|

Summary:
On Feb. 2, 1994, around 1:00 p.m., 75-year-old Willard Davis was
found lying in the street in front of his home in Longview. Davis
had been shot once in the head and his car had been stolen.
The police arrested T.J. Jones several blocks from the crime scene
after he abandoned the victim's car. When apprehended, Jones had the
murder weapon, a .357 revolver, in his sweatshirt pocket. The weapon
was fully loaded, except for one round, cocked, and ready to fire.
Jones confessed to the police that he and three friends had been
drinking at a friend's house around 12:15 p.m. Jones asked his
friends if they were "down for a jack," meaning did they want to
steal a car. He claimed that the he was not aware that he had shot
Davis, and that he did not intend to kill him, only to scare him.
The medical examiner testified that Davis died of a single gunshot
wound to the head, which entered near the center of his forehead
next to his left eyebrow.
A firearm expert testified that the gun did not go off accidentally;
it could not have been fired unless the trigger was pulled. Forensic
evidence showed that Jones was two to three feet from Davis when the
gun was fired.
Jones was the 19th murderer executed in the
United States since 1976 for a murder committed when younger than
18, and the 11th in Texas.
Final Meal:
Triple meat cheeseburger with fried bun and everything, French fries,
ketchup, four pieces of chicken (two legs and two thighs), and one
fried pork chop sandwich.
Final Words:
"I would like to say to the victim's family I regret the pain I put
y'all through. I hope you can move on after this. Mom, I love y'all.
Take care. I'm ready."
ClarkProsecutor.org
Texas Attorney General
Media Advisory
Tuesday, Aug. 6, 2002
T.J.
Jones Scheduled to be Executed.
AUSTIN - Texas Attorney General John Cornyn
offers the following information on T.J. Jones, who is scheduled to
be executed after 6 p.m. on Thursday, Aug. 8, 2002.
On Oct. 28, 1994 T.J. Jones was sentenced to
death for the capital murder of Willard Davis during a robbery,
which occurred in Longview, Texas, on Feb. 2, 1994. A summary of the
evidence presented at trial follows:
FACTS OF THE CRIME
On Feb. 2, 1994, around 1:00 p.m., 75-year-old
Willard Davis was found lying in the street in front of his home in
Longview. Davis had been shot once in the head and his car had been
stolen.
The police arrested T.J. Jones several blocks from the crime
scene after he abandoned the victim's car. When apprehended, Jones
had the murder weapon, a .357 revolver, in his sweatshirt pocket.
The weapon was fully loaded, except for one round, cocked, and ready
to fire.
After his arrest, Jones confessed to the police
that he and three friends had been drinking at a friend's house
around 12:15 p.m.
Jones asked his friends if they were "down for a
jack," meaning did they want to steal a car. The friends agreed, and
the four of them went to a known gang-house to obtain a gun to use
in the "jack."
According to Jones' confession, they saw Davis
backing out of his driveway in a red car. Jones approached the car
and told Davis to step outside. Jones stated that, although he had
the gun out, he was not pointing it at Davis at that time.
Davis got out of the car, and Jones' three
friends got in. Jones stated that Davis was standing at the back of
the car when Jones told him to get into the car.
Davis said he would
not because of his wife, or something to that effect. Jones then
pointed the gun to the side of Davis' head and tried to get him into
the car so they could take him somewhere and rob him.
When Davis would not get into the car, Jones said
that he decided to shoot the gun in an attempt to scare him. Jones
claimed that as soon as he shot the gun, he got scared, jumped in
the car, and quickly drove off. Jones claims he was not aware that
he had hit Davis, and that he did not intend to kill him, only to
scare him.
The medical examiner testified that Davis died of
a single gunshot wound to the head, which entered near the center of
his forehead next to his left eyebrow.
A firearm expert testified
that the gun did not go off accidentally; it could not have been
fired unless the trigger was pulled. Forensic evidence showed that
Jones was two to three feet from Davis when the gun was fired.
Jones' cell mate from the Gregg County Jail
testified that Jones told him that he and his accomplices saw Davis
walking to his car and approached him. Davis told Jones and his
accomplices that they could not have his car and that they would
have to kill him to get it. Jones told his cell mate, in a very calm
manor, that he then shot Davis.
Jones' mother testified that she first began
having trouble with Jones when he was 16 years old, which was the
same time that Jones moved into the gang-house.
Jones denied being a
member of a gang, and in his defense offered the testimony of
Heather McLane, the 16-year-old mother of his child, who testified
that she had lived in the gang-house with Jones and his friends, and
did not consider herself to be a member of a gang. When asked if
Jones considered himself a member of a gang, she replied: "Not that
[she] knew of."
Tom Allen, a clinical and forensic psychologist,
testified regarding Jones' propensity for future violence. Allen
felt that Jones posed a threat to society to commit future acts of
violence.
Allen's opinion was based on Jones' criminal history,
particularly his willingness to use unnecessary violence to obtain
property, the number of times Jones had been arrested in connection
with criminal activity, his lack of education and job skills, his
age, and his use of illegal drugs.
In defense, Jones called Craig Moore, a clinical
psychologist. Moore concluded that Jones was competent, below
average in intelligence, but not retarded, profoundly immature ("needy,"
dependent), not trustful of others, and had a conduct disorder,
which is the failure to acquire rule-abiding behavior.
Moore also
concluded that Jones presents "a distinct propensity for future
risks to society," but that Jones -- at 17 year old -- was still
developing-- and there was no way to determine his long-range
behavior. Moore stated that Jones had been profoundly affected by
being reared in a one-parent home and his failure to "bond" with his
mother.
Moore also stated that Jones' use of marijuana
laced with embalming fluid was addictive and could have caused brain
damage, particularly in the areas of the brain affecting judgment
and reasoning. Finally, Moore testified that Jones did not have a
normal ability to show emotion, did not feel good about himself, and
was preoccupied with guilt, grief, and sadness.
Pamela Jones testified that Jones was her only
child and that his father left six months after Jones was born.
Pamela Jones began a relationship with another man when Jones was
approximately 10 or 11 years old. Jones would "hum and shake" when
Ms. Jones and her boyfriend would argue and fight.
Although Jones
was close to his grandmother, he did not show any emotion when she
died. Ms. Jones said that Jones was unable to participate in
gymnastics because she could not afford to pay for it. She also
stated that Jones preferred to play Nintendo and with action
figures, which was uncharacteristic given Jones' age. Will Jackson,
Jr., Jones' grandfather, testified that Jones was a "follower."
PROCEDURAL HISTORY
-
Oct. 24, 1994 - Jones was tried in the 124th
Judicial District Court of Gregg County, Texas, and found guilty of
the capital murder of Willard Davis while in the course of
committing robbery.
-
Oct. 28, 1994 - After a separate punishment phase, the court
sentenced Jones to death.
-
Dec. 18, 1996 - Jones' conviction and sentence affirmed by the Texas
Court of Criminal Appeals.
-
Dec. 11, 1997 - Jones filed an application for post conviction writ
of habeas corpus in the state court.
-
Jan. 13, 1998 - The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals adopted the
recommendation of the trial court and denied state habeas relief.
-
Aug. 30, 1999 - Jones filed a petition for writ of habeas corpus in
the federal district court.
-
Jan. 11, 2001 - The district court entered final judgment dismissing
Jones' federal petition for writ of habeas corpus and denying all
relief. However, the district court issued Certificate of
Appealability (COA) as to two issues: Jones' claim that a juror was
influenced by out of court information, and his claim that the trial
court improperly excused a venire person for cause. Jones filed a
motion to enlarge COA to include nine additional issues, which both
the district court and the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals denied.
-
Sept. 19, 2001 - After oral arguments, the Fifth
Circuit affirmed the District Court's denial of relief.
PRIOR CRIMINAL HISTORY
TDCJ records show that Jones has no prior
criminal record as an adult.
The evidence during the punishment phase showed
that Jones was arrested for breaking into and vandalizing a middle
school in Longview when he was 14 or 15 years old. Jones was
arrested and confessed to throwing a large concrete block through
the front glass door of a sporting goods store, then stealing
clothing from the store.
Jones was also found in possession of
baseball trading cards, taken from a neighbor's home during a
burglary. Jones claimed a friend gave him the cards but the friend
could not be located. The record does not indicate that Jones was
ever charged with any of these crimes, or that any of these
burglaries resulted in a conviction or probation.
Jones was a suspected member of a gang that was
known in the law enforcement community to engage in various criminal
activities, such as assaults, sexual assaults, illegal weapons
possession, and illegal drug possession.
Three days before the murder of Willard Davis,
Jones repeatedly shot the clerk of a convenience store before
robbing him. Jones shot the clerk first in the head, then several
more times as the victim lay on the ground. The victim, who was
struck in the head, chest, arm and shoulder, survived but is
permanently disabled.
ProDeathPenalty.com
T.J. Jones was sentenced to death for the robbery
and murder of 75-year-old Willard Lewis Davis in Longview.
Jones was part of a group of four young people
drinking at a friend's house during the early afternoon hours of
Feb. 2, 1994. Jones asked his friends if they were "down for a jack,"
(if they wanted to steal a car).
They agreed, and after getting a .357-caliber
pistol, the group saw 75-year-old Willard Davis backing out of his
driveway in his car. Jones approached the car and told Davis to get
out. He did, and Jones' three friends got in.
Jones then told Davis to get back in the car so
he could be taken to a more secluded area and robbed; Davis refused.
According to forensic evidence used at Jones'
trial, he was between two and three feet away when he fired at Davis
with a .357 Magnum pistol, striking him in the head and killing him
instantly. Davis's body was dumped in the driveway, and the group
fled in his car.
They were caught after they crashed the car a
short time later and all four confessed to the police investigators.
Jones was arrested several blocks from the scene less than an hour
later after abandoning the car. Edgar Fletcher Jr., 19, Sanford Ray
Jimerson, 18 and Latecia Howard, 17, were also taken into custody.
According to his cellmate in the Gregg County
Jail, Jones calmly described how Davis had told him he would have to
kill him to take his car, at which point Jones said he shot him.
Jones had been accused of shooting the clerk of a
convenience store several times just three days before Davis' murder.
The victim, Willard Davis, was shot in the head, chest, arm and
shoulder and was permanently disabled as a result of the attack.
Texas Execution Information
Center by David Carson
Txexecutions.org
T. J. Jones, 25, was executed by lethal injection
on 8 August in Huntsville, Texas for the carjacking murder of a 75-year-old
man.
In February 1994, four young people saw Willard
Lewis Davis, 75, backing out of his driveway. One of the youths, T.J.
Jones, then 17, approached the car and told Davis to get out.
Davis
was carrying a .357 magnum revolver. When Davis got out of the car,
the other three youths -- Edgar Fletcher Jr., 19, Sanford Ray
Jimerson, 18, and Latecia Howard, 17, got in. Jones then told Davis
to get back in the car, but Davis refused.
Jones then shot Davis
once in the head from a distance of two to three feet. He got in the
car with his three friends and drove off. Davis died in the road in
front of his house. The bandits were captured a short time later
after wrecking Davis' car.
All four gave written confessions to the police.
In his confession, Jones stated that he and his friends had been
drinking when he asked them if they were "down for a jack," i.e. if
they wanted to steal a car. They agreed, and went to a gang house to
obtain a gun. Jones stated that he only fired the gun in an attempt
to scare Davis, and he did not intend to kill him. When he was
arrested, he was carrying the murder weapon -- a loaded .357 magnum
revolver with one round fired.
At 17, Jones had no prior felony convictions. He
did, however, have a history of arrests for vandalism, burglary, and
drug usage. He was also charged with the attempted murder of a
convenience store clerk, which occurred three days before the murder
of Willard Davis.
Craig Moore, a clinical psychologist testifying
for the defense, said that Jones had a below-average intelligence
and had the emotional maturity of a 10 to 12 year old. He also
testified that Jones may have had brain damage from using drugs.
Nevertheless, Moore testified that Jones was mentally competent and
was not retarded.
A jury convicted Jones of capital murder in
October 1994 and sentenced him to death. The Texas Court of Criminal
Appeals affirmed the conviction and sentence in December 1996.
Jones' state habeas corpus appeals were denied, but in 2001, the
U.S. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals agreed to hear his case.
Jones'
lawyers contended that a juror in his case was influenced by
out-of-court information, and that the trial court improperly
excluded a potential juror. The Fifth Circuit rejected these claims
in September 2001.
"I would like to say to the family, I regret the
pain I've put you through. I hope you can move on after this," Jones
said in his last statement. "Mom, I love y'all. Take care. I'm ready."
The lethal injection was started, and Jones was pronounced dead at
6:18 p.m.
Jones' three co-defendants were convicted of
engaging in organized criminal activity and received long prison
terms.
Texas Man Convicted of Murder at 17 Executed
Canadian Coalition to Abolish
the Death Penalty
An 8th-grade dropout who was a teenager when he
was convicted of killing an East Texas man during a carjacking more
than 8 years ago apologized for the crime and was executed today. "I
would like to say to the victim's family I regret the pain I put
y'all through. I hope you can move on after this," T.J. Jones said,
looking at relatives of his victim.
Then Jones, 25, turned to a second window where
his mother was watching and said, "Mom, I love y'all. Take care. I'm
ready." He gasped and stopped breathing. Jones was pronounced dead
at 6:18 p.m., 7 minutes after the lethal dose began. His mother
sobbed quietly and was comforted by Jones' aunt.
Jones was 17 when he was arrested with 3
companions for gunning down 75-year-old retired electrician Willard
Davis, who had surrendered his car to them outside his home in
Longview, about 190 miles north of Houston. "They tried to make him
get in the back seat and he said: 'No. Here's my car. Please let me
go to my wife,'" recalled Alfonso Charles, an assistant district
attorney in Gregg County who helped prosecute Jones. "And T.J. shot
him right between the eyes."
Jones' lawyers filed no late appeals to try to
halt the punishment. "He has exhausted his remedies," attorney Don
Davidson said. Jones' sentence and his age at the time of the
shooting renewed criticism from traditional death penalty opponents.
As a teenage offender, Jones "would not be facing this punishment in
almost any other country in the world," Amnesty International said
in a statement.
"He's not a juvenile," Gregg County District
Attorney Bill Jennings responded. "Under Texas law he is an adult
and he's in an adult system. "He did an adult crime and he deserves
to receive an adult penalty, which in this case 12 jurors decided
should be death."
Texas is among 22 states that allow capital
punishment for 17-year-olds. Jones was the 12th Texas inmate and the
20th in the United States executed since 1976 for a murder committed
when the killer was younger than 18.
In May, and with much greater
outcry from capital punishment opponents, Napoleon Beazley received
lethal injection in Texas for killing the father of a federal judge.
Beazley was 17 at the time of the crime. "I'm pretty sure of my fate
here," Jones, who declined to speak with reporters in the weeks
leading up to his execution, said on a Web site sponsored by an anti-death
penalty organization. On the site, he asked for pen pals "who will
give me moral support and if possible help me to make the rest of my
stay here as comfortable as can be in this situation."
Court records show Jones and 3 partners
approached Davis the mid-afternoon of Feb. 2, 1994 and demanded his
red Chrysler LeBaron. When Davis surrendered the car but refused to
go with them, he was shot with a .357-caliber Magnum. Witnesses saw
Jones and his companions get in the car and drive away. Davis' wife
of 56 years heard the shots from inside her house and was among the
1st to see the body.
All 4 teenagers were arrested soon after the
shooting. "The car made it a short distance before a tire blew out,"
Jennings said. Jones' partners were convicted of engaging in
organized criminal activity and received long prison terms.
Testimony showed Jones lived in a gang house with
the then-16-year-old mother of his child and was addicted to smoking
marijuana laced with embalming fluid. He had been arrested
repeatedly as a juvenile for burglary and police said the gang was
believed responsible for numerous assaults. 3 days before the Davis
killing, authorities determined Jones shot a convenience store clerk
during a robbery in nearby Tyler. The victim survived 5 bullet
wounds and testified against Davis in the punishment phase of the
capital murder trial.
Another 2 executions are set for next week, and 2
more for later in the month, including Toronto Patterson, who was 17
in 1995 when he was arrested for shooting a mother and her 2 young
daughters at their home in Dallas.
Jones becomes the 20th condemned inmate to be put
to death this year in Texas and the 2nd in as many days. Richard
William Kutzner, 59, was executed Wednesday for killing a Montgomery
County woman during a robbery. Kutzner had a 2nd death sentence for
a similar Harris County slaying.
Jones was the 276th condemned
inmate put to death in Texas since the state resumed capital
punishment on December 7, 1982. Jones becomes the 40th condemned
inmate to be put to death this year in the USA and the 789th overall
since America resumed executions on January 17, 1977.
(Sources: Associated Press & Rick Halperin)
T. J. Jones
The Huntsville Item
Attention focuses on tonight's
execution of inmate T.J. Jones, sentenced to death for the 1994
killing of a 75-year-old Longview man, is scheduled to become the
second man executed in as many days if his sentence is carried out
this evening. Jones' case has received some international attention
because he was 17 years old at the time of the murder.
Jones was part of a group of 4 young people
drinking at a friend's house during the early afternoon hours of
Feb. 2, 1994. Jones asked his friends if they were "down for a jack,"
or if they wanted to steal a car. They agreed, and after getting a
.357-caliber pistol, the group saw 75-year-old Willard Davis backing
out of his driveway in his car. Jones approached the car and told
Davis to get out. He did, and Jones' three friends got in.
Jones then told Davis to get back in the car so
he could be taken to a more secluded area and robbed; Davis refused.
According to forensic evidence used at Jones' trial, he was between
2 and 3 feet away when he fired at Davis, striking him in the head
and killing him instantly. Jones was arrested several blocks from
the scene less than an hour later after abandoning the car.
Edgar Fletcher Jr., 19, Sanford Ray Jimerson, 18 and Latecia Howard, 17,
were also taken into custody. According to his cellmate in the Gregg
County Jail, Jones calmly described how Davis had told him he would
have to kill him to take his car, at which point Jones said he shot
him.
During Jones' trial, clinical psychologist Craig
Moore, called by the defense, described him as "profoundly immature"
and distrustful of others. He also said Jones has an IQ of 78, a low
but acceptable intelligence level, and that his continued use of
marijuana laced with embalming fluid was addictive and might have
caused brain damage. Moore also said Jones was still developing at
the age of 17, but admitted he presented "a distinct propensity for
future risks to society."
As part of its case, the prosecution told the
jury Jones had been accused of shooting the clerk of a convenience
store several times just 3 days before Davis' murder. The victim,
Willard Davis, was shot in the head, chest, arm and shoulder and was
permanently disabled as a result of the attack. On Oct. 24, 1994,
Jones was found guilty of capital murder, and 4 days later, he was
sentenced to death.
International activist groups have taken up the
cause of Jones, now 25. Amnesty International and the European Union
have both demanded Texas Gov. Rick Perry halt Jones' execution,
claiming it would violate the International Covenant on Civil and
Political Rights, which bars the execution of individuals who
committed their crimes before age 18. The United States is not a
signatory to the treaty, and a 17 year old is legally considered an
adult in Texas. Perry has rejected similar demandsin the past.
Jones has requested his lawyers not seek clemency
or any further appeals. Barring a last-minute stay, Jones will be
executed sometime after 6 p.m. in the death chamber of the
Huntsville "Walls" Unit.
NATIONAL COALITION TO ABOLISH
THE DEATH PENALTY----PRESS RELEASE
On The Execution Dates for TJ Jones and Toronto
Patterson
RACE, GEOGRAPHY AND THE EXECUTION OF JUVENILE OFFENDERS:
ONCE AGAIN, TEXAS LEADS THE PACK.
Aug. 5, 2002 - The National Coalition to Abolish
the Death Penalty Monday called on Texas Gov. Rick Perry to
acknowledge the role that race and geography play in the application
of the death penalty, particularly as it relates to juvenile
offenders, and to stay the scheduled executions of T.J. Jones and
Toronto Patterson.
Since executions resumed in the United States in
the 1970s, 19 juvenile offenders have been put to death. The past
four such executions have each taken place in Texas and each has
involved an African American inmate. If the scheduled Aug. 8
execution of Jones and the scheduled Aug. 28 execution of Patterson
are allowed to proceed, it will mean that the last 6 juvenile
offender executions in the United States all will have taken place
in Texas and all will have involved African American inmates.
"Texas has accounted for 11 of the 19 juvenile
offender executions in the United States during the past 2 decades,"
said NCADP Executive Director Steven W. Hawkins. "7 of the 11
juvenile offenders executed in Texas have been African American or
Latino. The death penalty in the United States disproportionately
affects people of color and this is even more true when it comes to
juvenile offenders."
Hawkins noted that of the 81 juvenile offenders
on death row in the United States, 52, or almost 2/3, are people of
color. Of the 81 inmates, just over 1/2 - 42 - are from Texas or
Alabama. The past 4 juvenile offenders executed in Texas were
Napolean Beazley, executed May 28; Gerald Mitchell, executed Oct.
22, 2001; Gary Graham, executed June 22, 2000; and Glen McGinnis,
executed Jan. 25, 2000.
Hawkins added that Texas is speeding up its pace
of executing juvenile offenders even as the international community
shuns the practice. Only three countries - the United States, Iran
and the Democratic Republic of Congo - currently execute juvenile
offenders. Just last week, Pakistan announced it is sparing the
lives of 72 juvenile offenders while in the Philippines, the Supreme
Court ordered the removal of a dozen juvenile offenders from death
row, ruling that their execution would violate the law.
"Such executions not only violate international
norms, they also offend human decency," Hawkins said. "The mind of a
juvenile offender is by definition less developed than the mind of
an adult. Juvenile minds do not handle social pressure, instinctual
urges and other stresses the way that adult minds do. Juvenile
offenders therefore cannot be held to the same degree of culpability
as adults, just as mentally retarded people cannot be held to the
same degree of culpability. We now ban the execution of mentally
retarded offenders. There can be little justification for applying a
different standard when it comes to juveniles."
T.J. JONES ORIGINAL PEN PAL REQUEST
My name is T.J. Jones and I've been on Texas
Death Row for 5 years now, and I'm seeking pen pals all over the
world who are interested in writing someone like me. I'm pretty sure
of my fate here, so I'm looking for a pen pal who will give me moral
support and if possible help me to make the rest of my stay here as
comfortable as can be in this situation. My interests are reading,
listening to slow music, and looking for people who have knowledge
in new age books like metaphysics, magick and the like. I'm 23 years
old and anybody male or female around my age or older I would prefer,
but will answer all letters. Here's to finding new and interesting
friends ! - T.J. Jones.
T. J. Jones
Deathrow.at
Execution date set for 08/08/2002
T.J. Jones (m), black, aged 25, is scheduled to
be executed in Texas on 8 August for a murder committed when he was
17 years old. International law, respected in almost every country
of the world except the USA, prohibits the death penalty against
people who were under 18 at the time of the crime.
T.J. Jones was convicted in October 1994 of the
car jacking murder of Willard Lewis Davis, a 75-year-old white man,
in Longview, Gregg County, east Texas on 2 February 1994. T.J. Jones
was also facing charges of attempted murder in relation to a robbery
in neighbouring Smith County committed four days before the Gregg
County crime. During the robbery, T.J. Jones allegedly shot and
seriously wounded a man. Prior to these shootings, T.J. Jones had no
record of violence against people, although as a younger teenager he
had been involved with acts of vandalism and burglary.
A death sentence can only be passed in Texas if
the jury unanimously agrees that 'there is a probability that the
defendant would commit criminal acts of violence that would
constitute a continuing threat to society' - so-called 'future
dangerousness'. The state presented evidence of T.J. Jones's short
juvenile burglary and vandalism record. It also presented detailed
evidence of the Smith County shooting, including testimony from the
victim.
The state presented a psychologist who testified
that T.J. Jones was a future danger. He had, however, never spoken
to or examined the defendant. In contrast to a 1982 US Supreme Court
opinion that 'chronological age of a minor is itself a relevant
mitigating factor of great weight', the expert testified that T.J.
Jones's young age was an aggravating factor. He also stated that his
'lack of education' and consequent lack of 'job skills' made him
likely to commit future acts of criminal violence.
The defence presented a psychologist who had
interviewed and tested T.J. Jones over several visits. He found that
T.J. Jones had an IQ of 78, in the borderline retardation range, and
had begun using drugs and alcohol at age 13, his continuing use of
which exacerbated his 'grossly poor judgment'.
The psychologist found that T.J. Jones was 'typically
a very passive person' and had the emotional and psychological
maturity of a 10 to 12 year old. The expert stated: 'A person at 17,
particularly a person who is this immature cannot, should not be
judged, I think, on the same basis that you would judge a 25 or 30-year-old.
And the reason is simple. Development is still taking place in this
boy. And we really don't know what's in his future in terms of final
and completed development.' He also stated that T.J. Jones could now
be offered rehabilitative treatment, as he could have been if the
authorities had offered appropriate intervention when he had come
into contact with the juvenile justice system as a younger teenager.
Not long before the shootings, T.J. Jones had
been living in a house used by alleged gang members, who had access
to guns and were allegedly involved in criminal violence. T.J. Jones
was the youngest male in the house. The gun used in both offences
was given to him by one of the others in the house, a 22-year-old,
who allegedly participated in the Smith County robbery and the
planning of both crimes. Two other older male teenagers and a 17-year-old
female were also involved in the Gregg County crime.
Various relatives testified on T.J. Jones' behalf
at the trial. His 16- year-old girlfriend, who two months earlier
had given birth to their daughter, suggested that 'peer pressure'
lay behind the crimes. His grandfather stated that T.J. Jones had
always been a 'follower'.
His mother testified about the beatings
she had been subjected to by his father, including when she was
pregnant with TJ. They separated when TJ was a baby. She lived with
another man for about two years when TJ was about 11 to 12. His
violence against her, witnessed by TJ, caused him evident distress.
She testified that she had sought official help with her son when he
quit school at 15 and began to stay away from home, but to no avail.
The unequivocal international prohibition on the
death penalty for people under 18 years old at the time of the crime
is enshrined in the International Covenant on Civil and Political
Rights (ICCPR) and the Convention on the Rights of the Child, the
latter ratified by all countries except the USA and Somalia. The
prohibition stems from the recognition of a young person's
immaturity, impulsiveness, vulnerability to peer pressure, and
capacity for rehabilitation. Since 1998, there have been 15
executions of child offenders documented worldwide, 10 in the USA (six
in Texas).
T.J. Jones has asked his lawyer not to seek
clemency or any further appeals.
National Mental Health
Association News Release
T.J. Jones Faces Unjust Execution; NMHA Urges
Texas Governor Perry to Commute Sentence.
ALEXANDRIA, Va. (August 5, 2002) The National
Mental Health Association sent Texas Gov. Rick Perry a letter urging
him to commute the death sentence of T.J. Jones to life in prison.
Jones has been diagnosed with schizoid personality disorder and has
an IQ of 78, which borders on mental retardation. Just 17 years old
at the time of his offense, Jones faces execution on August 8.
“Governor Perry has a moral responsibility to
commute this sentence and put an end to the practice of executing
people who committed their crimes when they were teens,” said
Michael Faenza, president and CEO of the National Mental Health
Association. “No one can deny the horrible nature of the crime for
which Jones was convicted, but execution is not the answer for a
youthful offender, particularly when the individual was known to
have an untreated mental illness at the time of his offence.”
NMHA opposes the execution of people who
committed their crimes before the age of 18, and believes that the
age, maturity, mental status and childhood history of abuse/trauma
of a youthful offender should always be mitigating factors in
deciding an individual’s punishment.
In T.J. Jones’ case, testimony by the
psychologist for the defense, Dr. Craig Moore, indicated that in
addition to his low IQ and personality disorder, Jones has the
emotional and psychological maturity of a ten to twelve year old.
These factors inherently impact Jones’ decision-making skills and
must be considered in sentencing him to death. Dr. Moore also
testified that Jones is capable of responding to rehabilitative
treatment.
Over the last decade, the United States has
executed more offenders of juvenile crime than the rest of the
world’s nations combined. The death penalty for juvenile offenders
is expressly prohibited by the International Covenant on Civil and
Political Rights, the American Convention on Human Rights and the
U.N. Convention on the Rights of the Child.
The National Mental Health Association is the
country's oldest and largest nonprofit organization addressing all
aspects of mental health and mental illness. With more than 340
affiliates nationwide, NMHA works to improve the mental health of
all Americans through advocacy, education, research and service.
Attention Focuses on Tonight's Execution of
Inmate
By Mark Passwaters -
The Huntsville Item
August 8, 2002
T.J. Jones, sentenced to death for the 1994
killing of a 75-year-old Longview man, is scheduled to become the
second man executed in as many days if his sentence is carried out
this evening. Jones' case has received some international attention
because he was 17 years old at the time of the murder.
Jones was part of a group of four young people
drinking at a friend's house during the early afternoon hours of
Feb. 2, 1994. Jones asked his friends if they were "down for a jack,"
or if they wanted to steal a car.
They agreed, and after getting a
.357-caliber pistol, the group saw 75-year-old Willard Davis backing
out of his driveway in his car. Jones approached the car and told
Davis to get out. He did, and Jones' three friends got in. Jones
then told Davis to get back in the car so he could be taken to a
more secluded area and robbed; Davis refused. According to forensic
evidence used at Jones' trial, he was between two and three feet
away when he fired at Davis, striking him in the head and killing
him instantly.
Jones was arrested several blocks from the scene
less than an hour later after abandoning the car. Edgar Fletcher Jr.,
19, Sanford Ray Jimerson, 18 and Latecia Howard, 17, were also taken
into custody. According to his cellmate in the Gregg County Jail,
Jones calmly described how Davis had told him he would have to kill
him to take his car, at which point Jones said he shot him.
During Jones' trial, clinical psychologist Craig
Moore, called by the defense, described him as "profoundly immature"
and distrustful of others. He also said Jones has an IQ of 78, a low
but acceptable intelligence level, and that his continued use of
marijuana laced with embalming fluid was addictive and might have
caused brain damage. Moore also said Jones was still developing at
the age of 17, but admitted he presented "a distinct propensity for
future risks to society."
As part of its case, the prosecution told the
jury Jones had been accused of shooting the clerk of a convenience
store several times just three days before Davis' murder. The victim,
Willard Davis, was shot in the head, chest, arm and shoulder and was
permanently disabled as a result of the attack. On Oct. 24, 1994,
Jones was found guilty of capital murder, and four days later, he
was sentenced to death.
International activist groups have taken up the
cause of Jones, now 25. Amnesty International and the European Union
have both demanded Texas Gov. Rick Perry halt Jones' execution,
claiming it would violate the International Covenant on Civil and
Political Rights, which bars the execution of individuals who
committed their crimes before age 18. The United States is not a
signatory to the treaty, and a 17 year old is legally considered an
adult in Texas. Perry has rejected similar demands in the past.
Jones has requested his lawyers not seek clemency
or any further appeals. Barring a last-minute stay, Jones will be
executed sometime after 6 p.m. in the death chamber of the
Huntsville "Walls" Unit.
Texas Man Convicted of Murder at 17 Executed
Houston Chronicle
Associated
Press - August 8, 2002
HUNTSVILLE -- An eighth-grade dropout who was a
teenager when he was convicted of killing an East Texas man during a
carjacking more than eight years ago apologized for the crime and
then was executed today. "I would like to say to the victim's family
I regret the pain I put y'all through. I hope you can move on after
this," T.J. Jones said, looking at relatives of his victim.
Then,
Jones, 25, turned to a second window where his mother was watching
and said, "Mom, I love y'all. Take care. I'm ready." He gasped and
stopped breathing. Jones was pronounced dead at 6:18 p.m., seven
minutes after the lethal dose began. His mother sobbed quietly and
was comforted by Jones' aunt.
Jones was 17 when he was arrested with three
companions for gunning down 75-year-old retired electrician Willard
Davis, who had surrendered his car to them outside his home in
Longview, about 190 miles north of Houston. "They tried to make him
get in the back seat and he said: 'No. Here's my car. Please let me
go to my wife,'" recalled Alfonso Charles, an assistant district
attorney in Gregg County who helped prosecute Jones. "And T.J. shot
him right between the eyes."
Jones was the 20th inmate put to death this year
in Texas and the second in as many days. Richard William Kutzner,
59, was executed Wednesday for killing a Montgomery County woman
during a robbery. Kutzner had a second death sentence for a similar
Harris County slaying.
Jones' lawyers filed no late appeals to try to
halt the punishment. "He has exhausted his remedies," attorney Don
Davidson said. Jones' sentence and his age at the time of the
shooting renewed criticism from traditional death penalty opponents.
As a teenage offender, Jones "would not be facing this punishment in
almost any other country in the world," Amnesty International said
in a statement. "He's not a juvenile," Gregg County District
Attorney Bill Jennings responded. "Under Texas law he is an adult
and he's in an adult system. "He did an adult crime and he deserves
to receive an adult penalty, which in this case 12 jurors decided
should be death."
Texas is among 22 states that allow capital
punishment for 17-year-olds. Jones was the 12th Texas inmate and the
20th in the United States executed since 1976 for a murder committed
when the killer was younger than 18. In May, and with much greater
outcry from capital punishment opponents, Napoleon Beazley received
lethal injection in Texas for killing the father of a federal judge.
Beazley was 17 at the time of the crime.
"I'm pretty sure of my fate here," Jones, who
declined to speak with reporters in the weeks leading up to his
execution, said on a Web site sponsored by an anti-death penalty
organization. On the site, he asked for pen pals "who will give me
moral support and if possible help me to make the rest of my stay
here as comfortable as can be in this situation."
Court records show Jones and three partners
approached Davis the mid-afternoon of Feb. 2, 1994 and demanded his
red Chrysler LeBaron. When Davis surrendered the car but refused to
go with them, he was shot with a .357-caliber Magnum. Witnesses saw
Jones and his companions get in the car and drive away. Davis' wife
of 56 years heard the shots from inside her house and was among the
first to see the body. "I was very thankful he apologized,"
Geraldine Davis said after watching Jones die. "It's the first time
he's ever showed any type of remorse. He said he was sorry and I
hope it was a sincere apology and I do appreciate him doing it."
All four teenagers were arrested soon after the
shooting. "The car made it a short distance before a tire blew out,"
Jennings said. Jones' partners were convicted of engaging in
organized criminal activity and received long prison terms.
Testimony showed Jones lived in a gang house with
the then-16-year-old mother of his child and was addicted to smoking
marijuana laced with embalming fluid. He had been arrested
repeatedly as a juvenile for burglary and police said the gang was
believed responsible for numerous assaults.
Three days before the Davis killing, authorities
determined Jones shot a convenience store clerk during a robbery in
nearby Tyler. The victim survived five bullet wounds and testified
against Davis in the punishment phase of the capital murder trial.
Another two executions are set for next week, and two more for later
in the month, including Toronto Patterson, who was 17 in 1995 when
he was arrested for shooting a mother and her two young daughters at
their home in Dallas.
JUVENILE
OFFENDER TJ JONES FACES EXECUTION AUGUST 8TH IN TEXAS
The State of Texas executed T.J. Jones
on August 8, 2002.
Abanet.org TJ
Jones is scheduled to be executed on August 8, 2002, for an offense
he committed when he was barely 17 years old. He was sentenced to
death in October 1994 for the carjacking murder of Willard Lewis
Davis, a 75-year-old white man, in Longview, Texas, on February 2,
1994.
The State's evidence showed that Mr. Davis was
confronted by TJ, who was armed with a pistol, and three other
youths at the end of his driveway. Mr. Davis complied when TJ
ordered him to get out of his car, and TJ shot him once in the
forehead before getting in the car and driving away with his
accomplices. TJ did not have a license or know how to drive and,
after careening through the neighborhood a short distance, wrecked
the car. The police, having been alerted by Mrs. Davis when she
found her husband, and neighbors who observed the suspicious
trajectory of the vehicle, ultimately captured all four accomplices.
In custody, TJ gave a written statement admitting
that he shot Mr. Davis, while alleging that he only intended to
scare the victim. The ballistics evidence ruled out a close range
gunshot (2 to 4 feet). Interestingly, two of the three accomplices
tested positive for apparent gunpowder residue on their hands. In
order to defeat TJ's accident defense, the prosecutors put on
testimony from a "jailhouse snitch" witness, a cell mate of TJ's,
who asserted that TJ told him that Mr. Davis said he would not
relinquish the car unless TJ killed him.
At the punishment phase, the State revealed that
TJ was also facing charges of attempted murder for the shooting of a
Smith County Texaco station attendant during a robbery with other
youths four days prior to the capital offense. The victim testified
that TJ oddly started to shoot him before indicating at all that a
robbery was taking place. In fact, he apparently fired upon the man
before a female shopper (and later witness) had made it out of the
store and back to her car.
The actions TJ allegedly took during the robbery
-- firing without warning, conducting the offense without waiting
until he would not be observed, and taking small bills while leaving
the large -- seemed impulsive and entirely lacking sense or control.
The two offenses within the same week were the only acts of violence
that the State alleged TJ had committed against others.
The State also put on evidence of TJ's prior
arrests for vandalism of a school and participation in the burglary
of a sporting goods store. With respect to every crime for which TJ
was arrested, he had been acting in concert with and under the
influence of other juveniles.
Although TJ may have been the shooter in the two
ultimate offenses, witnesses testified that TJ, an only child, was
generally a passive follower with great need for the enhancement of
his self-esteem that peers could supply. TJ was living in a house
with several other youths. The weapon used was supplied by an older
young man who apparently expected to benefit from the spoils of TJ's
latter offenses without having to directly participate.
At the time of trial, TJ was evaluated for the
defense by Dr. Craig Moore, a clinical psychologist. Dr. Moore
previously had been chief psychologist at Rusk State Hospital, where
he conducted several hundred forensic psychological evaluations. He
was proficient in neuropsychological testing, which detects
cognitive deficits and brain damage, and had previously taught Texas
Department of Corrections personnel in such methods.
Dr. Moore undertook a comprehensive battery of
tests on TJ, including several personal interviews. TJ was born to
parents who divorced when he was very young, leaving him with no
recollection whatsoever of his father. TJ's mother testified that
his father beat her while she was pregnant with TJ. As TJ was
growing up, the only men he knew were his mother's boyfriends. At
least one of these was abusive. This left TJ without a father image
and with a somewhat distant relationship to his mother.
He was diagnosed generally by the defense expert
as schizoid, unable to relate to people, to properly participate in
the give and take of relationships. The only person with whom he
apparently had a close relationship was his grandmother, who died a
few years before his capital offense. Due to his disabilities, TJ
found it very difficult to relate to anyone else with the same
degree of intimacy. He acted out his frustrations, usually under the
influence of other juveniles.
As a result, in 1991 and 1992 he had the two
above-mentioned juvenile arrests for non-violent offenses. The
juvenile system did not pick up on these early signs of problems in
TJ's life. Dr. Moore noted that, despite these problems, TJ never
indicated any propensity to violence until the two shootings he
committed within a week of each other. He observed that this strange
occurrence might implicate a neurological problem. However, no
testing ever has been done on TJ to determine if that was the cause.
Dr. Moore found TJ to be a "very poorly
socialized immature adolescent, a boy who [was] mostly puzzled by
how the world works, who bluff[ed] his way through, who used
marijuana and alcohol as an analgesic to his psychic pain only
complicating his lack of judgment -- his grossly poor judgment." TJ,
along with his peer group, began using alcohol at an early age. His
drinking was well established by age 13 or 14. He also began using
marijuana and speed or amphetamine type substances. He and his
associates used a street drug called Whack, which often is marijuana
laced with PCP. This leads to a quick and intense high and is
relatively inexpensive.
TJ believed that the version of Whack he used,
which produced hallucinations, was laced with small amounts of
embalming fluid. If true, this drug probably caused damage to the
developing frontal lobes of his brain. Another sign of possible
neurological damage was TJ's propensity to rock himself to sleep. TJ
dropped out of school in the ninth grade and tested as having a full
scale IQ of 78 at the time of trial. He was overwhelmed by the
questions in the psychological testing performed by Dr. Moore. For
recreation, TJ played video games and liked to pillow fight. At the
age of 17, he continued to like to watch cartoons on television and
play with toys more appropriate to smaller children.
Dr. Moore found TJ to be socially isolated,
passive in the face of others, and functioning at the level of a
ten-year-old in terms of acquiring the standard behaviors for his
culture. "This is a boy that may look seventeen, but on the inside,
psychologically, he is probably more like a ten or twelve year old.
. . . Every part of interacting with his environment, even when he
is watching T.V., will be that of a child who is ten or twelve years
old."
Dr. Moore asserted that the prosecutors misread
TJ when they maintained he should be held criminally responsible
because he was self-centered. "Please appreciate," he emphasized on
cross-examination, "It isn't just a case of adult selfishness. It
really is I don't understand the world out there. All I understand
is when I'm hungry or when I want something." Despite his
communication disabilities, TJ did express guilt and remorse for his
offenses, expressing worry that God would forgive him for what he
had done.
Dr. Moore opined that TJ should not be judged for
the offense in the same way that a 25 year old would be, because of
his immaturity. Recognizing that the Texas death penalty statute
requires a jury to make a finding on future dangerousness before the
death penalty can be returned, Dr. Moore noted that it would appear
that TJ posed an immediate future risk, but found that there also
was no way to reliably predict future dangerousness in a juvenile
offender like TJ. "A person at seventeen, particularly a person that
is this immature cannot, should not be judged . . . on the same
basis as [an adult]. Development is still taking place in this boy.
And we really don't know what's in his future in terms of final and
completed development. . . . [T]he brain is not even through
developing. The brain continues to develop all the way into the
early twenties. . . . Given the data that I have now, I'd say he's
certainly a significant risk, . . . [b]ut it's the issue beyond age
twenty-five that I have difficulty with. I don't think there's
anyone nor any technology that can tell us how this boy will end up
maturing at that point."
Moore also pointed out that all of the data that
supported statistical studies of future dangerousness was drawn from
adult populations. The results of these studies, then, could not
reasonably be applied to a 17-year-old. In short, the jury could not
reliably predict future dangerousness, certainly not beyond a
reasonable doubt, in an underdeveloped juvenile such as TJ.
Dr. Moore pointed out that, because of a
juvenile's slow biological maturation, psychological science refuses
to diagnose 17-year-olds as having an anti-social personality. "If
they are a normal or highly matured individual, we can do that at
eighteen. If they are immature, the preference in my field is to
wait until they're twenty-five." Moore noted that many factors which
had led to TJ's situation had been out of his control: his lack of
access to a father, the abusive step-father, his failure to develop
a warm, emotional bond with his mother, and his slowness to mature.
He found him treatable and argued that the system had failed TJ.
Early psychological intervention and better supervision of TJ would
have prevented the conditions that led to his assaultive offenses.
Dr. Moore reported that, at TJ's developmental
level, it had been important for him to receive prompt consequences
for his prior misbehavior. The prosecutor pressed Dr. Moore on the
issue of individual accountability, asking him if it did not have
some place in his analysis. Moore responded that, if he felt that he
was faced with a mature 17-year-old or a twenty-five year old, he
would have a different orientation toward accountability. Urged to
recognize that Texas law would treat a 17-year-old as an adult,
Moore replied that from a psychological point of view, there was a "discrepancy
between the seventeen year old being seen as an adult and the
psychological data that suggests he functions more like a twelve or
a ten year old."
In punishment argument, T.J.'s counsel fell on
their own sword, conceding that TJ posed a future risk of danger to
others, even though their own expert had concluded that no such
prognostication was possible. The best defense TJ got at trial was
from Dr. Moore, but even his acute observations were gutted by the
defense. In addition, the jury became distracted with issues not in
evidence. Inter alia, at the behest of a juror who wanted to be sure
that TJ would be on death row long enough to come to find God before
execution, some of the other jurors speculated during deliberations
that the time period for his appeals would be anywhere between 7 and
20 years. Indeed, it has been about seven years and, if executed on
August 8th, TJ will leave behind a seven-year-old daughter.
EXECUTING JUVENILE OFFENDERS RUNS COUNTER TO BASIC
AMERICAN STANDARDS OF JUSTICE AND FAIRNESS
The execution of a juvenile offender is contrary
to fundamental principles of American justice which punishes
according to the degree of culpability and reserves the death
penalty for the "worst of the worst" offenders. By their very nature,
teenagers are less mature, and therefore less culpable, than adults
who commit similar acts but have no such explanation for their
conduct.
Adolescence is a transitional period of life when
cognitive abilities, emotions, judgment, impulse control, identity
-- even the brain -- are still developing. Indeed, immaturity is the
reason we do not allow those under eighteen to assume the major
responsibilities of adulthood such as military combat service,
voting, entering into contracts, drinking alcohol or making medical
decisions. This is not to say that juvenile offenders do not know
right from wrong and should not be punished, but that we as a
society and a legal system have deemed that juveniles are simply
different from adults.
A number of organizations such as the American
Bar Association, The American Psychiatric Association, the Child
Welfare League of America, the Children's Defense Fund, the Youth
Law Center, the Juvenile Law Center, the Coalition for Juvenile
Justice, the American Society for Adolescent Psychiatry, the
American Academy for Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, the National
Mental Health Association, and the Constitution Project have come to
oppose executions for crimes committed by offenders under the age of
18. Similarly, the United Nations High Commission for Human Rights,
the European Union, the Council of Europe and the Vatican have
expressed their strongest opposition to the execution of juvenile
offenders.
A MAJORITY OF STATES HAVE RECOGNIZED THAT SUBJECTING
ADOLESCENTS AND TO THE DEATH PENALTY IS CONTRARY TO BASIC AND
EVOLVING STANDARDS OF DECENCY
Of the 38 states that permit the death penalty,
only 22 permit the execution of persons who were under the age of 18
at the time of their crimes. Among these 22 states, only 15 have
juvenile offenders on their death rows while only 7 have carried out
actual executions of juveniles since the death penalty was
reinstated in 1973. In 2002, Indiana abolished the juvenile death
penalty while Florida came extremely close (a bill passed the Senate
unanimously but died in the House, which had passed a bill the
previous year, only because it ran out of time). In 1999, the State
of Montana abolished the juvenile death penalty while the Florida
Supreme Court raised the age of eligibility from 16 to 17.
A growing number of states are considering
legislation to abolish the execution of juvenile offenders,
including: Arizona, Indiana, Pennsylvania, Kentucky, South Carolina,
Mississippi, Arkansas, and Texas. Indeed, in the Texas 2001
legislative session, a bill to eliminate the death penalty for
offenders under 18 passed the House and gained significant support
in the Senate before it was procedurally barred from reaching a vote
on the Senate floor. Moreover, a recent national poll conducted by
the Houston Chronicle indicated that solid support for the
capital punishment of juvenile offenders has fallen to only 26%.
EXECUTING JUVENILE OFFENDERS IS CONTRARY TO INTERNATIONAL
LAW AND FUNDAMENTAL HUMAN RIGHTS
In continuing to execute juvenile offenders, the
United States acts in defiance of international law and almost
complete agreement among nations. Indeed, such executions have all
but ended around the world, except in the United States. The death
penalty for juvenile offenders is expressly prohibited by the
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), the
American Convention on Human Rights and the U.N. Convention on the
Rights of the Child (CRC). The United States and Somalia (which has
no recognizable government) are the only two countries that have
failed to ratify the CRC -- 191 nations have adopted the fundamental
standards articulated in this treaty.
In the last decade, the United States has
executed more juvenile offenders than all the world's nations
combined. Since 1990, only seven countries are reported to have
executed prisoners who were under 18 years of age at the time of the
crime: The Democratic Republic of Congo, Iran, Nigeria, Pakistan,
Yemen, Saudi Arabia and the United States. The nations of Pakistan,
and Yemen have since abolished the juvenile death penalty, while
Saudi Arabia and Nigeria deny that they have executed juvenile
offenders.
In the last three years the number of nations
that execute juvenile offenders has dropped significantly to only
three: Iran, the Democratic Republic of Congo, Pakistan and the
United States. Moreover, just this past year, Iran stated that it no
longer executes juvenile offenders while the leader of the
Democratic Republic of Congo commuted the death sentences of four
juvenile offenders.
The execution of TJ Jones would further alienate
the United States from the international community, thus damaging
our legitimacy as a leader on the protection and promotion of human
rights, particularly the rights of children.
USA (Texas) T.J. Jones
Amnesty International
July 18, 2002
T.J. Jones (m), black, aged 25, is scheduled to
be executed in Texas on 8 August for a murder committed when he was
17 years old. International law, respected in almost every country
of the world except the USA, prohibits the death penalty against
people who were under 18 at the time of the crime.
T.J. Jones was convicted in October 1994 of the
car jacking murder of Willard Lewis Davis, a 75-year-old white man,
in Longview, Gregg County, east Texas on 2 February 1994. T.J. Jones
was also facing charges of attempted murder in relation to a robbery
in neighbouring Smith County committed four days before the Gregg
County crime. During the robbery, T.J. Jones allegedly shot and
seriously wounded a man. Prior to these shootings, T.J. Jones had no
record of violence against people, although as a younger teenager he
had been involved with acts of vandalism and burglary.
A death sentence can only be passed in Texas if
the jury unanimously agrees that 'there is a probability that the
defendant would commit criminal acts of violence that would
constitute a continuing threat to society' - so-called 'future
dangerousness'. The state presented evidence of T.J. Jones's short
juvenile burglary and vandalism record. It also presented detailed
evidence of the Smith County shooting, including testimony from the
victim.
The state presented a psychologist who testified
that T.J. Jones was a future danger. He had, however, never spoken
to or examined the defendant. In contrast to a 1982 US Supreme Court
opinion that 'chronological age of a minor is itself a relevant
mitigating factor of great weight', the expert testified that T.J.
Jones's young age was an aggravating factor. He also stated that his
'lack of education' and consequent lack of 'job skills' made him
likely to commit future acts of criminal violence.
The defence presented a psychologist who had
interviewed and tested T.J. Jones over several visits. He found that
T.J. Jones had an IQ of 78, in the borderline retardation range, and
had begun using drugs and alcohol at age 13, his continuing use of
which exacerbated his 'grossly poor judgment'. The psychologist
found that T.J. Jones was 'typically a very passive person' and had
the emotional and psychological maturity of a 10 to 12 year old.
The expert stated: 'A person at 17, particularly
a person who is this immature cannot, should not be judged, I think,
on the same basis that you would judge a 25 or 30-year-old. And the
reason is simple. Development is still taking place in this boy. And
we really don't know what's in his future in terms of final and
completed development.' He also stated that T.J. Jones could now be
offered rehabilitative treatment, as he could have been if the
authorities had offered appropriate intervention when he had come
into contact with the juvenile justice system as a younger teenager.
Not long before the shootings, T.J. Jones had
been living in a house used by alleged gang members, who had access
to guns and were allegedly involved in criminal violence. T.J. Jones
was the youngest male in the house. The gun used in both offences
was given to him by one of the others in the house, a 22-year-old,
who allegedly participated in the Smith County robbery and the
planning of both crimes. Two other older male teenagers and a 17-year-old
female were also involved in the Gregg County crime.
Various relatives testified on T.J. Jones' behalf
at the trial. His 16- year-old girlfriend, who two months earlier
had given birth to their daughter, suggested that 'peer pressure'
lay behind the crimes. His grandfather stated that T.J. Jones had
always been a 'follower'.
His mother testified about the beatings she had
been subjected to by his father, including when she was pregnant
with TJ. They separated when TJ was a baby. She lived with another
man for about two years when TJ was about 11 to 12. His violence
against her, witnessed by TJ, caused him evident distress. She
testified that she had sought official help with her son when he
quit school at 15 and began to stay away from home, but to no avail.
The unequivocal international prohibition on the
death penalty for people under 18 years old at the time of the crime
is enshrined in the International Covenant on Civil and Political
Rights (ICCPR) and the Convention on the Rights of the Child, the
latter ratified by all countries except the USA and Somalia. The
prohibition stems from the recognition of a young person's
immaturity, impulsiveness, vulnerability to peer pressure, and
capacity for rehabilitation. Since 1998, there have been 15
executions of child offenders documented worldwide, 10 in the USA (six
in Texas).
T.J. Jones has asked his lawyer not to seek
clemency or any further appeals.
|