 1988, he rode his bike to Clara's and
took the car and drove around until he reached Lake Avenue near the
Genesee River. It was an industrial area well known for it's cheap
prostitutes and drug dealers. As he drove slowly down the street, a
woman called Dorothy "Dotsie" Blackburn signalled him to stop. When
he pulled over she asked him if he wanted a "date." He agreed and
she directed him to a car park behind a warehouse. He told her that
he wanted to have mutual oral sex and paid her thirty dollars. She
then undressed and complied with his request.
Shawcross later
described that at that point, the woman bit him on the penis,
drawing blood. He said he became incensed and bit her vagina in
retribution and squeezed her throat until she lost consciousness.
He them attempted to stem the flow of blood from his damaged organ
and tied the woman up with articles of her clothing before driving
out of town along State Route 104 to an area in Northampton Park
called Salmon River, one of his favourite fishing spots.
He told her
that he was going to rape her and she began taunting him and calling
him names. He threatened to kill her but she continued the name
calling until he took her neck in his hands and crushed the breath
out of her. He sat in the car with her body until nearly midnight
then calmly carried her through the snow to the river bridge and
dropped her body into the icy river below. Walking back to the car,
he drove back into Rochester and drove up and down Lake Avenue
looking for any sign that indicated that "Dotsie" had been missed.
Satisfied that he hadn't been observed he went to a nearby coffee
shop to relax. After an hour or so, he returned to the car,
collected the woman's clothes and other property and threw them into
a dumpster bin.
The
following morning, after cleaning up the car, he returned it to
Clara and rode his bike home. Because of his normally erratic
behaviour neither of the women in his life realised anything
different in his demeanour. In the following months, Arthur became
a Lake Avenue regular and was well known by the local prostitutes as
"Mitch." On March 24, police found the body of "Dotsie" Blackburn
floating in the river some distance downstream from the area where
she had been dumped. Her body was well preserved by the icy waters
but the water had also removed any evidence that might link her with
her killer. The one thing that they did notice about the body was
the chunk that had been torn from the woman's vagina.
Arthur
Shawcross had contained the urge to kill for several months but when
his boss learned why Arthur had been in prison and sacked him, it
triggered off his next wave of violence. The second victim was a
part-time prostitute named Anna Steffen who Shawcross had picked up
and taken to the river near Driving Park Bridge.
Shawcross claimed
she had offered him sex for twenty dollars but when he was unable to
get an erection she began to make fun of him. He became angry and
punched her to the ground. Trying to get away from him she crawled
into the water but he went in after her and held her under the water
by the throat until she drowned. He later told police that he
couldn't be bothered trying to conceal her body and just let it
float downstream. It later became caught up in debris downstream
where, because of the warmer conditions, it rapidly decomposed.
From that time on he tried to resist the temptation to kill and got
another job working nights packing salads for a company called G & G
Food Services.
He didn't
kill again until June 1989. His third victim was different to the
first two in that she wasn't a prostitute. She was a
fifty-eight-year-old homeless woman named Dorothy Keller. Shawcross
had met Dorothy when she worked as a waitress in a diner that he
frequented. The two struck up a friendship, which had quickly
turned into an affair. On a fine afternoon, Arthur was on his way
to the river to fish when he stopped to talk to Keller. When she
found out where he was going she asked if he would take her with
him, he agreed.
According to Shawcross, they spent the morning
fishing and making love until around midday when it started to
rain. They huddled under a crude shelter that he had built and
shortly after got into an argument about her stealing money and
about his relationships with Clara and Rose. He claims that when
she threatened to tell the other women about their affair he became
angry and picked up a small log and beat her on the side of the head
killing her instantly. After hiding her body under a fallen tree he
returned home. He later told police that he returned to the spot
several months later and removed the skull and dumped it in the
river.
Fishermen
eventually found Keller's remains but Shawcross was never connected
with the woman even though he had been seen with her regularly and
often went to the fishing spot where he had left her body.
The next to
die was another Lake Avenue prostitute named Patty Ives. He claims
that she offered him sex for twenty-five dollars when he approached
the same diner where Dorothy Keller had worked. He agreed and they
went to a construction site and lay down on a mound of earth. While
they were having sex, Shawcross says that he caught Ives trying to
remove his wallet and pushed her hard against the ground. When she
began to cry he anally raped her and began strangling her until she
lay still.
He hid her
body under some scraps of construction material and waited until
dark and went home.
Two months
later he killed another prostitute called Frances Brown in similar
circumstances except that in this instance he claims to have choked
Brown with his penis while having oral sex and continued to have sex
with her body after she died.
When he
dumped her body down a nearby embankment, so much debris was dragged
down with it that police thought the body had been covered
intentionally.
Following
Brown's murder, the media began to pick up on the story of the
murders of five Rochester women within eighteen months calling the
unknown perpetrator, "The Rochester Nightstalker," "The Rochester
Strangler" and "The Genesee River Killer."
Some even
suggested that the crimes were similar to the Green River killings
in Seattle and speculated that the killer had merely changed
localities.
For his
sixth victim, Shawcross again chose someone close to home. June
Stotts was a friend of Arthur and Rose and a regular visitor to
their home. She was also mildly retarded. Shawcross had seen June
sitting near the river on a warm November day and asked her to go
for a ride with him. She gratefully accepted and they drove down to
a local beach where they played on the sand and fed the birds before
they walked to a deserted area and lay down on the ground to make
love.
At some point in their lovemaking Shawcross claims that he
made an innocent comment about her not being a virgin and she
started screaming. He then held his hand over her mouth to silence
her but soon realised that he had suffocated her. He then cut her
open with his knife so that she would decompose quicker and covered
her with a blanket and brush and left her. He later claimed to have
removed her vagina and some of her organs and ate them.
Arthur was
now on a roll and in the same month picked up Maria Welch from Lake
Avenue and took her to a small beach near the banks of the Genesee
River where they argued over a suitable price before they began
having sex. Again he claims that she tried to take his wallet and
he strangled her. He later changed his story and told investigators
that he had become angry and killed her when he realised that she
was menstruating. He drove further down the road next to the river
and dumped her body in some bushes.
On November
11, police investigators from the sixty strong serial crimes unit
identified the body of Frances Brown. Incredibly, no one in the
newly formed task force uncovered the fact that a known sex offender
and child killer who was still on parole was living in their midst.
Two weeks later, on November 23, while police were examining the
decomposing body of June Stotts, Shawcross killed again. As before,
the pattern was set. He picked Darlene Trippi up from the Lake
Avenue area and drove to an isolated car park. After the money was
paid they indulged in oral sex but Shawcross failed to get an
erection. She became frustrated and called him names and he choked
her until she lay dead under him. He dumped her body in open
woodland.
The following month, he killed Elizabeth Gibson in a
similar fashion when she got into his car to keep warm while he was
getting coffee from a diner. They had oral sex in the car and
again, he claimed that she tried to take his wallet and he got angry
and strangled her. Shawcross later told police that she had
struggled so hard that she had broken the gearshift in his car. He
disposed of Gibson's body in a new area near Wayne County, as he
feared that the police were getting too close.
Two more
weeks passed and even though the police were out in force in the
Lake Avenue area, Arthur Shawcross picked up an attractive girl
named June Cicero and took her to another isolated area and
attempted sex with her before strangling her. Virtually right under
the noses of the investigating police, "The Genesee River Killer"
had struck again. This time he dumped the body off a bridge over
the Salmon River.
Two days later he returned to the dumpsite with a
small hand saw and cut the vagina from her frozen body and ate it.
It is not hard to see that, just as the prison psychiatrists had
detected, Arthur Shawcross lived in a fantasy world and made up
these fanciful accounts of his numerous "accidental" murders to hide
the fact that he was a sadistic killer who could only "get off" when
he was subjecting his victims to pain and anguish which eventually
resulted in their deaths.
The final
victim was another prostitute only this time Arthur chose a black
woman named Felicia Stephens. In later interviews he stated that he
could not recall any details of Felicia's murder only that she was
black and he had strangled her and dumped her body near those of
Jean Cicero and Dorothy Blackburn. It was this desire to keep the
bodies where he could find them again that led to his capture.
Lunch By
the River
On
Wednesday, January 3 1990, he drove to Salmon Creek in Northampton
Park to visit Jean Cicero's body. He was aroused at the thought of
having sex with her corpse. Arthur hadn't been following the
progress of the serial task force that had become prime news on TV
and in the papers. If he had, he would have known that police
surveillance in and around the Northampton Park area had increased
dramatically. He was happy that there were no cars parked where he
wanted to stop on a bridge overlooking the creek so he could view
Jean's body while he ate his lunch, a salad that he had prepared at
work.
What he did
not know was that a police helicopter that had been checking the
Salmon River had not only seen his car parked on the bridge but also
the outline of the body under the ice. As the helicopter
approached, Shawcross left the area and drove along Highway 31 and
turned left at Route 259 heading toward the town of Spencerport with
the helicopter following his every move. The helicopter crew then
called in two patrol cars to follow the car and intercept it. They
followed it to an address in Spencerport where the car was parked
and Shawcross got out and entered the Wedgewood Adult Home where his
wife worked.
The police
entered the home and asked the attendant about the man who had just
entered and was told that he had gone down into the basement. The
police followed and approached Shawcross in the basement and asked
for identification. He produced a photo I.D. and asked what the
police wanted. They then asked him to step outside to answer some
questions. Later he was interviewed in the car by Paul DeCillis,
one of the task force investigators and asked why he had been at
Salmon Creek. Shawcross answered that he had been out driving and
stopped to urinate but when he saw the helicopter he decided to sit
in the car and urinate in a bottle instead.
For several
hours, Detective DeCillis questioned Arthur Shawcross extensively
about his movements that morning but found that Shawcross had a
pretty convincing story. While they were talking, Shawcross told
him about his earlier conviction for the child murders. DeCillis
continued to ask him questions about his wives, his jobs, his sexual
habits and even asked him details of the attacks on Jack Blake and
Karen Hill. Throughout the questioning he was completely
cooperative even though he had not been arrested and was talking to
the police voluntarily.
Later that
night he was released and he went home, unaware that his house was
under constant surveillance. The following morning the detectives
picked him up again to "clarify some inconsistencies in his story."
Again, Shawcross complied with their request and went with them.
They drove him to an area near a golf course where he had supposedly
had a liaison with a prostitute who had testified that he had often
frequented the Lake Avenue area picking up prostitutes. When Arthur
agreed with the assertion he was asked to accompany the detectives
to their office where an official interrogation was conducted.
Later the
same evening, Arthur Shawcross positively identified photographs of
the eleven victims and confessed to their murders. He then
accompanied the police to the various gravesites and late that night
after twelve straight hours of interrogation, Arthur Shawcross was
officially charged with the Genesee River killings.
Epilogue
At his
arraignment, Arthur Shawcross followed his court appointed attorneys
advice and pleaded innocent on all charges and it was strongly
rumoured that he would raise an insanity defence. For the next
several months, Arthur was given a battery of tests by numerous
psychiatrists one of which, Dr. Kraus, compiled an extensive report
which suggested that Arthur Shawcross was "an emotionally unstable,
learning disabled, genetically impaired, biochemically disordered,
neurologically damaged individual, psychologically alienated from
significant others during his entire life, venting his frustration
and rage, mixed with fear and defiance in a lifetime of ever more
violent and destructive aggression, which ultimately turned to
overpowering murderous fury."
The trial,
although extensively covered by print and television media, was a
boring foregone conclusion with the state rolling out a virtual
plethora of psychiatric specialists including Dr. Park Dietz who was
well known for his consultive work with the F.B.I. The only defence
witness was Dr Dorothy Otnow Lewis who testified that Shawcross had
been "hideously traumatised" as a child, which had left him with a
multiple personality disorder. She also cited post-traumatic stress
disorder caused by his war experiences as a root cause for his
behaviour. Shawcross also played his part and sat in court like a
zombie day after day trying to give his impression of advanced
psychosis to the jury. They were less than impressed and took just
six-and-a-half hours to return a unanimous guilty verdict and
recommend a sentence of two hundred and fifty years in jail.
Shawcross
in prison
The latest
mention of Arthur Shawcross came in September 1999 when he was found
to be selling his paintings and autographs on the Internet from
within Fallsburg prison in New York.
The New York
State Department of Correctional Services temporarily suspended his
art privileges after learning that his artwork and autographs were
listed for sale on eBay, the Internet auction service. He received
disciplinary actions for the breach, which included being locked in
his cell for extended periods. As always the question is why? But
while psychiatrists around the world battle with the question of the
motivation and emotional triggers that caused a man like Arthur
Shawcross to kill and keep killing, perhaps we would be better
served by pondering the other why. Why, when the prison authorities
were blatantly aware of his fragile mental state after having served
an extended period in jail for a brutal double murder, did they
release him back into society and then have the audacity to impose
incredible parole restrictions on him in the hope that the parole
board and local police departments could succeed where they had
dismally failed?
We may never
know but one thing is certain, the deaths of eleven women stand as a
testament to their gross incompetence.
Bibliography
The
reference material for this story was drawn from the following
sources:
"The
Misbegotten Son," by Jack Olsen. - Bantam Doubleday Dell Publishing
Group, New York.
"Arthur
Shawcross: The Genesee River Killer" by Dr. Joel Norris. - Windsor
Publishing Group, New York.
"The New
Encyclopedia of Serial Killers," by Brian Lane and Wilfred Gregg. -
Headline Book Publishing, London.
"Overkill -
Mass Murder and Serial Killing Exposed," by James Alan Fox and Jack
Levin. - Bantam Doubleday Dell Publishing Group, New York.
"Journey
into Darkness," by John Douglas and Mark Olshaker. - Random House,
London.
"Serial
Murderers and their Victims - Second Edition," by Eric W. Hickey. -
Wadsworth Publishing Company, Belmont California.
"Whoever
Fights Monsters," by Robert K. Ressler and Tom Shachtman. - Simon
and Schuster, London.
"Mindhunter,"
by John Douglas and Mark Olshaker. - William Heinemann, London.