Murderpedia has thousands of hours of work behind it. To keep creating
new content, we kindly appreciate any donation you can give to help
the Murderpedia project stay alive. We have many
plans and enthusiasm
to keep expanding and making Murderpedia a better site, but we really
need your help for this. Thank you very much in advance.
Sheets was
sentenced to death on the basis of
Barnett's taped confession (and
Sheets's own testimony, which the
jury found unbelievable). The
Nebraska supreme court reversed his
conviction because Sheets's lawyer
had not been able to cross-examine
the dead Barnett. Sheets walked.
The lead police
investigator in the case called the
result a "travesty," but it was
probably the right legal call. What
it wasn't was an "exoneration" of
Sheets.
Jeremy Sheets was
released after the U.S. Supreme
Court declined to hear an appeal of
a Nebraska Supreme Court decision
overturning his conviction.
Prosecutors then dropped the charges
against him. (Associated Press,
6/14/01).
In September,
2000, the Nebraska high court
unanimously ruled that a tape
recording made by an alleged
accomplice who committed suicide
prior to the trial was the kind of
statement deemed "highly suspect," "inherently
unreliable," and hence inadmissible
without the opportunity for Sheets
to cross-examine. (Nebraska v Sheets,
618 N.W.2d 117 (2000)).
The statements (later
recanted) were made by Adam Barnett,
who was arrested for the 1992 rape
and murder of the same victim as in
Sheets' case. Barnett confessed to
the crime and implicated Sheets.
In exchange for
the taped statement, Barnett
received a plea bargain in which he
avoided a charge of first degree
murder, did not have an additional
weapons charge filed, and received a
commitment for his safety while
incarcerated. Barnett's statement
was the key evidence used against
Sheets at trial. (State v. Sheets,
618 N.W.2d 117 (Neb. 2000) and
Associated Press, 6/12/01).
The United States Supreme Court declined to review
the case of Jeremy Sheets, a white man sentenced to death for the 1992
racially motivated murder of a 17-year-old black girl, meaning he may go
free. The Nebraska Supreme Court had ordered a new trial for Mr. Sheets,
ruling that a recording of a co-defendant's statement implicating him
should not have been played for jurors because the co-defendant had
committed suicide and could not be cross-examined. But the prosecutor
said the remaining evidence would not allow him to pursue a new trial.
Mr. Sheets could be released in three weeks.
Jeremy Sheets
On June 13, 2001 Jeremy Sheets was released after
prosecutors decided not to retry his case. Sheets had been sentenced to
death for the September 23, 1992 kidnaping and murder of Kenyatta Bush.
The Nebraska Supreme Court overturned Sheets' 1997 conviction in
2000. It ruled that prosecutors should not have been allowed to use
their key piece of evidence - a taped confession by Adam Barnett in
which Barnett said that he and Sheets kidnapped, raped and killed Bush
because she was black.
Barnett hanged himself in jail after giving the statement and before
Sheets' trial started, so Sheets was unable to confront his accuser, the
state court ruled. On Monday May 14, 2001 the U.S. Supreme Court
declined to hear an appeal of the state court's decision.
LINCOLN, Neb. -- Former death-row inmate Jeremy
Sheets grinned as he was released from prison Tuesday, three years
after he was ordered to die for the kidnapping, rape and killing of
an Omaha girl.
Sheets, 27, walked out the front door of Nebraska
State Penitentiary in a T-shirt and blue jeans and wearing a crew cut.
Accompanied by prison guards, he said nothing as he quickly walked past
reporters before he got into a minivan with Iowa plates that immediately
drove away.
He became the first person released from Nebraska's
death row in 88 years.
His release came after the Nebraska Supreme Court
threw out a taped statement used to convict Sheets in the murder of 17-year-old
honor student Kenyatta Bush.
The U.S. Supreme Court last month refused to hear the
state's appeal of the court decision. Without the taped statement,
prosecutors said they did not have enough other evidence to proceed with
another trial.
The taped statement implicating Sheets was made by co-defendant
Adam Barnett shortly before he killed himself in jail.
Sheets was set free shortly after the Douglas County
District Court signed off on his release Tuesday.
''It's painful to have to do this. I'm convinced we
tried and convicted the appropriate person,'' said Douglas County
Attorney Jim Jansen, who prosecuted the case against Sheets.
Sheets is the first person to be released from
Nebraska's death row since 1913 when Jay O'Hearn was furloughed. Prison
and court records do not indicate what happened in that case.
State prison officials did not know where Sheets went
after his release. He previously had told news reporters that he planned
to spend some time with his parents in Colorado.
During his three years on death row, Sheets appeared
on billboards and in magazines worldwide as part of an advertising
campaign against the death penalty by Italian fashion company Benetton.
Nebraska's high court said that allowing jurors to
hear Barnett's taped statement violated Sheets' constitutional right to
confront his accuser because defense lawyers could not cross-examine
Barnett.
Barnett gave his statement to police as part of a
plea agreement to escape a possible death sentence. In his statement, he
said Sheets, who is white, attacked Bush because she was black.
The state's prosecutor had argued that Barnett's
statement to police was given voluntarily and in the presence of his
attorney. The prosecutor also said Barnett knew details of Bush's death
that only the killers would know, including the condition and location
of Bush's body and the exact cause of death.
Bush was kidnapped outside Omaha North High School on
her way to class Sept. 23, 1992. Her throat was slashed and her body was
dumped in a wooded area north of Omaha.
Barnett told police that he and Sheets, after a night
of dropping acid, decided to rape a black woman to get revenge on black
men who date white women. He said Sheets stabbed Bush after she lost
consciousness.
In his 1997 trial, Sheets took the witness stand and
denied that he hated blacks or had any involvement in the 1992 killing
of Kenyatta Bush.
''I've never killed anybody,'' he said.
Sheets' release leaves 10 people on Nebraska's death
row.