Richard Charles Johnson, the appellant, was
indicted for the murder of Bruce K. Smalls (Trooper Smalls), a South
Carolina State Trooper. A jury convicted appellant of murder, and he
was sentenced to death. We reverse and remand this case for a new
trial.
In September, 1985, Dan Swanson (Swanson) was
traveling through North Carolina in his recreational vehicle on his
way to Florida when he picked up appellant, who was hitchhiking. The
following day Swanson and appellant picked up hitchhikers Curtis
Harbert (Harbert) and Connie Hess (Hess), alias Julie Smith, on
Interstate 95.
This group made stops in Florence County and
Clarendon County, South Carolina, where Swanson parked along the
interstate to rest. As Swanson slept, the appellant fatally shot him
with a .357 caliber gun. Appellant and Harbert wrapped Swanson's
body in blankets and sheets, tied it with wire and concealed the
corpse in the vehicle underneath a mattress.
The appellant, Harbert and Hess continued their
journey in Swanson's vehicle with appellant driving. Appellant had
been drinking liquor and began driving erratically. Several
motorists noticed his reckless operation of the vehicle, including a
truck driver who notified Trooper Smalls. The officer stopped the
vehicle and during the questioning, appellant shot Trooper Smalls
six times, killing him.
Appellant alleges he was denied due process of
law when the solicitor argued to the jury during the guilt phase of
the trial that appellant had shown no remorse for his actions.
Defendant was convicted of murder by the General
Sessions Court, Jasper County, William T. Howell, J., by jury
verdict. Defendant appealed. The Supreme Court, Finney, J., held
that: (1) solicitor's improper reference to defendant's lack of
remorse was error; (2) admission of extensive evidence in detail of
defendant's prior criminal conduct constituted reversible error; (3)
the trial court's failure to comply with requirements for clarifying
jury's concern about parole during sentencing phase was error; and
(4) defendant was denied fair trial. Reversed and remanded for new
trial.