Murderpedia has thousands of hours of work behind it. To keep creating
new content, we kindly appreciate any donation you can give to help
the Murderpedia project stay alive. We have many
plans and enthusiasm
to keep expanding and making Murderpedia a better site, but we really
need your help for this. Thank you very much in advance.
Eric Stanley GRAHAM
Early
life
Graham was born and raised in Longford, Kokatahi, New
Zealand. He then moved to Kowhitirangi, an agricultural district 12
miles from Hokitika in the South Island where he worked as a farmer and
where he lived with his wife and two children. He became argumentative
and alienated from the community from 1938 onwards, alleging that
neighbours were poisoning his cows. As income from his farm dropped he
fell into debt and his behaviour towards others became more threatening.
His behaviour took a turn for the worse and he started threatening and
abusing neighbours passing his house. Graham and his wife practiced
target shooting out the back of their home in the middle of the night.
Graham was an expert marksman and had an assortment of firearms.
The day of the
rampage
On October 8, 1941 Graham confronted a neighbour with
a rifle. Later that morning Constable Edward Best, 27, attempted to
discuss the matter with Graham but backed off with Graham pointing two
rifles out the window at him. Best retreated to Hokitika for back-up and
returned to the farm with Sergeant William Cooper, 43, and Constables
Frederick Jordan, 26, and Percy Tulloch, 35.
Graham fired at them as they approached the house,
and Sergeant Cooper and Constables Jordan and Tulloch were killed
instantly, Cooper having at least four bullet wounds in his body.
Constable Best was also shot and died three days later
Graham also shot an agricultural instructor, George
Ridley, who came to his door, and fled his house. He returned the next
evening and killed home guardsmen Richard Coulson and Gregory Hutchison
in a firefight.
More than 100 police and army personnel searched
dense bush for Graham for 12 days, with orders to shoot on sight if they
found Graham still armed. On October 20 an injured Graham was shot by
Auckland Constable James Quirke as he walked out of the bush carrying
his rifle. He died the next day in hospital. Constable Quirke reported
Graham told him he was intending to give up that night.
Graham met his wife, Dorothy McCoy, when she moved
from Rakaia in the late 1920s to work at the Longford Hotel. They
married in Christchurch on 22 December 1930, living there for six months
before moving to a dairy property at Koiterangi (Kowhitirangi) on the
West Coast. They were to have two children.
Through the late 1930s Graham maintained reasonably
good relations with neighbours although he and his wife took little part
in the district’s social life. By 1940 the Graham family was under
severe financial pressure, having had cream condemned by the Westland Co-operative
Dairy Company and having incurred debt from a venture into cattle
breeding. William Jamieson, a neighbour and member of the dairy company’s
board of directors, was aware of the decline in Graham’s cream, and
noted a corresponding deterioration in Graham. ‘In himself he was
different. I thought he might be slipping mentally’. Graham thought he
was being persecuted by the police for not surrendering a requisitioned
rifle, and by his neighbours, some of whom he believed were poisoning
his cows. His wife shared his suspicions.
Matters came to a head on 8 October 1941. Constable
Edward Best was called to Koiterangi because of Graham’s threatening
behaviour, which included aiming a rifle at a neighbour. Best visited
Graham, recorded the complaints of his neighbours and went to Hokitika
for assistance. He then returned to Graham’s house accompanied by
Sergeant William Cooper, and Constables Percy Tulloch and Frederick
Jordan. Graham met the policemen at his front door. The details of what
followed are unknown, but Cooper, Jordan and Tulloch were shot dead;
Best suffered grave wounds from which he later died. Also shot on
arriving at the Graham house was an agricultural instructor, George
Ridley, who died of his wounds in March 1943. Graham fled the property,
returning the following evening. In an exchange of shots, home guardsmen
Richard Coulson and Gregory Hutchison were hit. Coulson died immediately
and Hutchison the following day. Graham was wounded but made his escape
in the darkness.
The manhunt that followed was overseen by
Commissioner of Police Denis Cummings and involved hundreds of police,
soldiers, home guards and volunteers. On the evening of 20 October,
after 12 nights’ hiding in forested hill country, Graham was sighted by
Constable James Quirke, of Auckland, approaching the adjacent Growcott
farm. The general instruction was that Graham, if armed, was to be shot
on sight. Quirke later told the coroner: ‘I was quite satisfied as to
his identity and the fact that he was carrying a rifle. I fired at him …
and wounded him and subsequently found that he had a rifle and a .32
calibre automatic pistol’. According to Quirke, Graham told him, ‘I am
done. I was going to chuck it tonight, I am done, I have paid in full’.
Graham died of his wounds in Westland Hospital in
Hokitika the following day and was buried in the local cemetery. On the
rim of the cement pad is one word: ‘Stanley’. The Graham home was burnt
to the ground four days later and Dorothy Graham and her children left
the area. There was some public feeling that Graham could have been
captured without being fatally shot and he has been romanticised as a
man alone against the world. Several novels, portraying him as a victim
of society, and the 1981 film Bad blood , have been based on his
story.