Murderpedia has thousands of hours of work behind it. To keep creating
new content, we kindly appreciate any donation you can give to help
the Murderpedia project stay alive. We have many
plans and enthusiasm
to keep expanding and making Murderpedia a better site, but we really
need your help for this. Thank you very much in advance.
Fritz Haarmann
(October 25, 1879 – April 15, 1925) was a notorious serial killer born
in Hannover, Germany.
From 1919 to 1924, Haarmann committed
at least 24 murders, and possibly many more. Haarmann's victims were
young male vagrants who hung around railway stations, whom Haarmann
would lure back to his apartment and then kill them by biting through
their throats in a kind of sexual frenzy. Rumours had it that Haarmann
would then peddle meat from the bodies of his victims as black market
pork, but there was no evidence. His accomplice, Hans Grans, sold the
clothing of his victims, and Haarmann claimed Grans urged him to kill
handsome boys, but was otherwise not involved in the murders.
Haarmann was eventually apprehended
when numerous skeletal remains, which he had dumped into the river Leine,
washed up. His trial was very spectacular; it was one of the first major
media events in Germany. There were no concepts or expressions for his
crimes; he was called a "werewolf", a "vampire" and a "sexual
psychopath" at the same time. But apart from the cruelty of what
Haarmann had admittedly done, even more scandalous — shaking German
society at the very core — was the involvement of the police in the
case: Haarmann cheated on thieves and dealers. He had also been used as
an informant by the police who failed to identify Haarmann as the
murderer.
Haarmann was beheaded, though it was
not entirely clear if he would rather have to be locked up in an asylum
for being in a state of diminished responsibility. But public opinion
was heated and would not have approved of Haarmann just being locked
away. Haarmann was found guilty and executed, even though serious doubts
about his state of mind remained. Grans received a 12-year sentence.
What became of him after his release is not known.
Haarmann became known as "The Butcher
of Hanover." A film titled The Tenderness of the Wolves was
released in Germany in 1973 dramatizing Haarmann's crimes. It starred
Kurt Raab as the killer and featured Rainer Werner Fassbinder in a minor
role. Another film based on the murder spree, Der Totmacher (The
Deadmaker; 1995), starred Götz George as Haarmann. It was based on
the protocols of the psychiatric examinations of Haarmann by Erich
Schultze, one of the main psychiatric experts in the trial.
The classic film M, directed
by Fritz Lang and starring Peter Lorre, was inspired by Haarman's
crimes, as well as those of Düsseldorf child killer Peter Kürten (Haarman
is mentioned by name in the film, along with another well-known German
serial killer, Karl Grossmann).
The American heavy metal band Macabre
have made two songs about him: "Fritz Haarmann, the Butcher" on Gloom
and "Fritz Haarmann, Der Metzger" on Murder Metal.
Literature
Tartar, Maria [1995]. Lustmord. Sexual Murder in
Weimar Germany.
Princeton UP.
Thomas Kailer: Werewölfe, Triebtäter, minderwertige Psychopathen.
Bedingungen von Wissensgenerierung. Der Fall Haarmann. In:
Carsten Kretschmann (Hg.): Wissenspopularisierung. Berlin 2003, S.
323-359.
Friedrich "Fritz" Haarmann (October 25, 1879 –
April 15, 1925) was a notorious serial killer born in Hanover, Germany,
who is believed to be responsible for the murder of 27 boys and young
men.
Early
life
Fritz Haarmann was born on October 25, 1879, the
sixth child of poor parents. Fritz was a quiet child who shunned many
boys' activities such as sports and preferred to play with his sisters'
toys. He was also a poor scholar.
At the age of 16, at the urging of his parents,
Haarmann enrolled in a military academy at Neu Breisach. He initially
adapted to military life, and performed well as a training soldier.
After just one year in the academy, however, he began to suffer seizures
and was discharged for medical reasons.
Haarmann returned to Hanover and took employment in a
cigar factory. He was arrested in 1898 for molesting children, but a
psychologist declared Haarmann was mentally unfit to stand trial, and he
was sent to a mental institution indefinitely. Six months later,
Haarmann escaped and fled to Switzerland, where he worked for two years
before he returned to Germany.
He again enlisted in the military, this time under an
alias, but in 1902, he was again discharged under medical terms. He was
awarded a full military pension, and returned to live with his family,
and took employment in the small business his father had established.
After an argument with his father, Ollie, led to a
violent fight between them both, Haarmann was arrested, charged with
assault and again sent for psychiatric evaluation. This time, a doctor
did not diagnose Haarmann as mentally unstable. A court discharged
Haarmann and he again returned to live with his family. Shortly
afterwards, Haarmann attempted to open a small shop, but the business
soon became bankrupt.
Criminal career
For the next decade, Haarmann lived as a petty thief,
burglar and con-man. He was frequently arrested and served several short
prison sentences. He gradually began to establish a relationship with
Hanover Police as an informer, largely as a means of redirecting the
attention of the Police from himself, and later admitted that the Police
began to view him as a reliable source of information regarding
Hanover's criminal network.
In 1914, Haarmann was convicted of a series of thefts
and frauds and was imprisoned just as the First World War began. Upon
his release in 1918, he was struck by the poverty of the German Nation
as a result of the loss the nation had suffered in the Great War. The
country was bankrupt. Fritz Haarmann immediately reverted to the
criminal life he had lived before he was arrested in 1914. The new state
of Germany provided him with even more opportunities to operate on the
fringes of the criminal network, and because of the increase in crime as
a result of the poverty the nation was enduring, Police again began to
rely on Haarmann as an informer.
Crimes
From 1918 to 1924, Haarmann committed at least 24
murders, although he is suspected of murdering a minimum of 27.
Haarmann's first known victim was a 17-year-old youth named Friedel
Rothe. When he disappeared, his friends told Police he was last seen
with Fritz Haarmann.
Under pressure from Rothe's family, Police raided
Haarmann's apartment, where they were dismayed to find their informer in
the company of a semi-naked teenage boy. They had no choice but to
charge Haarmann with sexual assault. Released after serving nine months,
Haarmann quickly reverted to the same lifestyle he led before his arrest.
Again, he regained the trust of the Police and became an informer.
Haarmann's subsequent victims largely consisted of
young male commuters, runaways, and, occasionally, male prostitutes who
hung around Hanover's central railway station, whom Haarmann would lure
back to his apartment and then kill by biting through their throats,
sometimes while sodomizing them. All his victims were dismembered before
they were discarded, usually in the river Leine.
The possessions of several victims were either sold
on the black market or retained by either Haarmann or his lover, Hans
Grans. Rumour had it that Haarmann would also peddle meat from the
bodies of his victims as canned black market pork, although there was
never physical evidence to confirm this. TruTV Crime Library claims he
did indeed do this.
His accomplice and live-in partner, Hans Grans, sold
the possessions of several of the victims cheaply on the black market,
and kept other possessions for himself, and Haarmann initially claimed
that although Grans knew of many of his murders, and personally urged
him to kill two of the victims so he could obtain their clothing and
personal possessions, was otherwise not involved in the murders.
Haarmann was eventually apprehended when numerous
skeletal remains, which he had dumped into the river Leine, washed up
downstream in May and June 1924. The Police decided to drag the river
and discovered more than 500 human bones which were later confirmed as
having come from at least 22 separate human individuals. Suspicion
quickly fell upon Haarmann, who had convictions for molesting children
and had been connected to the disappearance of Friedel Rothe in 1918.
Haarmann was placed under surveillance and on the
night off 22 June, was observed prowling Hanover's railway station. He
was quickly arrested after trying to lure a boy to his apartment. His
apartment was searched and the walls were were found to be heavily
bloodstained. Haarmann tried to explain this as a by-product of his
illegal trade as a butcher. However, clothing and personal items known
to be possessions of several missing youths were also found in his home.
Under interrogation, Haarmann quickly confessed to
raping, killing and butchering young men since 1918. When asked how many
he had killed, Haarmann claimed 'somewhere between 50 and 70'. The
Police, however, could only connect Haarmann with the disappearance of
27 youths, and he was charged with 27 murders. It is interesting to note
that only a quarter of the personal items found in his apartment were
identified as having belonged to any of the victims.
Trial
Haarmann's trial began on 4 December, 1924. Haarmann
was charged with the murder of 27 boys and young men who had disappeared
between 1918 and June that year. The trial was very spectacular; it was
one of the first major media events in Germany. The term "serial killer"
had not yet been coined, and the public and press were lost for words to
describe the case; he was simultaneously referred to as "werewolf", a "vampire",
and the "The Wolf Man".
Apart from the cruelty of what Haarmann had
admittedly done, even more scandalous - shaking German society to the
core - was the involvement of the police in the case: Haarmann was a
police informant who frequently gave up other criminals to investigators;
until Haarmann was arrested, it had never occurred to police that the
serial killer they were looking for was well-known to them and right
under their nose, even though some of the victims were last seen in his
company. The trial lasted barely two weeks.
On 19 December, Haarmann was found guilty of 24 of
the 27 murders and sentenced to death. He was acquitted of three murders
which he denied, even though the personal possessions of the boys were
either in his possession or acquaintances of his at the time of his
arrest. He was beheaded with a guillotine on April 25, 1925.
Grans was initially found guilty of enticement to
murder in the case of Adolf Hannappel, an apprentice who vanished from
Hanover's railway station on November 11, 1923. Witnesses had seen Grans,
in the company of Haarmann, pointing to Hannappel, Haarmann claimed this
was one of two murders committed upon the insistence of Grans and for
this reason, Grans was sentenced to death. The discovery of a letter
from Haarmann declaring Grans's innocence later led to a second trial
and a 12-year prison sentence for Grans. After serving his time, Grans
continued to live in Hanover until his death around 1980.
The remains of Haarmann's victims were buried
together in a communal grave.
After his execution, Haarmann's head was preserved in
a jar by scientists to examine the structure of his brain. Haarmann's
head is now kept at the Göttingen medical school.
The case stirred much discussion in Germany about the
death penalty, the correct approach towards mentally ill offenders,
police investigation methods, and homosexuality.
Victims
In popular culture
Haarmann became known as "The Butcher of Hannover."
The classic film M (1931), directed by Fritz Lang and starring
Peter Lorre, was inspired by Haarmann's crimes, as well as those of
Düsseldorf child killer Peter Kürten (Haarmann is mentioned by name in
the film, along with another well-known German serial killer, Karl
Grossmann).
A 1973 German film The Tenderness of the Wolves
(Die Zärtlichkeit der Wölfe) dramatizing Haarmann's crimes. It
starred Kurt Raab as the killer and featured Rainer Werner Fassbinder in
a minor role.
Another film based on the murder spree, Der
Totmacher (The Deadmaker; 1995), starred Götz George as
Haarmann. It was based on the records of the psychiatric examinations of
Haarmann by Erich Schultze, one of the main psychiatric experts in the
trial. The film's plot centers around the last days of Haarmann's life,
as he is being interviewed by a court psychiatrist
Kim Newman included Haarmann as a minor character in
his novel The Bloody Red Baron (1995), serving as a "batman" (military
servant) to Manfred von Richthofen, the "Red Baron."
In 2007, the Hannover Tourism Board (Hannover
Tourismus) caused controversy by including Haarmann in its cartoon-style
advertising calendar, along with other well-known people from the city.
The calendar became a best-seller, and the initial
print run of 20,000 calendars was expected to run out in November 2007,
rather than lasting through Christmas as planned. Allegedly, Haarmann
also featured in the 2006 issue, but the inclusion drew no attention at
the time. The 2008 calendar included a new picture of Haarman in
handcuffs. According to the Hannover Tourism Office, Haarmann will also
be included in 2009.
Beton Kopf Media, the record label behind german
electro-industrial project :Wumpscut:, uses a picture of Fritz Haarmann
as company logo (which has often been mistaken to be a picture of Adolf
Hitler due to Haarmann wearing a similar mustache).
Margit Sandemo used Haarmann for the evil character
Lynx in her Isfolket book series.
Haarmann has also been the subject of the song "Fritz
Haarman [sic] Der Metzger" ("Fritz Haarman the butcher") by death/thrash
metal band Macabre.
Wikipedia.org
Fritz Haarman:
The Butcher of Hannover
by Alexander
Gilbert
The First
Finds
After the
relative crime watershed of World War I, the 20th Century entered the
"age of sex crime." Perhaps predictably, the country where this first
became apparent was Germany, where the miseries and deprivation of
hyperinflation and food shortage made their maximum impact. Hannover, an
elegant municipality in the centre of lower Saxony, was one of the
cities most affected and it was in this sleepy hollow that Fritz
Haarmann committed one of the most extraordinary series of crimes in
modern times.
On 17th May
1924, some children playing at the edge of a river near the Herrenhausen
Castle found a human skull and, on May 29th, another washed up on the
riverbank. The town was sent in to frenzy on the 13th June when two more
skulls were found included in the river's sediment. An autopsy proved
the first two crania to be that of young people aged between 18 and 20
and the last skull found from a boy of approximately 12. In all cases, a
sharp instrument had been used to separate the skulls from the torso and
the flesh had been entirely removed.
It was initially
thought that the human remains originated from the anatomical institute
in Gottingen or that they had been flung into the river by grave-robbers
fleeing from capture. Yet these theories remained unproven and the
mystery gained further publicity when boys playing on a marshland
unearthed a sack containing human bones. It had become impossible for
the authorities to keep these grisly finds a secret and, whilst young
boys continued to be reported missing (the number in 1923 grew to almost
600), the Hannoverian population was gripped by terror. The
investigation highlighted that those missing were mostly aged between 14
and 18 and rumours were circulating that human flesh had been on sale at
the public market.
On Whit Sunday
in 1924, hundreds of people left Hannover and descended on the small
paths and bridges of the Old Town, where they started searching for
human remains. The vastness of this expedition was unprecedented in
German criminal history and was spurred on primarily by the talk of a
"werewolf" or "man-eater" at large. After a multitude of bones had been
discovered, the city's central River Leine was dammed and inspected by
policemen and municipal workers. The finds were horrific. More than 500
parts of corpses were detected, proved later to be the remains of at
least 22 people, a third aged between 15 and 20. Approximately one half
had been in the water for some time and the joints of many of the fresh
bones had smoothly cut surfaces.
Every thief and
sexual deviant in Hannover was questioned and, through dogged detective
work and a series of strange coincidences, a suspect by the name of
Friedrich (known as Fritz) Haarmann was taken to the court prison. The
man was already known to the police as both a 'dealer' in clothing and
meat and to the criminal investigation department due to his publicly
homosexual status. His appearance and mannerisms in the ultra-reserved
days of inter-war Germany redefined the conventional impression of
murder and murderers.
Haarmann was
certainly sympathetic in appearance, a simple man with a friendly, open
expression and a courteous nature. Of average height, broad and well
built, he had a rough 'full-moon' face and neat, cheerful eyes. His
features were generally small and as unprepossessing as the rest of his
appearance, the only notability a well-groomed, light brown moustache.
Fritz's expression closed up completely as soon as the atmosphere became
embarrassing and investigating officers soon realised that their suspect
was a man of deep contrast. At times cagey and calculating, yet also
talkative and hyperactive, desperately seeking sympathy and attention.
His soft, white hands moved nervously, plucking and pulling constantly
at his long fingers.
Whilst
Haarmann's body was strong and coarse, it was also slightly feminine and
his speech "was like the querulous voice of an old woman." The killer's
almost constant defensiveness and embarrassment was reflected in his
automatisms and stereotypes: the wiggling of his behind, the licking of
his lips - even the constant blinking of his eyes. Haarmann loved
'feminine' pastimes, such as baking and cooking, but would smoke strong
cigars at the same time. Although his appearance was, as the Hannover
police stated, "far from evil", Fritz Haarmann entered the record books
as Germany's most prolific killer.
A Reign of
Terror
Haarmann had
begun his crime rampage in September 1918, a time in which Germany was
suffering economic depravation and severe food shortages. A young
runaway by the name of Friedel Roth disappeared from home on the 25th,
writing to his mother only to say that he would not return home until
"she was nice again." Various friends of the boy were forthcoming with
information and eventually led the police to no.27 Cellerstrasse, the
home of a man they claimed had seduced Friedel. A detective surprised
one Fritz Haarmann in bed with a young boy and he was sentenced to nine
months' imprisonment for seducing the juvenile. Unbelievably, the rooms
were not searched and, upon interrogation five years later, Haarmann
confessed that the "murdered boy's head was stuffed behind the stove
wrapped in newspaper."
The murderer's
story was to take a dramatic turn in late 1919 when he met young Hans
Grans at the Hannover railway station. A petty thief, Hans had run away
from home and now earned his living selling old clothes at the station.
The young boy approached the openly homosexual Haarmann with the purpose
of prostituting himself for money. Remarkably, a friendship soon
developed and Grans began living with the old man, where a bond of
"madness and spiritual parasitism developed." The relationship was more
than sexual and the insane ideas that surfaced in Haarmann's conscience
always involved his young housemate.
Having carefully
avoided his jail sentence throughout 1919, Haarmann served his penance
from March until December 1920. Grans thieved his way around Germany
during this time and, upon reunion at Christmas 1920, there followed a
period of uninterrupted bliss until August 1921. The two thieves
appeared as well-dressed, decent gentlemen and earned respect amongst
the local people. Needless to say, however, the two men had more illicit
intentions and plied their trade by begging or stealing laundry and
selling it to the public.
In early 1922
the two men moved to no.8 Neuestrasse in the heart of the so-called
'haunted area". Haarmann was earning a good income; the thieving was
accompanied by social security payments (he had been declared an invalid
and therefore unable to work) and also his newfound role as a police
informer. Haarmann double-crossed everybody and became a "custodian of
the law and an information office for all criminal matters." Amazingly,
the clothes that Haarmann passed around Hannover earned him the
reputation as a benefactor of the homeless. His obvious homosexuality
further hushed up any theories people may have had as to the origin of
the garments. This was just as well as, in February 1923, Haarmann
returned to his murderous past.
The killer
detained two youths at Hannover station on the pretence that he was an
officer inspecting the waiting rooms. The less attractive lad was sent
away and Fritz Franke accompanied the phoney officer home. Haarmann
later claimed that Grans had turned up unexpectedly whilst the corpse of
Franke was still in the room. Shocked, he simply stared at Haarmann and
said, "When shall I come back again?"
The murders now
gained pace and in the following nine months 12 more young men's lives
were taken. In almost every scenario, the victim was met at the train
station and offered accommodation or work; or apprehended on the
pretence that his abductor was a police officer. This guise was used so
often that on one occasion, after a youth welfare worker had asked the
guard as to whether Haarmann was employed in the same capacity, the
station official replied, "No, he's a detective." Once in the
Neuestrasse room the boy would be killed, according to Haarmann, by
biting through his windpipe. Always with a view to his commercial
instincts, the body would then be dismembered and the clothes and meat
sold through the usual channels for smuggled goods. The useless portions
were thrown into the River Leine.
One year later,
when the items confiscated from the killer were on public display,
victim's families discovered a wealth of personal artefacts, many kept
as souvenirs and the remainder sold on through Haarmann's impressive
distribution network. On each occasion there was normally an array of
witnesses who had seen the recognisable Haarmann (and often Grans)
approach and leave with the stranger. Such was the respect that the two
men had now earned for themselves, however, that no incident was ever
reported. On one such circumstance Haarmann even had the audacity to
reply to an announcement in the paper offering a reward for information.
He appeared at the family door under the guise of a criminologist, yet
was said to have spent most of his time "laughing hysterically."
The murders
continued unabated throughout early1924, Haarmann honing his remarkable
knack of spotting disillusioned young tearaways at the station and then
removing them casually into the night. Due to the nature of the victims,
angry or estranged parents and friends often took a while to even report
the disappearance. By then, the clothing and meat of the victims had
been speedily distributed around Hannover and were practically
untraceable. Without that sort of hard evidence, the police were at a
virtual dead-end, although there were some particularly close calls. On
one such occasion, a portion of the trader's meat was taken to the
police because the buyer thought it was human flesh. The police analyst
unequivocally pronounced it pork!
The
disappearance of Erich de Vries on 14th June 1924 signalled the end of
the killer's reign. In classic fashion, it was an offer of cigarettes at
Hannover station that tempted the young lad to join the friendly
stranger in his room. It was estimated at this time that the fugitive
had murdered around 27 boys in less than 16 months: an average of almost
two a month.
Despite the
enormous manhunt now in operation, the killer had still not been
apprehended and Hannover was at the point of public outcry. By late June
of 1924 sheer terror had gripped the city and the "Werewolf" was still
on the loose.
Discovery and
Confession
Throughout the
panic that engulfed Hannover in 1924, Fritz Haarmann remained a definite
suspect. Along with every other local sex offender, he was investigated
repeatedly during May and June, yet no conclusive evidence could be
found. Meanwhile, press announcements appeared giving details of the
skulls in the hope of obtaining clues from the general public. The
quantity of skulls and corpses still being discovered was generating a
nationwide furore and a general lack of confidence in the German police
force.
With the
pressure mounting, the following course of action was agreed upon: as
Haarmann already knew the town officials, two young policemen would
arrive from Berlin at Hannover train station, pretending to be homeless
and looking for a place to stay. They would then focus on the suspect's
activities and hope to catch him in the act. Once again, however, the
killer's incredible luck conspired against them as Fritz was found
arguing with 15-year-old Karl Fromm, a boy who had spent several days at
Haarmann's apartment. Fromm was being particularly "cheeky and
supercilious" on this evening and, amazingly, Haarmann had the audacity
to report him to the railway police, claiming that he was travelling on
false papers. Once at the police station, though, Fromm turned the
tables on the older man by accusing him of sexual harassment during his
stay. Coincidentally, a member of the vice squad was at the station at
this time and, in the knowledge that the police were hoping to arrest
Haarmann, the officer decided to apprehend the suspect immediately.
Before any unnecessary suspicions could be aroused, Haarmann was taken
to prison on the morning of 23rd June.
The killer later
claimed that he had only arranged to have Fromm taken into custody
because he knew he was going to murder the boy and was afraid he would
not be able to resist the urge for much longer. If this statement is to
be believed, here was the first time that Haarmann's actions were
motivated by any moral scruples and these alleged feelings of guilt were
to prove his downfall.
Yet the case was
not nearly as clear cut as the substantial evidence would imply. Several
hundred items of clothing found in Haarmann's room or confiscated from
his acquaintances were collected and identified as the property of the
missing children, but there was no evidence to declare he had been
responsible for even one of the deaths. Haarmann inevitably claimed that
the property in his possession was due to his business of trading and
dealing in used clothes. He admitted having sexual relations with some
of the children, yet denied any knowledge of the victims' current
whereabouts and gave plausible explanations for the traces of blood
present in the garments.
The suspect once
again displayed considerable skill at avoiding taxing questions and
prolonging the inquisition. Haarmann was an astute man and,
understanding the rather secretive nature of homosexuality at the time,
subsequently knew it would be difficult for the police to obtain
incriminating evidence from his victims and their families.
One of these
victims was a boy named Robert Witzel, whose parents had continually
besieged the police since their son's disappearance on April 26th 1924.
When the first skulls were found later that year, Herr Witzel was
persuaded to examine the evidence in order to confirm that his son's
irregular jawbone was one of the discovered crania. All that was known
at this time was that Robert had visited the local circus on the night
of his disappearance with his best friend, the "sly and girlish Fritz
Kahlmeyer." Fritz, silent throughout the entire ordeal, would only say
that the boys had travelled to the circus with a "police official from
the railway station." The reason for the boy's secretive nature was
understandable; he too had been approached and sexually abused by
Haarmann, who subsequently procured him for homosexual "society
gentlemen." Items of Witzel's clothing were found in the killer's
apartment, yet Haarmann would still not confess.
The breakthrough
came when a couple walked into the police station and passed the Witzel
family who sat outside the Chief Commissioner's office. Frau Witzel
immediately recognised the man's jacket and asked as to where he had
obtained the garment. The man admitted that he had acquired the coat
from Haarmann and even provided an identification card in the trousers
bearing the name 'Witzel'. The lady accompanying him was Frau Engel,
Haarmann's landlady, who happened to be in the police station making
enquiries concerning her tenant's military pension. An enormous stroke
of luck in addition to the fabric evidence and, more importantly, one
which finally convinced Haarmann to concede defeat.
The prisoner was
consequently subjected to incessant and severe questioning, before being
given relief and encouragement commensurate with the "unburdening of the
conscience." After seven days of maniacal and emotional rages Haarmann
broke down and asked for the superintendent and examining magistrate, to
whom he would make a full confession.
The killer then
took the court officials on a murder tour of Hannover. They were shown
parts of corpses hidden in bushes, bones dredged from a lake and
skeletons concealed around the city. Inevitably, more and more people
stepped forward who had obtained clothing or meat from either Haarmann
or Grans and the evidence snowballed.
Haarmann's
character also changed during this period. He now opened up to the
investigating authorities and displayed the helpful, childish and often
sarcastic side to his nature. Only if confronted by the parents of his
victims or if discussing the act of decapitation would the killer
withdraw himself again. The general impression was that he felt relieved
of a terrible burden by being able to discuss the darkness and fear of
his abnormal sex-life. There was also a distinct degree of pride in
having duped mankind, of whom Haarmann always spoke badly.
As a result of
the information secured, Hans Grans was arrested on 8th July and the two
men met on several occasions before their trials began. At these times,
Haarmann was always troubled, where as Grans appeared indifferent to the
entire affair. Haarmann remained in the prison until 16th August, before
being sent to nearby Gottingen for psychiatric examination. The trial,
unprecedented in German judicial history, contained 60 volumes of files
and opened on 4th December 1924.
Trial and
Sentence
The trial was
conducted at the Hannover Assizes and lasted through 14 days and almost
200 witnesses. The much publicised opening decree stated that Fritz
Haarmann was "accused of killing 27 persons intentionally and
deliberately" from September 1918 to June 1924.
Haarmann
insisted on conducting his own defence and remained entirely nonchalant
throughout the trial, at one point complaining that there were too many
women in the courtroom. He was allowed remarkable freedom and was
notably immature and irresponsible, frequently interrupting the
proceedings. At one stage he demanded indignantly why there were so many
women in the court; the judge answered apologetically that he had no
power to keep them out. On another occasion, when a mother became too
distraught to give evidence about her son with clarity, Haarmann got
bored and asked to be allowed to smoke a cigar. Permission was
immediately granted.
Nonetheless, the
murderer's naive combination of fiction and fact was generally agreed as
refreshing in contrast to the legal speak of the jurists and the
confused hypocrisy of the authorities. To the journalists he once said
reproachfully, "You are not to lie; we know you are all liars," and to
the jury, "Keep it short. I want to spend Christmas in heaven with
Mother."" Haarmann was constantly amused by the proceedings and,
remarkably, even brought a smile from the public on more than one
occasion.
In contrast,
Hans Grans, accused in two cases of instigating murder, appeared as a
tough and unbreakable character. The jury subsequently branded him as
the more dangerous (yet the more innocent) of the two. Grans was
entirely focused on self-preservation, an attitude that was to prove his
downfall as Haarmann became concentrated on his devilish desire for
revenge; to take the one he loved the most with him to the dark land.
Hence, Fritz formed incredible and completely inaccurate accusations of
murder against his partner that the court whole-heartedly believed. Once
he had achieved his aim of not going to death alone, Haarmann quietened
down and let Grans do the talking.
Inevitably,
though, the most chilling tale of all came when Haarmann took the stand
to explain his murder method in the most graphic of detail.
"I never
intended to hurt those youngsters, but I knew that if I got going
something would happen and that made me cry ... I would throw myself on
top of those boys and bite through the Adam's apple, throttling them at
the same time."
Haarmann
explained the guilt he often felt at this point, regularly collapsing on
the dead body and covering the face with a cloth so "it wouldn't be
looking at me."
"I'd make two
cuts in the abdomen and put the intestines in a bucket, then soak up the
blood and crush the bones until the shoulders broke. Now I could get the
heart, lungs and kidneys and chop them up and put them in my bucket. I'd
take the flesh off the bones and put it in my waxcloth bag. It would
take me five or six trips to take everything and throw it down the
toilet or into the river. I always hated doing this, but I couldn't help
it - my passion was so much stronger than the horror of the cutting and
chopping."
The skulls were
smashed to pieces and thrown in the river or marsh, the clothes given
away or sold. The more often this process occurred, the more efficient
it became and, whilst the city of Hannover utilised the meat and
clothing of its victims, Fritz Haarmann remained out of the authorities'
reach.
Some boys he
denied killing - for example a boy named Hermann Wolf, whose photograph
showed an ugly and ill-dressed youth, Haarmann declared that the boy was
far too ugly to have interested him.
The killer
repeatedly claimed that he was driven by beauty and sensuality, not the
cynical interpretation of sex or profit. In his eyes, it was easier to
kill someone you loved - that way you brought them peace.
"Often, after I
had killed, I pleaded to be put away in a military asylum, but not a
madhouse. If Grans had really loved me he would have been able to save
me. Believe me, I'm not ill - it's only that I occasionally have funny
turns. I want to be beheaded. It'll only take a moment, then I'll be at
peace."
The experts then
submitted their reports to the effect that, although the killer had a
"pathological personality", he had not been devoid of free will and
responsibility and therefore bore no manic depressive insanity. Grans
and Haarmann continued their petty squabbles throughout the summing up,
their behaviour towards each other remaining the same until the bitter
end.
At 10am on 19th
December 1924, Haarmann received 24 death sentences in 24 cases and
Grans one death sentence for his supposed incitement to murder in the
Hannappel case. Upon announcement of the verdict, Haarmann proclaimed,
"I want to be
executed on the marketplace. On the tombstone must be put this
inscription: 'Here Lies Mass-Murderer Haarmann'." The court acceded to
neither request and Haarmann was duly decapitated within the walls of
Hannover Prison. Grans's appeal was rejected and the death sentence
pronounced correct and final.
Yet this story
contains one final twist. A Hannover messenger named Lueters found a
letter addressed to Albert Grans, father of the man under sentence of
death, lying on the street. He made sure the letter was passed on to the
addressee, who in turn passed it on to the court. The note was a
four-page confession from Fritz Haarmann, written whilst being taken by
car to the police station.
The letter
summarised the relationship of Grans and himself and, most importantly,
professed the innocence of the younger man.
"Hans Grans has
been sentenced unjustly and that's the fault of the police and also
because I wanted revenge ... Put yourself in Grans's position: he will
question the existence of the Lord and justice just because of me ...
May Hans Grans forgive me for my revenge and humanity."
The exact
intention of this letter has never fully been understood. Was Haarmann
truly troubled by his conscience, or was this simply a devious attempt
to delay his own execution? It is now the common view of experts that
the verdict of the Hannover court is an unsatisfactory one in the sense
that Haarmann was undoubtedly put under pressure by certain authorities
throughout the trial. It is most probably the case that a neglected and
innocent young man has been sentenced to death solely as a result of
statements made by a man pronounced mentally ill by five different
psychiatrists. In this sense, as said by Theodor Lessing, a commentator
on the Haarmann affair, "a judicial murder was committed." Like his
other victims, Fritz Haarmann killed the one he loved, this time by
using the German legal system as his weapon.
After the two
men's deaths, another letter from Haarmann was found, this one
explaining his actions purely as an attempt to take revenge against the
police. The statement concludes,
"You won't kill
me; I'll be back - yes, I shall be amongst you for all eternity. And now
you yourselves have also killed. You should know it: Hans Grans was
innocent! Well? How's your conscience now?"
The Making of
a Killer
Friedrich
Heinrich Karl Haarmann was born the youngest of six children on October
25th 1879. His mother, 41 at the time of his birth, spoiled and pampered
him as a child and encouraged young Fritz to play with dolls instead of
more masculine games. Most crucial to the interests of a psychologist,
Fritz disliked his father from an early age and was to continue this
loathing throughout his life.
The parents were
indeed an ill-assorted couple. 'Old Haarmann' was a morose and
cantankerous locomotive stoker who was to be found at night rampaging
his way around the seedy bars of the Old Town. His wife, Johanna
Claudius, was seven years his senior and provided him with a dowry of
several houses and a small fortune, making him a wealthy citizen in this
time of rapid economic expansion. Johanna was a simple-minded, slightly
stupid woman and managed to ignore her husband's continuous drunkenness
and womanising. The birth of her sixth child left her sick and she spent
much of her remaining twelve years in bed.
As for
Haarmann's siblings, the eldest son, Alfred, became a lower-middle class
factory foreman with upright Philistine and family values. The second
son, Wilhelm, was sentenced at an early age for a sexual offence and the
three sisters, all of whom divorced their husbands early in married
life, proved to be particularly obsessive and compulsive characters.
Frau Rudiger was to meet a premature death in the Great War and Haarmann
never got on with the fourth child, Frau Erfurdt. It was therefore left
to the youngest sister, Emma, to provide Fritz's sole family connection.
From a young age
Haarmann and his father argued and constantly threatened each other, the
father to have his son put in an asylum and Fritz to have his father
thrown in jail for the supposed murder of a train driver. The only
occasions of unity were exhibited when the men would combine to either
carry out a swindle or to appear in court to exonerate the other. In
contrast, Haarmann always felt a deep bond with his mother and she
remained the only person he spoke of with warmth and sentimentality.
The anecdotes
relating to Haarmann's childhood show two distinct traits. The first is
the notable feminine (possibly transvestite) tendencies that were
exhibited throughout his school life. The second is the pleasure in
causing fear and horror. Haarmann enjoyed tying up his sisters and
regularly tapped on windows in the dead of night, awakening a dormant
fear of ghosts and werewolves. The child was spoilt and easily led, yet
lively and popular amongst his peers.
The boy failed
his locksmith apprenticeship and so was sent to the training school for
non-commissioned officers at Neu-Breisach in April 1895. Fritz was a
good gymnast and an obedient soldier, but soon began suffering from
periodic lapses in consciousness and epileptic fits. This was blamed on
a concussion contracted whilst performing bar exercises or sunstroke
suffered during the exercise. Haarmann dismissed himself from the sick
bay in November 1895, saying that he "didn't like it there any more" and
soon began working for his father.
Whilst
Haarmann's laziness and inefficiency continued, his sexual development
was progressing rapidly. Sexual offences against children occurred
almost every day and it was not long before the molestation accusations
began mounting. Eventually and inevitably, the pervert was deemed
incurably deranged by the town doctor and was sent to an asylum shortly
after his 18th birthday. It was here that the young man suffered some
form of trauma that was to affect him for the rest of his life and his
intense fear of the asylum caused him later to say, "Hang me, do
anything you like to me, but don't take me back to the loony bin."
Lacklustre security soon allowed the patient to escape, however, and
Haarmann fled to Switzerland.
At the age of
just 20 he returned to Hannover and around 1900 achieved a sexually
normal period when he seduced and married a large, pretty girl by the
name of Erna Loewert. The engagement had the blessings of both sets of
parents, who fervently hoped that the union would put an end to the
young delinquent's reckless abandon. This was not to be the case,
though, as Haarmann soon deserted the girl and their unborn child for
military service.
He settled well
into army life and, like the killer William Burke before him, became an
excellent soldier; "full of obedience and esprit de corps." Haarmann was
later to refer to this time as "the happiest of his life." A year went
past with no incident until, in October 1901, Haarmann collapsed during
a company exercise and was admitted to the military hospital for four
months. It was diagnosed that the soldier had a mental deficiency and
was deemed "unsuitable for use in community service."
Once again,
Fritz was sent back to his quarrelsome family and resumed his life-long
battle with his father. 'Old Haarmann' attempted to have him committed
to an asylum, but the town doctor regarded him as merely "morally
inferior" and, at the ripe old age of 24, Fritz Haarmann was released
into society.
Numerous
burglaries and confidence scams soon became a feature of Haarmann's life
and, after 1904, he spent one third of the following 20 years either in
custody or in prison. In 1914 he was sentenced to five years in jail for
theft from a warehouse. Released in 1918, he joined a smuggling ring and
conducted a prosperous business as a smuggler, thief and police spy (the
latter activity guaranteed that his activities were not too closely
scrutinised.) For a man supposedly struggling with sanity, Haarmann
showed impressive signs of preparation and calculation in his crimes.
The sexual offences also continued, although he was rarely convicted of
such misdemeanours as the partners were too ashamed to report him to the
police.
Upon release
from prison in April 1918 Haarmann surfaced briefly in Berlin and then
again in Hannover. The murders soon began.
Inside the
Mind of Haarman
Having analysed
the life of one of Germany's most depraved sons, it is now perhaps
appropriate to ask ourselves what we have learned about the inner
dimensions of a sex-killer's mind. Even though it has long since been
accepted that there is no single reason for serial crime, the same
contributing factors rear their evil head in the case of nearly all
killers of this type. Fritz Haarmann is no exception and exhibits the
same ugly traits as so many before and since.
Little was known
of the workings of a psychopath at the time of Haarmann's murders, but
the awareness and understanding of such crimes has now come a long way.
Yet sex-killers cannot be detected by their appearance, domestic
situations or day-to-day behaviour. The sexual impulse is primarily a
mental process and germinates within a secret, interior universe. Whilst
the profilers are learning, as yet it is only through bloody hindsight.
Generally,
serial sex murderers are classified in three broad types: the biological
killer, whose crimes are triggered by a physical defect or injury of
some sort; the psychologically predisposed killer (usually stemming from
an all-female or particularly traumatic childhood); and the sociological
or 'made' killers. The traits of young Haarmann noted in the previous
chapter bring us to the frightening conclusion that Fritz is a strong
candidate for all three of the above categories.
The biological
influence is evident if we consider Haarmann's repeated head injuries
and epileptic fits in his early adulthood. Indeed, a surprisingly large
number of killers have a history of head injuries in their youth.
Whether the troublesome youngster was truly turning the corner at the
training school we shall never know, yet it does remain a tragedy that
an ordinary accident seemed to put an end to an honourable attempt at
obedience.
As to the second
category, the child was pampered and mollycoddled from a young age and
his features of feminism and sadistic pleasure are consistently repeated
factors in the analysis of serial killers' childhoods. Haarmann was
inherently incapable of holding on to abstract ideas; any impressions he
received had to become reality immediately. When talking about sexual
matters he would reach automatically for his genital area, even when
being questioned in the courtroom. His upbringing developed a "raw
creature, without logic and morals; yet also without logical and moral
hypocrisy."
The so-called
"made" killers are those who feel that life has cheated them and owes
them more. In his early years Haarmann welcomed prison as confinement
imposes structure on life and provides a meaning and order to existence.
A crucial sociological feature of the case and one that is typical of
the 20th Century penal system is that whenever Haarmann was released
from jail both his craftiness and his crimes increased. Until the bitter
end Haarmann pursued his 'rage against the machine'. It was later
admitted that he was beaten whilst under police interrogation and his
payback to Hans Grans was a perfectly executed attempt at embarrassing
the authorities he so loathed. The court eventually had to change
Grans's sentence to 12 years' imprisonment, yet only in Hannover would
Grans have received any initial punishment.
This idea of
vengeance and atonement is, in Haarmann's case, rooted in sadism and is
a mask for the sexual feeling. His actions towards his supposed friend,
Hans Grans, were an act of revenge using the last remnants of power that
the accused could exercise.
Indeed, the
relationship between Grans and his mentor is certainly one of the most
fascinating aspects of the case. Grans understood the older man's "wild,
sick urges" and realised that he could thereby ensure his own power and
control over Haarmann. Yet there was also a distinct gratitude and
sympathy between the two,
"I had to have
someone I meant everything to. Hans often laughed at me. Then I got mad
and threw him out. But I always ran after and fetched him back. I
couldn't help it; I was crazy about the boy."
Haarmann did
love Grans and Grans took advantage of it. He was the cleverer of the
two and thus continually toyed and jested with his companion. As irony
would have it, he was to receive the harshest possible payback for his
efforts at manipulating Haarmann. Those who toy with the devil are sure
to be burned!
As a further
scope for evaluation, the question of Haarmann's sanity is one that has
never fully been resolved. Expert evaluation is entirely contrasting,
although it is agreed that he was not ruled by the urge to torment
others, but by the urge to kill at the height of his sexual desire.
Psychoanalysts
declare that the criminal differs from the man who adjusts himself to
society in that he fails to sublimate the aggressive primitive urges.
The wounds inflicted upon him by injustice motivate these actions. There
can be no doubt that Haarmann suffered harshly in his early life and in
this way he obtained the subject matter for an easy later
rationalisation.
Haarmann's
psychological examiners at the time believed that he saw his execution
as one final, intense orgasm and the excitement of this possibility
exceeded anything he had experienced in his day-to-day life. He rejected
the inhibitions that society attempts to place upon us and manipulated
love and crime into a sexual game and "comfortable semi-luxury."
Haarmann murdered for profit, both sexual and financial - and yet,
whilst often racked with remorse, he never at any time in his life felt
the burden of fear upon him. Fritz Haarmann lived his entire life with a
desire for his own destruction.
Bibliography
Due to the
unusual era and location of the crimes, there are consequently very few
books with detailed information on Fritz Haarmann.
Bolitho, W.
Murder for Profit (1926);
Lessing, T.
Monsters of Weimar: Haarmann - The Story of a Werewolf (1993);
Marriner, B. A
New Century of Sex Killers (1992);
Wilson, C. and
D. World Famous Serial Killers (1992);
CrimeLibrary.com
After the relative crime watershed of World War I,
the 20th Century entered the "age of sex crime." Perhaps predictably,
the country where this first became apparent was Germany , where the
miseries and deprivation of hyperinflation and food shortage made their
maximum impact. Hannover, an elegant municipality in the center of lower
Saxony , was one of the cities most affected and it was in this sleepy
hollow that Fritz Haarmann committed one of the most extraordinary
series of crimes in modern times.
On 17th May 1924, some children playing at the edge
of a river near the Herrenhausen Castle found a human skull and, on May
29th, another washed up on the riverbank. The town was sent in to frenzy
on the 13th June when two more skulls were found included in the river's
sediment. An autopsy proved the first two crania to be that of young
people aged between 18 and 20 and the last skull found from a boy of
approximately 12. In all cases, a sharp instrument had been used to
separate the skulls from the torso and the flesh had been entirely
removed.
It was initially thought that the human remains
originated from the anatomical institute in Gottingen or that they had
been flung into the river by grave-robbers fleeing from capture. Yet
these theories remained unproven and the mystery gained further
publicity when boys playing on a marshland unearthed a sack containing
human bones. It had become impossible for the authorities to keep these
grisly finds a secret and, whilst young boys continued to be reported
missing (the number in 1923 grew to almost 600), the Hannoverian
population was gripped by terror. The investigation highlighted that
those missing were mostly aged between 14 and 18 and rumors were
circulating that human flesh had been on sale at the public market.
On Whit Sunday in 1924, hundreds of people left
Hannover and descended on the small paths and bridges of the Old Town ,
where they started searching for human remains. The vastness of this
expedition was unprecedented in German criminal history and was spurred
on primarily by the talk of a "werewolf" or "man-eater" at large. After
a multitude of bones had been discovered, the city's central River Leine
was dammed and inspected by policemen and municipal workers. The finds
were horrific. More than 500 parts of corpses were detected, proved
later to be the remains of at least 22 people, a third aged between 15
and 20. Approximately one half had been in the water for some time and
the joints of many of the fresh bones had smoothly cut surfaces.
Every thief and sexual deviant in Hannover was
questioned and, through dogged detective work and a series of strange
coincidences, a suspect by the name of Friedrich (known as Fritz)
Haarmann was taken to the court prison. The man was already known to the
police as both a 'dealer' in clothing and meat and to the criminal
investigation department due to his publicly homosexual status. His
appearance and mannerisms in the ultra-reserved days of inter-war
Germany redefined the conventional impression of murder and murderers.
Haarmann was certainly sympathetic in appearance, a
simple man with a friendly, open expression and a courteous nature. Of
average height, broad and well built, he had a rough 'full-moon' face
and neat, cheerful eyes. His features were generally small and as
unprepossessing as the rest of his appearance, the only notability a
well-groomed, light brown moustache. Fritz's expression closed up
completely as soon as the atmosphere became embarrassing and
investigating officers soon realized that their suspect was a man of
deep contrast. At times cagey and calculating, yet also talkative and
hyperactive, desperately seeking sympathy and attention. His soft, white
hands moved nervously, plucking and pulling constantly at his long
fingers.
Whilst Haarmann's body was strong and coarse, it was
also slightly feminine and his speech "was like the querulous voice of
an old woman." The killer's almost constant defensiveness and
embarrassment was reflected in his automatisms and stereotypes: the
wiggling of his behind, the licking of his lips - even the constant
blinking of his eyes. Haarmann loved 'feminine' pastimes, such as baking
and cooking, but would smoke strong cigars at the same time. Although
his appearance was, as the Hannover police stated, "far from evil",
Fritz Haarmann entered the record books as Germany 's most prolific
killer.
Haarmann had begun his crime rampage in September
1918, a time in which Germany was suffering economic depravation and
severe food shortages. A young runaway by the name of Friedel Roth
disappeared from home on the 25th, writing to his mother only to say
that he would not return home until "she was nice again." Various
friends of the boy were forthcoming with information and eventually led
the police to no.27 Cellerstrasse, the home of a man they claimed had
seduced Friedel. A detective surprised one Fritz Haarmann in bed with a
young boy and he was sentenced to nine months' imprisonment for seducing
the juvenile. Unbelievably, the rooms were not searched and, upon
interrogation five years later, Haarmann confessed that the "murdered
boy's head was stuffed behind the stove wrapped in newspaper."
The murderer's story was to take a dramatic turn in
late 1919 when he met young Hans Grans at the Hannover railway station.
A petty thief, Hans had run away from home and now earned his living
selling old clothes at the station. The young boy approached the openly
homosexual Haarmann with the purpose of prostituting himself for money.
Remarkably, a friendship soon developed and Grans began living with the
old man, where a bond of "madness and spiritual parasitism developed."
The relationship was more than sexual and the insane ideas that surfaced
in Haarmann's conscience always involved his young housemate.
Having carefully avoided his jail sentence throughout
1919, Haarmann served his penance from March until December 1920. Grans
thieved his way around Germany during this time and, upon reunion at
Christmas 1920, there followed a period of uninterrupted bliss until
August 1921. The two thieves appeared as well-dressed, decent gentlemen
and earned respect amongst the local people. Needless to say, however,
the two men had more illicit intentions and plied their trade by begging
or stealing laundry and selling it to the public.
In early 1922 the two men moved to no.8 Neuestrasse
in the heart of the so-called 'haunted area". Haarmann was earning a
good income; the thieving was accompanied by social security payments
(he had been declared an invalid and therefore unable to work) and also
his newfound role as a police informer. Haarmann double-crossed
everybody and became a "custodian of the law and an information office
for all criminal matters." Amazingly, the clothes that Haarmann passed
around Hannover earned him the reputation as a benefactor of the
homeless. His obvious homosexuality further hushed up any theories
people may have had as to the origin of the garments. This was just as
well as, in February 1923, Haarmann returned to his murderous past.
The killer detained two youths at Hannover station on
the pretence that he was an officer inspecting the waiting rooms. The
less attractive lad was sent away and Fritz Franke accompanied the phony
officer home. Haarmann later claimed that Grans had turned up
unexpectedly whilst the corpse of Franke was still in the room. Shocked,
he simply stared at Haarmann and said, "When shall I come back again?"
The murders now gained pace and in the following nine
months 12 more young men's lives were taken. In almost every scenario,
the victim was met at the train station and offered accommodation or
work; or apprehended on the pretence that his abductor was a police
officer. This guise was used so often that on one occasion, after a
youth welfare worker had asked the guard as to whether Haarmann was
employed in the same capacity, the station official replied, "No, he's a
detective." Once in the Neuestrasse room the boy would be killed,
according to Haarmann, by biting through his windpipe. Always with a
view to his commercial instincts, the body would then be dismembered and
the clothes and meat sold through the usual channels for smuggled goods.
The useless portions were thrown into the River Leine.
One year later, when the items confiscated from the
killer were on public display, victim's families discovered a wealth of
personal artifacts, many kept as souvenirs and the remainder sold on
through Haarmann's impressive distribution network. On each occasion
there was normally an array of witnesses who had seen the recognizable
Haarmann (and often Grans) approach and leave with the stranger. Such
was the respect that the two men had now earned for themselves, however,
that no incident was ever reported. On one such circumstance Haarmann
even had the audacity to reply to an announcement in the paper offering
a reward for information. He appeared at the family door under the guise
of a criminologist, yet was said to have spent most of his time
"laughing hysterically."
The murders continued unabated throughout early1924,
Haarmann honing his remarkable knack of spotting disillusioned young
tearaways at the station and then removing them casually into the night.
Due to the nature of the victims, angry or estranged parents and friends
often took a while to even report the disappearance. By then, the
clothing and meat of the victims had been speedily distributed around
Hannover and were practically untraceable. Without that sort of hard
evidence, the police were at a virtual dead-end, although there were
some particularly close calls. On one such occasion, a portion of the
trader's meat was taken to the police because the buyer thought it was
human flesh. The police analyst unequivocally pronounced it pork!
The disappearance of Erich de Vries on 14th June 1924
signaled the end of the killer's reign. In classic fashion, it was an
offer of cigarettes at Hannover station that tempted the young lad to
join the friendly stranger in his room. It was estimated at this time
that the fugitive had murdered around 27 boys in less than 16 months: an
average of almost two a month.
Despite the enormous manhunt now in operation, the
killer had still not been apprehended and Hannover was at the point of
public outcry. By late June of 1924 sheer terror had gripped the city
and the "Werewolf" was still on the loose.
Throughout the panic that engulfed Hannover in 1924,
Fritz Haarmann remained a definite suspect. Along with every other local
sex offender, he was investigated repeatedly during May and June, yet no
conclusive evidence could be found. Meanwhile, press announcements
appeared giving details of the skulls in the hope of obtaining clues
from the general public. The quantity of skulls and corpses still being
discovered was generating a nationwide furor and a general lack of
confidence in the German police force.
With the pressure mounting, the following course of
action was agreed upon: as Haarmann already knew the town officials, two
young policemen would arrive from Berlin at Hannover train station,
pretending to be homeless and looking for a place to stay. They would
then focus on the suspect's activities and hope to catch him in the act.
Once again, however, the killer's incredible luck conspired against them
as Fritz was found arguing with 15-year-old Karl Fromm, a boy who had
spent several days at Haarmann's apartment. Fromm was being particularly
"cheeky and supercilious" on this evening and, amazingly, Haarmann had
the audacity to report him to the railway police, claiming that he was
traveling on false papers. Once at the police station, though, Fromm
turned the tables on the older man by accusing him of sexual harassment
during his stay. Coincidentally, a member of the vice squad was at the
station at this time and, in the knowledge that the police were hoping
to arrest Haarmann, the officer decided to apprehend the suspect
immediately. Before any unnecessary suspicions could be aroused,
Haarmann was taken to prison on the morning of 23rd June.
The killer later claimed that he had only arranged to
have Fromm taken into custody because he knew he was going to murder the
boy and was afraid he would not be able to resist the urge for much
longer. If this statement is to be believed, here was the first time
that Haarmann's actions were motivated by any moral scruples and these
alleged feelings of guilt were to prove his downfall.
Yet the case was not nearly as clear-cut as the
substantial evidence would imply. Several hundred items of clothing
found in Haarmann's room or confiscated from his acquaintances were
collected and identified as the property of the missing children, but
there was no evidence to declare he had been responsible for even one of
the deaths. Haarmann inevitably claimed that the property in his
possession was due to his business of trading and dealing in used
clothes. He admitted having sexual relations with some of the children,
yet denied any knowledge of the victims' current whereabouts and gave
plausible explanations for the traces of blood present in the garments.
The suspect once again displayed considerable skill
at avoiding taxing questions and prolonging the inquisition. Haarmann
was an astute man and, understanding the rather secretive nature of
homosexuality at the time, subsequently knew it would be difficult for
the police to obtain incriminating evidence from his victims and their
families.
One of these victims was a boy named Robert Witzel,
whose parents had continually besieged the police since their son's
disappearance on April 26th 1924. When the first skulls were found later
that year, Herr Witzel was persuaded to examine the evidence in order to
confirm that his son's irregular jawbone was one of the discovered
crania. All that was known at this time was that Robert had visited the
local circus on the night of his disappearance with his best friend, the
"sly and girlish Fritz Kahlmeyer." Fritz, silent throughout the entire
ordeal, would only say that the boys had traveled to the circus with a "police
official from the railway station." The reason for the boy's secretive
nature was understandable; he too had been approached and sexually
abused by Haarmann, who subsequently procured him for homosexual "society
gentlemen." Items of Witzel's clothing were found in the killer's
apartment, yet Haarmann would still not confess.
The breakthrough came when a couple walked into the
police station and passed the Witzel family who sat outside the Chief
Commissioner's office. Frau Witzel immediately recognized the man's
jacket and asked as to where he had obtained the garment. The man
admitted that he had acquired the coat from Haarmann and even provided
an identification card in the trousers bearing the name 'Witzel'. The
lady accompanying him was Frau Engel, Haarmann's landlady, who happened
to be in the police station making enquiries concerning her tenant's
military pension. An enormous stroke of luck in addition to the fabric
evidence and, more importantly, one which finally convinced Haarmann to
concede defeat.
The prisoner was consequently subjected to incessant
and severe questioning, before being given relief and encouragement
commensurate with the "unburdening of the conscience." After seven days
of maniacal and emotional rages Haarmann broke down and asked for the
superintendent and examining magistrate, to whom he would make a full
confession.
The killer then took the court officials on a murder
tour of Hannover . They were shown parts of corpses hidden in bushes,
bones dredged from a lake and skeletons concealed around the city.
Inevitably, more and more people stepped forward who had obtained
clothing or meat from either Haarmann or Grans and the evidence
snowballed.
Haarmann's character also changed during this period.
He now opened up to the investigating authorities and displayed the
helpful, childish and often sarcastic side to his nature. Only if
confronted by the parents of his victims or if discussing the act of
decapitation would the killer withdraw himself again. The general
impression was that he felt relieved of a terrible burden by being able
to discuss the darkness and fear of his abnormal sex-life. There was
also a distinct degree of pride in having duped mankind, of whom
Haarmann always spoke badly.
As a result of the information secured, Hans Grans
was arrested on 8th July and the two men met on several occasions before
their trials began. At these times, Haarmann was always troubled, where
as Grans appeared indifferent to the entire affair. Haarmann remained in
the prison until 16th August, before being sent to nearby Gottingen for
psychiatric examination. The trial, unprecedented in German judicial
history, contained 60 volumes of files and opened on 4th December 1924.
The trial was conducted at the Hannover Assizes and
lasted through 14 days and almost 200 witnesses. The much-publicized
opening decree stated that Fritz Haarmann was "accused of killing 27
persons intentionally and deliberately" from September 1918 to June
1924.
Haarmann insisted on conducting his own defense and
remained entirely nonchalant throughout the trial, at one point
complaining that there were too many women in the courtroom. He was
allowed remarkable freedom and was notably immature and irresponsible,
frequently interrupting the proceedings. At one stage he demanded
indignantly why there were so many women in the court; the judge
answered apologetically that he had no power to keep them out. On
another occasion, when a mother became too distraught to give evidence
about her son with clarity, Haarmann got bored and asked to be allowed
to smoke a cigar. Permission was immediately granted.
Nonetheless, the murderer's naive combination of
fiction and fact was generally agreed as refreshing in contrast to the
legal speak of the jurists and the confused hypocrisy of the
authorities. To the journalists he once said reproachfully, "You are not
to lie; we know you are all liars," and to the jury, "Keep it short. I
want to spend Christmas in heaven with Mother." Haarmann was constantly
amused by the proceedings and, remarkably, even brought a smile from the
public on more than one occasion.
In contrast, Hans Grans, accused in two cases of
instigating murder, appeared as a tough and unbreakable character. The
jury subsequently branded him as the more dangerous (yet the more
innocent) of the two. Grans was entirely focused on self-preservation,
an attitude that was to prove his downfall as Haarmann became
concentrated on his devilish desire for revenge; to take the one he
loved the most with him to the dark land. Hence, Fritz formed incredible
and completely inaccurate accusations of murder against his partner that
the court whole-heartedly believed. Once he had achieved his aim of not
going to death alone, Haarmann quieted down and let Grans do the
talking.
Inevitably, though, the most chilling tale of all
came when Haarmann took the stand to explain his murder method in the
most graphic of detail.
"I never intended to hurt those youngsters, but I
knew that if I got going something would happen and that made me cry ...
I would throw myself on top of those boys and bite through the Adam's
apple, throttling them at the same time."
Haarmann explained the guilt he often felt at this
point, regularly collapsing on the dead body and covering the face with
a cloth so "it wouldn't be looking at me."
"I'd make two cuts in the abdomen and put the
intestines in a bucket, then soak up the blood and crush the bones until
the shoulders broke. Now I could get the heart, lungs and kidneys and
chop them up and put them in my bucket. I'd take the flesh off the bones
and put it in my waxcloth bag. It would take me five or six trips to
take everything and throw it down the toilet or into the river. I always
hated doing this, but I couldn't help it - my passion was so much
stronger than the horror of the cutting and chopping."
The skulls were smashed to pieces and thrown in the
river or marsh, the clothes given away or sold. The more often this
process occurred, the more efficient it became and, whilst the city of
Hannover utilized the meat and clothing of its victims, Fritz Haarmann
remained out of the authorities' reach.
Some boys he denied killing - for example a boy named
Hermann Wolf, whose photograph showed an ugly and ill-dressed youth,
Haarmann declared that the boy was far too ugly to have interested him.
The killer repeatedly claimed that he was driven by
beauty and sensuality, not the cynical interpretation of sex or profit.
In his eyes, it was easier to kill someone you loved - that way you
brought them peace.
"Often, after I had killed, I pleaded to be put away
in a military asylum, but not a madhouse. If Grans had really loved me
he would have been able to save me. Believe me, I'm not ill - it's only
that I occasionally have funny turns. I want to be beheaded. It'll only
take a moment, then I'll be at peace."
The experts then submitted their reports to the
effect that, although the killer had a "pathological personality", he
had not been devoid of free will and responsibility and therefore bore
no manic depressive insanity. Grans and Haarmann continued their petty
squabbles throughout the summing up, their behavior towards each other
remaining the same until the bitter end.
At 10am on 19th December 1924, Haarmann received 24
death sentences in 24 cases and Grans one death sentence for his
supposed incitement to murder in the Hannappel case. Upon announcement
of the verdict, Haarmann proclaimed,
"I want to be executed on the marketplace. On the
tombstone must be put this inscription: 'Here Lies Mass-Murderer
Haarmann'." The court acceded to neither request and Haarmann was duly
decapitated within the walls of Hannover Prison. Grans's appeal was
rejected and the death sentence pronounced correct and final.
Yet this story contains one final twist. A Hannover
messenger named Lueters found a letter addressed to Albert Grans, father
of the man under sentence of death, lying on the street. He made sure
the letter was passed on to the addressee, who in turn passed it on to
the court. The note was a four-page confession from Fritz Haarmann,
written whilst being taken by car to the police station.
The letter summarized the relationship of Grans and
himself and, most importantly, professed the innocence of the younger
man.
"Hans Grans has been sentenced unjustly and that's
the fault of the police and also because I wanted revenge ... Put
yourself in Grans's position: he will question the existence of the Lord
and justice just because of me ... May Hans Grans forgive me for my
revenge and humanity."
The exact intention of this letter has never fully
been understood. Was Haarmann truly troubled by his conscience, or was
this simply a devious attempt to delay his own execution? It is now the
common view of experts that the verdict of the Hannover court is an
unsatisfactory one in the sense that Haarmann was undoubtedly put under
pressure by certain authorities throughout the trial. It is most
probably the case that a neglected and innocent young man has been
sentenced to death solely as a result of statements made by a man
pronounced mentally ill by five different psychiatrists. In this sense,
as said by Theodor Lessing, a commentator on the Haarmann affair, "a
judicial murder was committed." Like his other victims, Fritz Haarmann
killed the one he loved, this time by using the German legal system as
his weapon.
After the two men's deaths, another letter from
Haarmann was found, this one explaining his actions purely as an attempt
to take revenge against the police. The statement concludes,
"You won't kill me; I'll be back - yes, I shall be
amongst you for all eternity. And now you yourselves have also killed.
You should know it: Hans Grans was innocent! Well? How's your conscience
now?"
Friedrich Heinrich Karl Haarmann was born the
youngest of six children on October 25th 1879. His mother, 41 at the
time of his birth, spoiled and pampered him as a child and encouraged
young Fritz to play with dolls instead of more masculine games. Most
crucial to the interests of a psychologist, Fritz disliked his father
from an early age and was to continue this loathing throughout his life.
The parents were indeed an ill-assorted couple. 'Old
Haarmann' was a morose and cantankerous locomotive stoker who was to be
found at night rampaging his way around the seedy bars of the Old Town .
His wife, Johanna Claudius, was seven years his senior and provided him
with a dowry of several houses and a small fortune, making him a wealthy
citizen in this time of rapid economic expansion. Johanna was a
simple-minded, slightly stupid woman and managed to ignore her husband's
continuous drunkenness and womanizing. The birth of her sixth child left
her sick and she spent much of her remaining twelve years in bed.
As for Haarmann's siblings, the eldest son, Alfred,
became a lower-middle class factory foreman with upright Philistine and
family values. The second son, Wilhelm, was sentenced at an early age
for a sexual offence and the three sisters, all of whom divorced their
husbands early in married life, proved to be particularly obsessive and
compulsive characters. Frau Rudiger was to meet a premature death in the
Great War and Haarmann never got on with the fourth child, Frau Erfurdt.
It was therefore left to the youngest sister, Emma, to provide Fritz's
sole family connection.
From a young age Haarmann and his father argued and
constantly threatened each other, the father to have his son put in an
asylum and Fritz to have his father thrown in jail for the supposed
murder of a train driver. The only occasions of unity were exhibited
when the men would combine to either carry out a swindle or to appear in
court to exonerate the other. In contrast, Haarmann always felt a deep
bond with his mother and she remained the only person he spoke of with
warmth and sentimentality.
The anecdotes relating to Haarmann's childhood show
two distinct traits. The first is the notable feminine (possibly
transvestite) tendencies that were exhibited throughout his school life.
The second is the pleasure in causing fear and horror. Haarmann enjoyed
tying up his sisters and regularly tapped on windows in the dead of
night, awakening a dormant fear of ghosts and werewolves. The child was
spoilt and easily led, yet lively and popular amongst his peers.
The boy failed his locksmith apprenticeship and so
was sent to the training school for non-commissioned officers at
Neu-Breisach in April 1895. Fritz was a good gymnast and an obedient
soldier, but soon began suffering from periodic lapses in consciousness
and epileptic fits. This was blamed on a concussion contracted whilst
performing bar exercises or sunstroke suffered during the exercise.
Haarmann dismissed himself from the sick bay in November 1895, saying
that he "didn't like it there any more" and soon began working for his
father.
Whilst Haarmann's laziness and inefficiency
continued, his sexual development was progressing rapidly. Sexual
offences against children occurred almost every day and it was not long
before the molestation accusations began mounting. Eventually and
inevitably, the pervert was deemed incurably deranged by the town doctor
and was sent to an asylum shortly after his 18th birthday. It was here
that the young man suffered some form of trauma that was to affect him
for the rest of his life and his intense fear of the asylum caused him
later to say, "Hang me, do anything you like to me, but don't take me
back to the loony bin." Lackluster security soon allowed the patient to
escape, however, and Haarmann fled to Switzerland .
At the age of just 20 he returned to Hannover and
around 1900 achieved a sexually normal period when he seduced and
married a large, pretty girl by the name of Erna Loewert. The engagement
had the blessings of both sets of parents, who fervently hoped that the
union would put an end to the young delinquent's reckless abandon. This
was not to be the case, though, as Haarmann soon deserted the girl and
their unborn child for military service.
He settled well into army life and, like the killer
William Burke before him, became an excellent soldier; "full of
obedience and esprit de corps." Haarmann was later to refer to this time
as "the happiest of his life." A year went past with no incident until,
in October 1901, Haarmann collapsed during a company exercise and was
admitted to the military hospital for four months. It was diagnosed that
the soldier had a mental deficiency and was deemed "unsuitable for use
in community service."
Once again, Fritz was sent back to his quarrelsome
family and resumed his life-long battle with his father. 'Old Haarmann'
attempted to have him committed to an asylum, but the town doctor
regarded him as merely "morally inferior" and, at the ripe old age of
24, Fritz Haarmann was released into society.
Numerous burglaries and confidence scams soon became
a feature of Haarmann's life and, after 1904, he spent one third of the
following 20 years either in custody or in prison. In 1914 he was
sentenced to five years in jail for theft from a warehouse. Released in
1918, he joined a smuggling ring and conducted a prosperous business as
a smuggler, thief and police spy (the latter activity guaranteed that
his activities were not too closely scrutinized.) For a man supposedly
struggling with sanity, Haarmann showed impressive signs of preparation
and calculation in his crimes. The sexual offences also continued,
although he was rarely convicted of such misdemeanors as the partners
were too ashamed to report him to the police.
Upon release from prison in April 1918 Haarmann
surfaced briefly in Berlin and then again in Hannover . The murders soon
began.
Having analyzed the life of one of Germany 's most
depraved sons, it is now perhaps appropriate to ask ourselves what we
have learned about the inner dimensions of a sex-killer's mind. Even
though it has long since been accepted that there is no single reason
for serial crime, the same contributing factors rear their evil head in
the case of nearly all killers of this type. Fritz Haarmann is no
exception and exhibits the same ugly traits as so many before and since.
Little was known of the workings of a psychopath at
the time of Haarmann's murders, but the awareness and understanding of
such crimes has now come a long way. Yet sex-killers cannot be detected
by their appearance, domestic situations or day-to-day behavior. The
sexual impulse is primarily a mental process and germinates within a
secret, interior universe. Whilst the profilers are learning, as yet it
is only through bloody hindsight.
Generally, serial sex murderers are classified in
three broad types: the biological killer, whose crimes are triggered by
a physical defect or injury of some sort; the psychologically
predisposed killer (usually stemming from an all-female or particularly
traumatic childhood); and the sociological or 'made' killers. The traits
of young Haarmann noted in the previous chapter bring us to the
frightening conclusion that Fritz is a strong candidate for all three of
the above categories.
The biological influence is evident if we consider
Haarmann's repeated head injuries and epileptic fits in his early
adulthood. Indeed, a surprisingly large number of killers have a history
of head injuries in their youth. Whether the troublesome youngster was
truly turning the corner at the training school we shall never know, yet
it does remain a tragedy that an ordinary accident seemed to put an end
to an honorable attempt at obedience.
As to the second category, the child was pampered and
mollycoddled from a young age and his features of feminism and sadistic
pleasure are consistently repeated factors in the analysis of serial
killers' childhoods. Haarmann was inherently incapable of holding on to
abstract ideas; any impressions he received had to become reality
immediately. When talking about sexual matters he would reach
automatically for his genital area, even when being questioned in the
courtroom. His upbringing developed a "raw creature, without logic and
morals; yet also without logical and moral hypocrisy."
The so-called "made" killers are those who feel that
life has cheated them and owes them more. In his early years Haarmann
welcomed prison as confinement imposes structure on life and provides a
meaning and order to existence. A crucial sociological feature of the
case and one that is typical of the 20th Century penal system is that
whenever Haarmann was released from jail both his craftiness and his
crimes increased. Until the bitter end Haarmann pursued his 'rage
against the machine'. It was later admitted that he was beaten whilst
under police interrogation and his payback to Hans Grans was a perfectly
executed attempt at embarrassing the authorities he so loathed. The
court eventually had to change Grans's sentence to 12 years'
imprisonment, yet only in Hannover would Grans have received any initial
punishment.
This idea of vengeance and atonement is, in
Haarmann's case, rooted in sadism and is a mask for the sexual feeling.
His actions towards his supposed friend, Hans Grans, were an act of
revenge using the last remnants of power that the accused could
exercise.
Indeed, the relationship between Grans and his mentor
is certainly one of the most fascinating aspects of the case. Grans
understood the older man's "wild, sick urges" and realized that he could
thereby ensure his own power and control over Haarmann. Yet there was
also a distinct gratitude and sympathy between the two, "I had to have
someone I meant everything to. Hans often laughed at me. Then I got mad
and threw him out. But I always ran after and fetched him back. I
couldn't help it; I was crazy about the boy."
Haarmann did love Grans and Grans took advantage of
it. He was the cleverer of the two and thus continually toyed and jested
with his companion. As irony would have it, he was to receive the
harshest possible payback for his efforts at manipulating Haarmann.
Those who toy with the devil, are sure to be burned!
As a further scope for evaluation, the question of
Haarmann's sanity is one that has never fully been resolved. Expert
evaluation is entirely contrasting, although it is agreed that he was
not ruled by the urge to torment others, but by the urge to kill at the
height of his sexual desire.
Psychoanalysts declare that the criminal differs from
the man who adjusts himself to society in that he fails to sublimate the
aggressive primitive urges. The wounds inflicted upon him by injustice
motivate these actions. There can be no doubt that Haarmann suffered
harshly in his early life and in this way he obtained the subject matter
for an easy later rationalization.
Haarmann's psychological examiners at the time
believed that he saw his execution as one final, intense orgasm and the
excitement of this possibility exceeded anything he had experienced in
his day-to-day life. He rejected the inhibitions that society attempts
to place upon us and manipulated love and crime into a sexual game and
"comfortable semi-luxury."
Haarmann murdered for profit, both sexual and
financial - and yet, whilst often racked with remorse, he never at any
time in his life felt the burden of fear upon him. Fritz Haarmann lived
his entire life with a desire for his own destruction.
All text that appears in this section was provided by
www.crimelibrary.com (the very best source for serial killer information
on the internet). Serialkillercalendar.com thanks the crime library for
their tireless efforts in recording our dark past commends them on the
amazing job they have done thus far).