The grandmother who has no more grandchildren. The
childless mother. The hardened prosecutor who doesn't usually cry. They
all had their final say Tuesday to Reco Jones , the man convicted of one
of Detroit's most heinous crimes.
They all addressed Jones before Wayne County Circuit
Judge Kym Worthy sentenced Jones to five life terms in prison for
slashing and torturing his ex-girlfriend and four children to death last
summer. Jones, who jumped out the fifth-floor window of a police
interrogation room the day after he was arrested and then took the stand
during his trial and tried to pin the quintuple murder on his girlfriend,
said he was sorry."I apologize for what happened. I didn't mean to kill
them," murmured Jones, who inflicted more than 100 stab and torture
wounds on his victims in the bloodbath.
The short, skinny waif of a man professed his love
for the woman he killed, 24-year-old Yolanda Bellamy. Prosecutors
charged he killed her after she lied in saying she had been pregnant and
planned an abortion. The children were sacrificed because they knew him."She
did so much for me," Jones said. "The reason I took the stand is because
I had so much to say and I wanted to say it my way,"Jones said. "I'm
sorry for what happened."
Ericka Bellamy, 22, who last summer found the bodies
of her two children -- Shafontah Bellamy,3, and Delvontay Bellamy, 5,
nephews Nathan Burns Jr., 5, and Nathan Burns III, 3, and her sister,
Yolanda, stared straight at Jones."I hate you. I hate the day you were
born and I hate the day my sister met you," she said. "Words can't
explain how I feel, not now, not ever. But knowing a monster will be
locked away until death catches up with you helps me a little." Linda
Bellamy, 41, the grandmother of all the dead children, told the court:
"No sentence except for death is good enough for what he did. I only
hope for the rest of his life Reco can be locked up like the animal that
he is."
Reco Jones - The trial
March 19, 1998 -- "By the end of the trial, we
hope to prove to you that someone other than Reco Jones committed these
homicides."
Those were the words of John McWilliams, defense
attorney for Jones, who faces five counts of first-degree murder for the
slayings of his ex-girlfriend Yolanda Bellamy, her two children (Nathan
Burns, Jr. and Nathan, III) and her niece and nephew (Shanfontah and
Delvontay Bellamy) in August 1997.
McWilliams told jurors that his client may have been
with Bellamy during the night of her murder, but he did not kill her.
Instead, McWilliams said, one of Jones's girlfriends at the time may
have killed Bellamy and the children in a jealous rage. The defense
attorney also suggested that jurors would actually hear the testimony of
the real murderer.
But to prosecutor Kevin Simowski, Jones is the actual
murderer. He portrayed Jones as a manipulative person who had about five
girlfriends at the time of the slayings.
Simowski said that the relationship between Jones and
Bellamy was not a happy one. In fact, Bellamy did not respect Jones very
much and thought that he was not a "man."
Simowski also told jurors that they would hear about
an incident where Bellamy slashed Jones's car tires and told him shortly
before her death that although she was pregnant with his child, she
would not have the baby. (Simowski revealed that Bellamy had
deliberately lied to Jones and was not pregnant at all.)
Simowski also suggested for the first time that Jones
may have tortured the four young children as he killed them, causing
several grimaces and looks of disgust among jurors.
He said that Jones made just one mistake when he
tried to cover up his crime. When he tried to wash his hands after the
killings, the blood of all five victims combined. Investigators came
upon blood stains that matched all the blood types of the victims.
The first victim called to the stand by the
prosecution did not want to be identified. She was Jones's girlfriend
during July 1997. This witness testified that she thought Yolanda
Bellamy was Jones's ex-girlfriend throughout their brief relationship
and that Jones acted as though his problems with Bellamy did not bother
him. She talked about an incident weeks before the slayings where she
saw a female slash Jones's tires but could not see the culprit. She
could not identify the tire slasher as Bellamy.
The witness eventually asked Jones about his
continuing correspondence with Bellamy and told him that he was "either
crazy or still liked her" for still talking to Bellamy.
The state then brought assistant medical examiner Dr.
Laning Davidson to the stand as a forensic pathology expert. Dr.
Davidson examined the bodies of all five victims after the murders. He
concluded from his examinations that all the victims died from multiple
stab and slash wounds.
The doctor said that three-year-old Shafontah Bellamy
in particular, suffered a lot of injuries: in addition to her 21 stab
wounds around her body, she suffered 21 additional wounds around her
neck and head. Dr. Davidson said her puncture wounds suggested that she
had been tortured.
During cross-examination, the doctor said he could
not determine from the wounds whether the attacker was right-handed or
left-handed and conceded that the murderer could have been male or
female.
Based on the fact that the attacker would have had to
overpowered both Yolanda Bellamy and the children, Dr. Davidson said the
culprit had to have been an adult.
The last witness for the day was Mary Wade, a
neighbor and landlady of the victim. She and Bellamy's sister, Ericka
Bellamy, discovered the bodies and called 911.
Wade said she woke sometime in the early morning
hours of Aug. 13 to the sound of Yolanda's voice. She thought she heard
Yolanda say, "Kids, come into the house.''
Wade said she then went right back to sleep. Later
that morning, Wade knocked on Bellamy's door because her plumber had to
get access to a valve in the basement. There was no answer.
Ericka, who lived right around the corner, soon came
over and both women went to Bellamy's door. Ericka looked through the
mail slot in the front door and saw her son, Delvontay, lying on the
living room floor in a pool of blood.
She kept looking and looking, Wade said, and then
said there must have been an accident. During cross-examination, Wade
denied ever telling the police -- as stated in a police report -- that
she heard an argument upon waking up. She said that the police were
mistaken. After testimony concluded, there was a shouting match between
a relative of the victim and a relative of the defendant Jones.
Presiding Judge Kym Worthy chastised members of both
families and warned them that they better behave or she will bar them
from the rest of the courtroom proceedings.
*****
March 19, 1998 -- Reco Jones's defense began
to slowly reveal its strategy as defense attorney John McWilliams
brought one of Jones's former girlfriends, Maliaka Martin, to the stand
and was able to get her to admit that the victim Yolanda Bellamy was her
romantic rival and that she wanted Jones to stay away from her.
Under direct examination from the prosecution, Martin
testified that Jones came to her house early in the morning after the
slayings and allegedly told her that he had killed Bellamy and the four
children. Jones first told Martin that he killed Bellamy because he had
grown tired of her coming to his house and insulting his mother.
He also allegedly claimed that the victim told him
that if he left her, she would tell Nathan Burns, Sr. (the father of her
two sons) that Jones had beaten the children. Jones "snapped" and then
killed Bellamy in a rage.
Martin described Jones as having blood smeared on the
right side of his neck when he showed up at her house. She then let him
take a shower and helped him dispose of his bloody sneakers and clothes.
But during cross-examination by the defense, Martin admitted that she
had a romantic interest in Jones long before the slayings.
During Jones's six-month imprisonment for a separate
assault between January and June 1997, Martin wrote Jones frequently and
apparently told him that she wanted to pursue a relationship with him.
She also wanted Jones to end his relationship with
Bellamy. Martin even admitted that she hated Yolanda Bellamy and was
jealous of her. In addition, Martin also said that she and Jones had
argued earlier that evening and conceded that he could have visited her
that morning to reconcile.
Jurors also heard major testimony from Ericka Bellamy,
the sister of the victim. Ericka's son and daughter were also killed in
the slayings. She described the relationship between her late sister and
Jones as "rocky" and said that both had threatened each other with
physical violence. Ericka was also aware that her sister had slashed
Jones's tires about a month before the murders.
In addition, this witness stoically described how she
discovered the bodies the morning after the murder but fought back tears
as her frantic call to police was played for jurors in court.
During cross-examination, Ericka Bellamy admitted
that she was aware that there was a romantic rivalry between her sister
and Maliaka Martin over Jones.
However, despite the fact that she was close to
Yolanda Bellamy, this witness said she was not aware that her sister had
written Jones so many love letters while he was in prison.
*****
March 23, 1998 -- Day three of the murder
trial of Reco Jones saw the defense for the first time in front of the
jury accuse one of the defendant's former girlfriends of being the
person responsible for the deaths of Yolanda Bellamy, her two young sons
and her young niece and nephew.
Defense attorney John McWilliams resumed his cross-examination
of Martin and suggested that Yolanda was more attractive to Jones
because she already had children and Martin did not. He went further,
asking her if she believed Reco would go to prison if he was caught, and
thus become a "captive audience'' for her.
Martin intended to show the jury Martin would be
happier with Jones in prison and not free to chase other women.
When he asked Martin if she had heard that Yolanda
and Jones were planning to wed, she replied that she had not.
Finally, McWilliams stated that Jones had come to
Martin's home about 6:30 a.m. on Aug. 13 to confront her over what she
had done at Yolanda's. Martin said that that was not true, denying all
responsibility for the murders.
Later in the morning, Jones's friend, Tamika Terrell,
took the stand to say Jones and Martin showed up at her house hours
after the murder about 7:30 a.m. and asked her to both help them get rid
of some of Jones's clothes and bloody gym shoes and return to Bellamy's
house to make sure the front door handle was wiped clean of his
fingerprints.
But Terrell did not have a washing machine. Jones
then asked her to get rid of the clothes, which were in a plastic bag.
Terrell said she questioned Jones further about why he needed disposal
of the clothes.
Martin, Terrell said, told her Jones "took care of
Yolanda.'' Jones went further and said he eliminated Yolanda and "cut
the f--- out of her.''
Terrell said she did not believe him. She said she
saw a paper bag in the trunk of Jones's mother's car that he was driving
that morning. Jones, she said, told her the bag contained the knife he
used and that he was going to throw it in a river or lake. Terrell said
she then burned his clothes and blood splattered gym shoes in a metal
garbage can her family used for burning trash.
There is a question over what clothes Jones was
wearing after the murders. Martin testified previously that Jones showed
up at her house wearing denim shorts and a T-shirt. Terrell said the
clothes she burned included a hooded sweat jacket and sweat pants and
apparently the same gym shoes described by Martin. McWilliams was using
a photo of Martin wearing a hooded sweatshirt quite a bit during
testimony.
Prosecutor Kevin Simowski suggested in questioning
that Jones switched clothes and put them into the bag for disposal when
he went to the trunk of his car.
Terrell said she then accompanied Martin and Jones
back to Bellamy's house, and that she got out of the car and wiped the
handle of the front screen door to ensure there were no fingerprints.
This, she said, took about 30 seconds. Terrell did not tell police what
she
knew for four days, and only after Martin gave police her name.
During cross-examination, McWilliams carefully asked
Terrell if she had misheard what Jones said about killing Yolanda. Was
it possible, McWilliams asked, that Jones said "Kia'' (Maliaka Martin's
nickname, pronounced like "pie") cut the f--- out of Yolanda?
Terrell conceded that that was possible. She
acknowledged that "I'' and "Kia'' sound alike. On redirect, however,
prosecutor Simowski got Terrell to agree that there was no
misunderstanding.
Jurors also heard testimony from Janet Jones, the
mother of Reco Jones. Her testimony showed that she could not account
for Reco between the hours of 4 a.m. and 8 a.m., when she was asleep.
She said she woke up at 8 a.m. to find her Chrysler LeBaron gone. Mrs.
Jones said it was not unusual for Reco to use her car.
She testified that Yolanda came to her house about 11
p.m. the previous night and was upset. Because of Yolanda's demeanor,
this witness would not allow her to confront Reco, who was inside the
house. She told Reco to stay in the basement.
Finally, Jones said, she called 911 to complain that
Yolanda would not leave. Yolanda ultimately left on her own.
Jones also said Maliaka Martin lived in her household
for a few years up until June of 1996. She said Martin acted "hostile''
toward children who interacted with Reco, and that Martin acted "jealous''
toward Reco's own siblings.
The prosecutor held up the knife believed to be
similar to the murder weapon--a Ginsu knife. He asked her if that knife
resembled one she had in her home at one time. She said that it did.
Jeffrey Jones, the defendant's uncle and one of the
police investigators, was also called to the stand. He was working Aug.
13 with a special quick reaction unit aimed at grabbing suspects off the
street quickly. He heard a call from another precinct that there was a
subject named Reco wanted for five fatal assaults who drive a burgundy
BMW.
This witness admitted to prosecutor Simowski that he
knew the description of the suspect matched his nephew, and he headed
toward his sister Janet's house.
Janet had just spoken with Reco when Jeffrey arrived
at her house. She told him that Reco was headed to the restaurant for
lunch with his barber. Jeffrey said he and his fellow officers then
arrested Reco.
Interestingly, Simowski had impeached Jeffrey Jones
about alleged statements his nephew made at the time of his arrest. The
police officer said he told Reco that his girlfriend had been killed.
Reco replied, ``Who?'' and according to Jeffrey, said a name that
sounded unusual. But the officer said he could not remember the name.
Simowski seemed unconvinced, wondering aloud how
Jeffrey Jones could not remember such a name while investigating a
murder with five victims.
Jeffrey Jones also maintained that he knew that the
five victims were stabbed to death before he assisted in the arrest of
his nephew, a claim that would be disputed by another officer.
The final witness called for the day was another
investigating officer, Sgt. Arlie Lovier. He said he arrived at the
Bellamy home around noon. (The first officer at the scene broke down the
front door around 11:10 a.m.) Lovier, who was given 30 days off in the
wake of the grisly murder scene, said it was the worst crime scene he
witnessed in 24 years with the Detroit Police Department. Lovier became
visibly shaken recounting the murder scene and the autopsies that
followed. He said he immediately called for doctors to examine the
victims and that he did not know for sure the victims were stabbed to
death until after two doctors examined the victims' bodies.
Lovier said the presence of so much blood prevented
an immediate determination of what caused the wounds. In contradiction
to Jeffrey Jones's previous testimony, Lovier said that only the senior
department commanders were informed of the cause of death that day, and
that they were not told until after 2 p.m. No other officers should have
known the victims were stabbed.
*****
March 24, 1998 -- Perhaps the most damaging
testimony yet against Reco Jones came from a DNA and blood expert who
found that the DNA of blood found at the sink of victim Yolanda Bellamy
matched those of the five murder victims and Jones.
Cathy Carr, who examines bodily fluids collected from
crime scenes, said the one drop of blood that proved consistent with the
DNA of the five victims and Reco Jones was found at the edge of the
kitchen sink. Carr said it was not noticed at first by investigators
because the countertop there was wet when police first arrived.
But over the course of the day, as investigators
sifted through the house for clues, the water dried, leaving a crusty
residue of blood. The state says the mix of blood was caused when Jones
washed his bloody hands in the sink. Prosecutor Kevin Simowski maintains
that Jones carefully washed and dried his hands, but one undetected drop
fell to the countertop.
Carr also testified about how she matched up blood
splatters in the living room of Yolanda Bellamy's house with the victims.
Her conclusion was that Bellamy must have struggled because her blood
DNA was found all over one side of the living room. Her niece, Shafontah,
and nephew, Delvontay, probably died where they were lying on their
sleeping bag. Bellamy's youngest son, Nathan III, probably died near his
mother's arms.
This witness's most chilling theory, however, was her
conclusion regarding five-year-old Nathan Burns Jr., Bellamy's oldest
son.
His blood DNA was found on the lower steps of the
stairway leading to the second floor and in other parts of the living
room by the front door. It could be concluded he was running, hurt,
trying to get away from his attacker before he was killed.
On cross, the defense seemed to focus on what was not
found in Carr's analysis. According to Carr, no matching blood matter
was found on any knife taken from Jones's home. And no DNA matter was
discovered in any of the sink drain traps in the victims' house.
In addition to Carr's testimony, Detroit police
officer and state shoe print expert Steven Gawlik testified that two of
the three bloody footprints found at the scene were made by Nike gym
shoes. This is important because prior witnesses Maliaka Martin and
Tamika Terrell, who said they helped Jones cover up the crime, said he
had his bloody Nike gym shoes with him on the morning of the murders.
However, none of the defendant's three other pairs of
Nikes matched the footprints. (There has already been testimony that
Jones had another pair of Nikes destroyed after the murders.)
The day's proceedings began with a defense motion to
prevent the state from showing the shocking crime scene photos to the
jury. Defense attorney John McWilliams' main complaint was that the
photos are in color and show a lot of blood, making them prejudicial to
the defense.
However, prosecutor Simowski claimed the photos were
necessary because they supported the testimony of the state medical
examiner and rebutted the defense argument that the 5-foot, 2-inch
Martin, not Jones, overpowered and killed the 5-foot, 4-inch Yolanda
Bellamy.
Furthermore, Simowski said, there were more than 30
state crime scene photos, but the two he chose to show the jury were the
least inflammatory. After reviewing all the photos, Judge Kym Worthy
ruled in favor of the state.
*****
March 25, 1998 -- Prosecutors called their
last witnesses to the stand, providing more damaging testimony against
Reco Jones as two police officers told the jury that Jones confessed to
the murders of Yolanda Bellamy and her two children and niece and nephew
after his arrest.
Officer Monica Childs, the first investigator to
interview Jones when he was brought to the Detroit Police Department's
downtown headquarters the afternoon of Aug. 13, 1997, said Jones waived
his right to remain silent and proceeded to engage in a lengthy
conversation with her that culminated with the defendant allegedly
saying, "You knew all day it was me. You knew I went to Yolanda's house.
You knew I did it.''
Childs said she first asked Jones when was the last
time he saw Yolanda. Jones said early in the morning and then proceeded
to tell the officer he went to Yolanda's when it was still dark.
According to Childs, Jones said he and Bellamy argued, and the victim
made threats against his family and his mother. Jones started to choke
her, long enough for her to stop resisting. The defendant said he then
left the house. Jones allegedly told Childs he saw Nathan Jr. and Nathan
III in the living room but did not know if they were hurt at the time.
Later that morning, according to Childs's account, Jones headed for work
when he changed course and wound up at Maliaka Martin's house.
At one point in the interview, Childs said, Jones
began crying. He told her he wanted to tell her what happened to the
kids, but he also said he wanted to talk with his mother first before
telling Childs the rest of the story.
Childs, however, said she was unsuccessful in
reaching Jones's mother. Childs said that later Jones asked her if she
believed a person can do something very bad while in a frenzy but cannot
stop himself.
When Childs replied, "No," this apparently sparked
Jones's "you know I did it" outburst. Jones's defense focused its
efforts on Childs, questioning why she did not somehow tape or otherwise
record her interview with him. Childs answered that that was against
department policy, and state law does not require police to record
interviews. And defense attorney John McWilliams made an effort to point
out to the jury that at no time in the hours upon hours of police
interviews did Jones admit to stabbing the five victims to death.
Sgt. Reginald Harvel interrogated Jones after Officer
Childs. He testified that the defendant was upset and crying after his
arrest, saying that he had cared for the victim. Jones allegedly
described to the officer how Bellamy had told him that she was pregnant
with his child but was going to refuse to carry out the pregnancy.
Because of this, Jones allegedly confessed to Harvel,
he "snapped" and killed Bellamy. Jones then told Harvel that he needed
to be alone. The officer left the room briefly, but when he returned, he
saw Jones climbing out the window. Harvel tearfully recalled Jones
telling him to get away from him, saying that jumping was "something he
just had to do." Jones jumped as Harvel reached for him and fell several
stories onto the concrete below. The defendant survived the suicide
attempt but suffered a broken elbow and various internal injuries.
In addition to police testimony, blood expert Cathy
Carr returned to the stand to finish her cross-examination by the
defense. Carr admitted that she was not aware that police reports did
not note any cuts on Jones. (Officer Childs and another police officer,
Steven Yakimovich, would later testify that Jones did have a cut on his
right hand. But neither of them noted the cut in a police report or took
pictures of the cut itself.)
She also said that no blood was found in his
fingernail scrapings or on the alleged murder weapon. (But there was
prior testimony that Jones had washed his hands and the knife after the
slayings). Carr did not conduct a similar test of Maliaka Martin, who
had helped Jones attempt to cover up his alleged role in the murders.
The state is expected to wrap its case by calling
Rauol Williams, an inmate who roomed with Jones. He is expected to
testify that Jones confessed the murders to him. Williams is also
expected to say that Jones admitted to jumping out the police
headquarters window but planned to sue by claiming officers pushed him.
Finally, Williams will testify that Jones asked him if he would kill
Maliaka Martin.
*****
March 26, 1998 -- A combative, unremorseful
Reco Jones took the stand and tried to place the blame for the murders
of Yolanda Bellamy and four children squarely on one of his ex-girlfriends,
Maliaka Martin. But when confronted by prosecutor Kevin Simowski during
cross-examination, Jones admitted that he was following a "script"
during his prior testimony and undermined his story about Martin.
Jurors heard an entirely different version of the
slayings from Jones. He testified that he had visited Martin in the
middle of the night and had fallen asleep at her house. According to
Jones, he and Martin were together for a brief time the previous night,
and they had argued about Jones's having female friends and continuing
to talk to Bellamy. Jones said that he visited Martin to settle the
argument with her and claimed that he also had CDs belonging to Bellamy
that he wanted to return. Jones then decided to drive to Bellamy's house
to return her belongings, and Martin accompanied him.
According to the witness, he also wanted to settle
the hard feelings between Bellamy and Martin over the love rivalry they
had involving him.
Jones told the jury that when he and Martin arrived
at Bellamy's house, Martin attacked Bellamy. He said that he tried to
break up the fight between them, but Bellamy had already been stabbed. "What
did you do that for?," Jones claimed he asked Martin. (Jones also
claimed that his arm was cut accidentally by the murder knife while he
tried to separate the two women.)
Martin, Jones claimed, went on to kill the four
children, but he never explained why he never stopped her. The defendant
then claimed that he and Martin returned to her home, both showered to
wash the blood off their bodies, and then ultimately returned to the
murder scene to help cover up the crime.
Jones acknowledged that he went to his friend Tamika
Terrell's house and that she helped them burn some of his bloody clothes.
Jones's direct examination was labored and difficult
for his own attorney, John McWilliams. Both on and off the stand, Jones
argued with McWilliams over his answers to the questions and wanted to
give detailed answers when McWilliams tried to persuade him to follow
his instructions.
Judge Kym Worthy had to excuse the jury multiple
times to remind Jones that he must only answer the questions asked by
his attorney and that McWilliams was trying to help him.
The defendant denied confessing to the murders when
interrogated by police and said that he jumped out of the window at
police headquarters because he was scared and knew Martin and the police
were trying to pin the murders on him.
However, prosecutor Kevin Simowski took an immediate,
aggressive approach during his
cross-examination of Jones, saying, "You like to tell stories and lie,
don't you, Mr. Jones?" To that, Jones incredibly replied, "Yes."
Simowski continuously accused Jones of lying, saying
that he was really the one that killed Bellamy and the children. Jones
replied that he was following his "script," when he told the story about
Maliaka Martin and the murders.
He said openly in court in front of the jurors that
he was following his script. (This implied
that his prior testimony was a story Jones's attorneys had made up for
him. His attorneys later said on record that they did not encourage him
to make up a story. They only made up notes so that they could verify
the facts of the case with Jones.)
The prosecutor asked Jones to confess, tell the court
the truth about his role in the murders. An unrepentant Jones only kept
referring to his script, denying that he killed the victims. When asked
whether he knew the truth in this case, Jones said he did not.
Finally, prosecutor Simowski gave Jones the chance to
confess to the murders in open court, but Jones refused to answer, and
attempted to use his Fifth Amendment Rights, which he could not do under
these circumstances. With that, Jones's cross-examination ended. His
defense did not present re-direct questions. If convicted of murder,
Jones faces life in prison without parole.
*****
March 27, 1998 -- One day after defendant Reco
Jones's controversial testimony, both the prosecution and the defense
presented closing arguments, with prosecutor Kevin Simowski portraying
Jones as a cold-blooded killer who ate lunch as the bodies of his ex-girlfriend
Yolanda Bellamy and four children were discovered by police.
Simowski told jurors that he would not focus on what
he characterized as Jones's "despicable display" on the stand. Rather,
Simowski said, the "overwhelming" evidence against Jones proves that he
was angry at Bellamy and killed her their sons, niece and nephew in a
rage. The prosecutor outlined the sequence of the slayings for the
jurors for the first time in his closing statements.
Simowski said that when Bellamy insulted Jones, the
defendant stabbed Shafontah and Delvontay Bellamy, who were asleep in
their sleeping bags and did not stand a chance against the attack.
"As her [Yolanda's] life's blood was escaping, Mr.
Jones stabbed Shafontah," Simowski said. "It was as if he was saying, 'Look
what I'm doing to your family' as he tortured the little girl."
At that moment, said Simowski, Bellamy yelled a long
"No!" and tried to gather her sons, Nathan Jr. and Nathan III, and
escape. But Jones, said the prosecutor, killed Bellamy and young Nathan
III while he was still in her arms.
"Mr. Jones told you that no one can speak for Yolanda
Bellamy," Simowsky said. "But she spoke to you through the evidence,
through the DNA evidence."
The prosecutor characterized Jones as a person who
has manipulated women all his life, hiding behind girlfriends and even
his mother. Simowski noted how after his arrest, Jones tried to hide the
cut he suffered on his right hand when he attacked Bellamy and the
children. As he showed photos taken of Jones after his arrest, the
prosecutor said, "You know what our hider does? The guy who hides behind
the women? Now he's hiding his right palm."
Simowski also noted for jurors how angry Jones
appeared to be at police officer Monica Childs, who testified that Jones
had admitted committing the murders to her. Simowski claimed that Jones
was angry at Childs because she was one of the few females in his life
who had betrayed him.
Jones, the prosecutor also noted, went to get a
haircut after the crimes to remove more possible evidence and as Yolanda
Bellamy's sister, Ericka, found her children and sister in a blood of
blood, Jones was having lunch. "How cold can you be?" Simowski asked the
jurors.
Defense attorney Kendall Sailler responded to the
prosecution's closing arguments by saying that if there is a reasonable
doubt that Jones did not kill the five victims and that they were
murdered by someone else (such as his ex-girlfriend Maliaka Martin),
then they must find him not guilty. Sailler characterized the murders as
the most heinous in Detroit's history, but also noted that the
prosecution's case was based largely on circumstantial evidence. No one,
said Sailler, saw Jones commit the crimes, and no one testified that
they saw him murder the victims.
Sailler said that police and prosecutors, anxious to
find a suspect, rushed to arrest his client and did not investigate
other possible suspects. "There was a rush to judgment in this case,"
Sailler said. "They had four dead kids, and they had to do something."
The defense attorney also said that the state's
strongest evidence, the DNA evidence, was based on what he called a "water
spot" and that the jury cannot convict Jones on evidence taken from a
water spot.
In addition, Sailer also attempted to explain Jones's
behavior on the stand by emphasizing that Jones is a scared "street kid"
who did not react well to the pressures of being on the stand and on
Court TV.
"He's scared to death... I hope you can understand
he's a very scared young man," Sailler said. "Perhaps it was a mistake
thinking that he could handle the pressures of testifying on the stand.
Please understand that my client is a street kid...he's not a rocket
scientist. He was doing his best and it was not real good."
During rebuttal closings, prosecutor Simowski
chastised the defense for not knowing the exact names of the police
officers they named in their closing arguments and accused them of
making up and changing their story about the murders during the course
of the trial.
"[They said] 'I'm not going to say a name in opening
statements because we're going to make it up as we go along,"' Simowski
said of Jones's defense team.
"They found a scapegoat, but they waited until the
end of the trial because they weren't sure who to pin it on...They're
playing over here." Simowski also commented on the defense's allegations
that Jones is scared. "He [Jones] wasn't so scared that he couldn't go
to Fishbones and have lunch," the prosecutor said. "He's scared because
the truth is coming right at him. Here comes the truth, Mr. Jones."
Afterwards, Judge Kym Worthy instructed the jury to
consider both first and second-degree murder charges against Jones. If
convicted of first-degree murder, Jones could face life in prison.
*****
VERDICT
March 30, 1998 -- After two hours of
deliberations that began on late Friday, Reco Jones was convicted of
five counts of first-degree murder in the brutal slayings of his ex-girlfriend
Yolanda Bellamy, her two sons, and her niece and nephew. Jones'
conviction did not come as a surprise, especially after his bizarre
behavior during his testimony last Thursday where he openly argued with
his attorneys and alluded to "script" he followed when he gave his
account of the murders.
Prosecutors claimed that Jones, 23, killed Bellamy in
a rage after she told him that she was pregnant and refused to have his
baby because he was not a "real man." Jones then
killed Bellamy's sons, Nathan Burns, Jr. and Nathan, III, and Bellamy's
niece and nephew, Shafontah and Delvontay, when they walked in on the
altercation between him and Bellamy. The young victims were no older
than five years old.
Jones's defense said that police arrested the wrong
person and claimed that Maliaka Martin, one of Jones's ex-girlfriends
and a sexual rival of Bellamy, killed the five victims.
Reco Jones was unemotional as the sentence was read.
Although there was high tension between relatives of Jones and Bellamy
during the trial, the court remained silent once the verdict was
announced. Jones could face life in prison when Judge Kym Worthy
sentences him on April 17.
*****
SENTENCE
April 22, 1998 -- The grandmother who has no
more grandchildren. The childless mother. The hardened prosecutor who
doesn't usually cry. They all had their final say Tuesday to Reco Jones,
the man convicted of one of Detroit's most heinous crimes.
They all addressed Jones before Wayne County Circuit
Judge Kym Worthy sentenced Jones to five life terms in prison for
slashing and torturing his ex-girlfriend and four children to death last
summer.