Murderpedia has thousands of hours of work behind it. To keep creating
new content, we kindly appreciate any donation you can give to help
the Murderpedia project stay alive. We have many
plans and enthusiasm
to keep expanding and making Murderpedia a better site, but we really
need your help for this. Thank you very much in advance.
In 1987, Kirkland killed his girlfriend Leola
Douglas, and set her body on fire. He pleaded guilty to
manslaughter and served 16 years in prison. He was released from
parole in 2004.
From December 22, 2006 through March 7, 2009,
Kirkland murdered four females, three by strangulation. He had
burned each of his victims' bodies in an attempt to conceal
evidence of rape. Kirkland was arrested near the scene of the
murder of 13-year old Esme Kenny in possession of her watch and
iPod.
After being convicted of aggravated murder,
gross abuse of a corpse, attempted rape and aggravated robbery,
the judge on March 31, 2010 sentenced Kirkland to death.
Victims
Leola Douglas, 27, murdered May 20, 1987.
Casonya Crawford, 15, murdered March, 2006.
Mary Jo Newton, 45, murdered April or May,
2006.
Kimya Rolison, 14, murdered December 22,
2006.
Esme Kenny, 13, murdered March 7, 2009
Although silent throughout the trial, members
of Esme Kenney’s family asked a judge to sentence serial murderer
Anthony Kirkland to death.
The family of another Kirkland murder victim,
Kimya Rolison, wrote a moving poem remembering her but asked the
judge to do something Kirkland didn’t – spare a life.
Hamilton County Common Pleas Court Judge
Charles Kubicki Jr. didn’t hesitate in agreeing with the jury’s
recommendation.
Kubicki gave Kirkland two death sentences, one
each for the murders of Casonya “Sharee” Crawford, 14, and Esme
Kenney, 13. He also imposed two separate sentences of 70 years to
life in prison for Kirkland’s convictions for the murders of
Rolison, 25, and Mary Jo Newton, 45.
Kirkland killed all four, three by
strangulation, and burned their bodies.
“I believe that Anthony Kirkland should be put
to death because he is an evil, remorseless, sadistic murderer. No
living person is safe,” aunt Elizabeth Kenney wrote in a March 29
letter to the judge.
“He deserves the strongest sentence possible,”
cousin Nikki Kenney wrote. “To do anything less would be unjust to
all his victims.”
Rolison’s family disagreed.
Stepmother Kathy Rolison noted the loss of
Kimya left her two children without a mother, but added, “We
respectfully request that the convicted murderer be sentenced to
life in prison.” She provided no explanation for that request.
Kirkland’s murder spree lasted from 2006 until
March 7, 2009, when he was arrested for killing Esme as she jogged
around the Winton Road reservoir. Her family, which requested the
return of the clothes she wore that day and her iPod, didn’t speak
to the media during the trial. But their letters, submitted
Wednesday to the judge, show their anger and loss.
“Maybe you … could have sat crying in the dirt
where she was killed there with us and watched her mother pull
singed pieces of Esme’s hair out of the ground, desperate to
preserve these few slim threads linking her daughter to this
earth,” cousin Brad Kenney wrote to the judge.
The emotions of the victims’ relatives in court
Wednesday were as strong.
“Mr. Kirkland. I call you mister. You don’t
deserve to be called that,” said Arlene Lee, Casonya’s
grandmother. “What you did to my granddaughter you also did to me.
She was part of me.”
Casonya’s aunt, Phyllis Moore, said she felt
sorry for Kirkland. “I have no forgiveness for you. You took a
life. You took something special to me and my family,” she said.
“They call you a monster. I don’t know what to
call you.”
The dual death sentences and life sentences
were a culmination of a month-long trial before Kubicki. Jurors
heard 13 days of testimony before convicting Kirkland and, two
weeks ago, recommending he be put to death.
One juror returned for Wednesday’s sentencing,
warning others that evil lives among us.
“This does happen in life and we have to go on
with ours,” the juror said. “I don’t know how to say I’m sorry to
the families.”
She went to the sentencing, she said, for
closure. “There’s one person I don’t have to fear,” she said.
Kirkland now has been convicted of five deaths.
He served 16 years for the 1987 killing of Leola Douglas after she
spurned his sexual advances. He also set her on fire.
Kubicki set an execution date of Sept. 30, but
that won’t happen.
All death sentences are automatically appealed
even if the inmate doesn’t want that. He could be on Death Row for
years or decades while the appeal is pending.
Kirkland is Ohio's 162nd Death Row inmate and
the 33rd inmate awaiting execution from Hamilton County.
March 12, 2010
Anthony Kirkland acted as judge and executioner
for five women.
Now, it’s Kirkland’s turn to be judged.
Kirkland, 41, was convicted Friday by a
Hamilton County jury of all charges against him in the murders of
teens Casonya “Sharee” Crawford and Esme Kenney. The jury’s
decision – which came after 3½ hours of deliberation – means
Kirkland faces the death penalty when the trial resumes Tuesday.
The jury convicted Kirkland of all counts
against him – aggravated murder, gross abuse of a corpse,
aggravated robbery and attempted rape of both Casonya, 14, and
Esme, 13.
Last week when his trial started, he pleaded
guilty to murder and other charges in the deaths of Mary JoNewton,
45, and Kimya Rolison, 25.
“We expected this,” Norm Aubin, one of
Kirkland’s attorneys, said of Friday’s verdict. “Now, we’ll try to
save his life.”
Kirkland was portrayed by prosecutors as a
ruthless hunter of prey – he specialized in small, young or
down-and-out females – to fuel his lust for sex and his hatred
toward women, seeking to get even for the women he believed ruined
his life.
Each of his victims’ bodies was burned.
Kirkland said that was his burial ritual for purification.
Prosecutor Joe Deters called that “a load of garbage” because he
actually was burning bodies to destroy evidence of his
heinousness.
“Sometimes pure evil just exists. Most people
can’t get their arms around that,” Deters told jurors, calling
Kirkland a monster. “I think over the last two weeks, the state
has … concluded that that’s a fact.”
Kirkland’s attorneys, Aubin and Will Welsh,
presented no defense because of the mountain of evidence – led by
nine hours of statements Kirkland gave to police confessing in
shocking detail to each of the four murders – against him.
Deters told jurors not to be fooled into
believing Kirkland is anything but a cold, calculating, serial
killer.
“Kirkland’s not insane. Kirkland’s not stupid.
These guys do exist. They do exist,” Deters said.
Chief assistant prosecutor Mark Piepmeier noted
all four of the bodies were found in areas people treated like
garbage dumps, symbolic of how Kirkland viewed his victims.
“(In) life, these women are sex objects to
Kirkland,” Piepmeier said. “After life, they were nothing more
than garbage.”
Aubin said Kirkland will give an unsworn
statement in hopes of convincing just one juror to spare his life.
That means Kirkland can speak to the jury but
he won’t be under oath. That way, prosecutors won’t be allowed to
ask him questions – especially about his 1987 manslaughter
conviction for burning Leola Douglas to death for which he served
16 of the 25 years in prison to which he was sentenced.
Kirkland’s attorneys will argue Kirkland be
spared because without his confession, the murders of Newton,
Rolison and Casonya likely never would have been solved.
A verdict of death must be unanimous. If it’s
not, Kirkland faces prison sentences of 25 years to life or 30
years to life for each of the murders of Casonya and Esme.
That’s in addition to the 32 years to two life
terms he faces in prison for the murders of Newton and Rolison.
In addition to Kirkland’s unsworn statement,
Aubin said a Kirkland relative and a mental health expert will
testify, trying to save his life.
Common Pleas Court Judge Charles Kubicki Jr.
told jurors they will resume the case Tuesday. He expects jurors
to begin deliberations on life or death by Wednesday.
The 12 jurors and four alternates will be
sequestered until a verdict is reached.