Murderpedia has thousands of hours of work behind it. To keep creating
new content, we kindly appreciate any donation you can give to help
the Murderpedia project stay alive. We have many
plans and enthusiasm
to keep expanding and making Murderpedia a better site, but we really
need your help for this. Thank you very much in advance.
Editor's note: This is the last of a two-part
story preceding the execution of Dominique Green, a Texas Death Row
inmate whose trial is drawing attention from both sides of the issue.
The victim's family is also asking for a reprieve which is unique.
Dominique Green was convicted and given the death
penalty in 1993 for the shooting death and robbery of Andrew
Lastrapes Jr. on Oct. 14, 1992, in the parking lot of a convenience
store in Houston. Lastrapes was one of 10 people robbed during a
three-day crime spree authorities said involved Green.
If his sentence is carried out Wednesday, Green
will be the 18th Texas Death Row inmate to die this year and the
fifth this month.
But there are several people holding out hope for
Green, including the victim's family, wife Bernatte Luckett-Lastrapes,
and sons, Andrew and Andre, Nobel Peace Prize laureate Desmond Tutu
who visited Green on death row earlier this year, and historian and
best-selling author Thomas Cahill.
Green's lawyers have submitted the case to state
and federal courts, and are anxiously awaiting a decision. In a
motion for extraordinary relief filed in the Court of Criminal
Appeals, attorney David Dow cited racial bias and incompetence on
behalf of the Houston Police Department Crime Lab as reasons for the
state to extend a reprieve to Green.
Crime lab accountability
Dow said the HPD Crime Lab's failed DNA/Serology
audits as of late 2002 should have an affect in Green's case.
Ballistics evidence states the bullet recovered from the shooting
compare to the tech 9 weapon found in the vehicle Green was in at
the time of his arrest days after the Lastrapes shooting. There was
no mention in police reports or in the trial that Green's
fingerprints were on the weapon.
There is also the question of unknown evidence in
280 boxes recently uncovered at the police department potentially
pertaining to thousands of cases from 1979-91. In the motion, Dow
cites HPD Police Chief Harold Hurtt as saying, "It is very
significant in the fact that we don't know what we have in those
boxes. Were they cases that are open? We don't know yet. The bottom
line is to ensure that justice is done - whether it's proving people
innocent or convicting others."
Dow states, "The firearms division of the HPD
crime laboratory provided corroborative evidence for the state in
its case against Dominique Green. ... No criminal conviction in
Texas may be supported only on evidence provided by accomplices.
Specifically, the corroborative evidence must connect the defendant
with the offense committed." (Texas Code of Criminal Proceedings)
"... Mr. Green's conviction and sentence may not stand on this
corroborative evidence in light of what we already know about
dubious ballistics examinations being performed in the HPD crime lab."
Assistant Harris County District Attorney Jack
Roady told the Houston Chronicle that no DNA or serologic testing
was used in the case, and all of the evidence gathered in the case
against Green was accounted for. He said ballistics testing was not
an issue.
"The problems at HPD don't relate to this case,
so it's not an issue here," Roady said. Dow countered that statement
in The Huntsville Item in a phone interview Thursday. "The
ballistics evidence is not at all definitive because the crime lab
has been proven incompetent," he said.
Why is the victim's family involved?
In written and videotaped affidavits, Lastrapes
wife and sons pleaded for reprieve. Bernatte has also written to
Governor Rick Perry in hopes of giving Green a second chance at life.
"During the robbery of my husband, did they intend to kill him," she
said in the affidavit. "Did it happen in the struggle and when
Andrew's pants pocket was torn off? I don't know. I do know that the
execution of Dominique will not bring back my husband. The sentence
was too harsh. That young man deserves another chance at life."
Green explained in an interview from death row
that his life has changed since being in prison, and in that vein,
he has become somewhat of a teacher and consult to others on death
row. "I went on death watch (Oct. 13), that's when they chronicle my
last 14 days," he said. "They'll watch where I go, what I eat and
who I talk to, and if I choose to have a last statement, I'll have
to put it into context in the last 6
to 10 minutes of my life. Unfortunately, it will be the last days
that matter, not the last 12 years."
Green said he is grateful for the Lastrapes
family for seeing beyond the prison walls. They have given him
strength and hope. "I am the opposite of who I was when I came here,"
he said. "The last 12 years, as a person, I've become to some extent,
one who understands. I chose to come here and live. I think I've
learned, stepped into myself, and all that is trying to be taken
away from me. I have made a difference here.
"The Lastrapes family gave me that chance
basically because they wanted to fight for me. I only hope I am able
to make them proud. The last thing I want them to have is another
dead body."
Bernatte wrote in a letter to the Texas Board of
Pardons and Paroles, stating that she felt the trial in 1993 was
unfair in a number of ways, and Green's family situation should have
some influence on the state's decision. "The loss of my husband,
Andrew, was devastating to me and my family," she wrote. "However, I
don't believe that Dominique should have received the death penalty.
He came from a very abusive family situation. His mother was
mentally ill and did not help him at all during his trial. In fact,
I saw her sleeping on a bench at the trial! Dominique's father did
not help either -- he was nowhere to be seen.
"... God teaches us that we should forgive one
another as he has forgiven us. All of us have forgiven Dominique for
what happened and want to give him another chance at life. Everyone
deserves another chance! ... For the love of God and justice, please
commute his sentence to life."
Green said he has only the utmost respect for the
Lastrapes family, and said he will do whatever he can to thank them.
"I don't want to die," he said. "If given a chance, I will use the
education this place has given me. Even places like this can create
good people. What hurts me more than anything is that I did not
commit this crime. I want the Lastrapes family to know that I'm
sorry they had to see a trial like mine -- to see how unfair it was.
I am grateful their loss did not fill them with so much hate."