BATF ACTIONS
LED TO TEN DEATHS
I thought I was going to die that day. I thought I
was going to get blown away. . .Put in that situation where you've got
women and children crying and screaming, "Oh, my God, please help us,
save us, do something! They're shooting at us!". . .You do anything,
you pick up anything you can, if your life is threatened, to defend
yourself. And you do your best to live another day or live another hour
or another minute.
Kevin Whitecliff before sentencing1/
BATF's
violent attack resulted in the deaths of five Davidians--four may have
been killed by shots fired from helicopters. Considering the amount of
gunfire directed at the Davidians from the helicopters and from ground
fire, it is amazing so few were injured or killed. Koresh did tell KRLD
radio on February 28 that his two-year-old daughter had been killed.
Jaime Castillo explains that some of Jaydean Wendell's blood fell on the
child and in the confusion it was explained to Koresh that the child had
died.2/ Other Davidians besides David Koresh not mortally wounded
included Judy Schneider who sitting in a chair when the firing began.
David Jones was wounded in the gluteus maximus and Scott Sonobe in the
leg.3/
Rather than take responsibility for the deaths of the five
Davidians who died during or shortly after the raid, the government has
labelled them "ambushers." At trial, prosecutors falsely claimed
Davidians "not only killed ATF, they killed their own. People who were
too wounded to fight were put out of their misery."4/
While there is no evidence Davidians ambushed BATF, it is clear
they were forced to take up weapons to defend themselves. While they
probably killed and injured BATF agents, some agents were hit by
friendly fire. Later that afternoon BATF agents killed a possibly
unarmed Davidian who was trying to return to Mount Carmel.
EVIDENCE
AGENTS SHOT FROM HELICOPTERS
The
Treasury report claims that when the National Gaurd helicopters got
within 350 meters of the building, they were fired upon and forced
back.5/ At trial helicopter pilots alleged the lead helicopter was hit
by three shots and the other two by one shot each.6/ However, Davidians
allege that agents in one or more helicopters started unprovoked firing
at them as they arrived at the north side of the building and continued
to pass back and forth over the building, firing at will, for several
minutes. They claim there were over 100 bullet holes from the agents in
helicopters shooting into the walls and roofs. The three largest
Davidian lawsuits, filed by the Cause Foundation, Ramsey Clark and
Caddell & Conwell, all charge there was firing from helicopters.7/
In KPOC-TV's "Incident at Waco," investigator Gordon Novel
charged, "In Vietnam, when they would attack a building like this, they
would shoot up the ceiling so everyone would get down." Indiscriminate
firing into a building from helicopters, especially that which killed
unarmed civilians, would open agents to prosecution for negligent or
intentional homicide."8/ If Mount Carmel had stood and the public
discovered agents fired indiscriminately from helicopters had killed
four Davidians, citizens and politicians would have demanded
prosecutions.
When questioned by the author during a May, 1995 televised
debate about whether agents should be charged with murder should
evidence of lethal firing be revealed, former BATF Director Stephen E.
Higgins, who approved the raid, replied, "Absolutely. If they fire at
someone who was not firing at them or pointing a weapon at them it would
absolutely be murder. The rules of the federal government and other law
enforcement officials are that you can only fire when you are trying to
save your own life or lives of other innocent people." Higgins did not
believe the agents were firing from helicopters.9/ However, if this was
his attitude as head of the Bureau, BATF agents would have had much to
fear. There is substantial evidence that BATF agents did shoot from at
least one helicopter. Below is the substantial evidence that BATF
agents shot from at least one and possibly two helicopters.
Davidian
Allegations
Davidians in the back of the building claim first shots came
from the helicopters. In the "Day 51" video Catherine Matteson, 77,
states: "I heard three helicopters. The reason I knew there were three
was I looked out the window and I could see they were firing on us. . .I
was in the back of the building. That's where my room was. And they
were firing towards David's room. And they turned and when they turned
I fell to the floor cause I could see that those bullets could hit me if
I was standing. They went to the front of the building. And it seemed
like by the time they got to the front, they were firing again. .
.Definitely. They were the only ones I heard and saw at the time. They
were coming in on the helicopters. There was no one else firing."
In the same video another elderly woman, Annetta Richards,
recounts: "I was actually getting ready for worship. I heard a noise
like a helicopter and then I heard bullets start firing, bullets start
coming in from every direction. And the helicopters were flying over
the building. The sound of it was so low that at that time I thought
they had landed on the roof. Bullets were coming from all directions."
Marjorie Thomas, a Davidian severely burned in the fire,
agreed to testify for the prosecution in exchange for immunity. In her
video taped testimony Thomas said she was in her third floor room
overlooking the tornado shelter when she noticed her roommates looking
out the window. She looked out and saw three helicopters approaching.
The lead one was shining a bright light, as one helicopter pilot
admitted at trial. "I could see a person hanging from one side of the
helicopter, because it was that close." Since she could see him from
"the waist, down," his legs obviously were hanging outside the aircraft.
On the March 8, 1993 video tape sent out to the FBI Thomas
said, "One minute you're looking out of the windown seeing three
helicopters and the next minute you're on the floor with bullet shells
flying all over your head." At trial she said, "As the helicopter drew
nearer, I heard a sound. It was a bullet coming, which came through the
window and shattered the blinds. We all dived to the floor. We moved
from the window and dived to the floor on hearing the bullets flying
over our heads." While she could not swear the bullets came from the
helicopter, she saw no BATF agents on the ground. At least one bullet
went through the third story window closest to the driveway.10/ Agents
may have thought the women were armed and purposively fired upon them.
Clive Doyle told interviewer Gary Null why he was convinced
Winston Blake, a 28 year old black man from England, was shot from a
helicopter. Blake's room was next to the three plastic water tanks at
the northwest corner of the building. "I could see Winston laying down
in a pool of water. The water tank, which was right up against his
window, was riddled with bullets. Since the tank was at an angle, I
would almost bet my life on it that Winston was shot from a helicopter.
That was the only thing out there that could shoot at that angle. There
weren't any buildings there. There weren't any ATF people on the ground
would be able to shoot at that angle." Jaime Castillo confirms that
bullets came in at that angle.11/
In late March, 1993 Rita Riddle told reporters there was "no
question" agents fired from helicopters. "They say these helicopters
were not armed? Bull puck. I heard them spraying the building when
they went over."12/ In the March 28, 1993 taped interview with attorney
Dick DeGuerin, David Koresh denied that Davidians fired on helicopters
before the cattle trailers arrived and challenged BATF's claim that BATF
agents did not fire on Davidians from helicopters.13/ The negotiation
audio tapes reveal that both Steve Schneider and David Koresh informed
negotiators of the firing.14/
Psychologist Bruce D. Perry, who interviewed Davidian children
who left Mount Carmel after the raid, described a child drawing a
picture of a house beneath a rainbow. "When Perry asked, `Is there
anything else?' the child calmly added bullet holes in the roof."15/
At trial Kathryn Schroeder said she saw a bullet holes in the
ceiling and walls of the four story tower.16/ During allocution before
sentencing Davidian prisoner Kevin Whitecliff said he was scared when he
heard women and children screaming as agents began their raid: "There
were three or four helicopters buzzing around shooting at people. I
thought I was going to die."17/
At allocution Renos Avraam tried to call to the stand BATF
investigator Davy Aguilera, who was in one of the helicopters, to prove
that helicopter pilots had lied when they denied there was shooting from
the helicopters. When Judge Walter Smith would not permit it, Avraam
asserted BATF came "with helicopters blazing. Davy Aguilera, he was
firing one of them. He ain't going to deny it. Helicopters blazing."
Avraam bitterly complained that National Guard helicopter pilots
perjured themselves. He himself saw the firing on February 28th.18/
Fifteen minutes into the raid, in their second phone call to
9-1-1, Davidians complain frantically to Lieutenant Lynch about
helicopters firing on them as nearly continuous gunfire can be heard in
the background.
Wayne
Martin: Another chopper with more people; more guns going off. They're
firing. That's them, not us.
Steve Schneider: There's a chopper with more of them.
Lt. Lynch: What!?
Schneider: Another chopper with more people and more guns
going off. Here they come!
Lynch: All right, Wayne, tell. . .
Schneider: We're not firing. That's not us, that's them!
Lynch: All right. Standby. I'm tryin' to reach 'em.
Stand. Don't return fire, okay?
Schneider: We haven't been.
Lynch: What?
Schneider: We haven't been.
Later
in the 9-1-1 tape Martin demands: "Don't land any more choppers," and
"We don't want any more choppers out here."19/ At trial both Judge
Smith and the prosecutors tried to dismiss these statements as
"self-serving," implying that panicky civilians would make up such a
story for some nefarious purpose!20/
KWTX-TV Video
Shows Shots Fired From Sky
The frequently shown KWTX-TV video of an agent being shot at
through the wall of the second story room displays clear evidence that
at least four bullets were fired from above, even as the sounds of
helicopters flying overhead can be heard. "Waco, the Big Lie Continues"
slows down the video and points out obvious bullet entries from overhead
into the roof, eaves, and wall. While BATF agents alleged in court that
Davidians were firing at them from the four story tower,21/ the
trajectory of the bullets appears much too steep to have come from the
tower.
The holes are shot through the roof right after an agent
appears to fire into the arms room, so it is possible Davidians were
defending against that agent's attack. However, it also possible that
an agent in a helicopter, seeing the other agent shooting into the room
(and not knowing there were already three agents inside) attempted to
help him by shooting in as well!
Many suspect KWTX-TV managers, fearful of offending the
government and the Federal Communications Commission, edited out even
more damaging evidence of helicopter and other illegal gunfire. At
trial KWTX-TV cameraman Dan Mulloney stated that although he was on the
scene for more than two hours and brought four hours of video tape, he
shot only 17 minutes of video because he was trying to save tape. He
asserted that the video shown by prosecutors "was not edited, it was
shot from the camera. The glitches and things were myself turning the
camera on and off. But it did come from a raw tape, and I'm not
familiar who dubbed in down from the raw master tape." However, he
then admitted that prosecutors had not show some film at the end of the
tape, where BATF agents had physically assaulted and knocked him
down.22/ It is likely Mulloney does not remember every inch of tape
shot and that some could have been edited out without his knowledge.
There has been no explanation for why in some of the audio--especially
of shots while the agents are on the roof--the sounds of gunfire and
aircraft overflying the building cut in and out so erratically.
Attorneys'
Statements and Testimony
Davidian attorneys Dick DeGuerin and Jack Zimmermann, who
visited Mount Carmel during the siege, insist that there was extensive
evidence that BATF agents shot indiscriminately through Mount Carmel's
front doors, walls and roof. They were very concerned with preserving
this evidence of an out-of-control assault.
In early April, 1993 the New York Times reported, "both
lawyers clearly believed that helicopters flying over the compound
during the raid had fired into upper floors of the main building from
above." BATF Spokesperson Jerry Singer denied this. "The helicopters
did not overfly the compound on Feb. 28 and I have no information that
anyone fired from the helicopters." However, Jack Zimmermann stated,
and Dick DeGuerin concurred, "an expert will be able to tell from the
angle of the trajectory plus the pattern whether there are entry or exit
holes. If it's in the ceiling and it's clearly an exit hole, it had to
come from above. How else could it have come in?"23/
At trial Zimmermann, who is an army colonel and Vietnam
veteran, described eight or nine bullet holes coming into the ceiling of
David Koresh's bedroom in the top floor of the four story tower. "You
could see the sky through the roof. They appeared to be exit holes, and
the wood was splintered downward. My conclusion was that they came from
the sky."24/ He held that these holes could not have come from the
water tower, which was not as high as the four story tower. He did
acknowledge that bullet holes in the chapel roof could have come from a
Davidian shooting from the four story tower.25/
Helicopter
Pilots Lied About Circling Mount Carmel Before Raid
At trial three National Guard helicopter pilots testified.
Captain Bryan Dickens piloted a small OH-58 helicopter which carried
another national guardsmen and raid commander SAC Philip Chojnacki. CWF
Doyle L. Stone Jr. piloted another OH-58 which carried two national
guardsmen.26/ CW4 Jerry Seagraves piloted the large Blackhawk which
carried five guardsmen and eight BATF agents. BATF agents aboard
included Ted Royster, commander of many past aggressive raids and an
unofficial commander for this one, and lead investigator Davy Aguilera,
who had told Marc Breault that David Koresh should be "put away."27/
At trial two helicopter pilots claimed that they left the
staging area at Texas State Technical College at approximately 9:30
a.m. However, Captain Dickens revealed that flight log books had been
destroyed 90 days after the raid, so he could not verify the time the
helicopters left.28/ Pilot Seagraves made the not-very-credible
statement it took helicopters 15 to 20 minutes to fly the short six to
eight miles to Mount Carmel. While pilot Stone acknowledged the
helicopters flew to a "loiter point" while waiting for "ground forces"
to make their way to the "target," pilot Seagraves insisted that the
helicopters did not circle Mount Carmel.29/
However, KWTX-TV cameraman Dan Mulloney and reporter John
McLemore told a very different story at trial, one that discredited the
testimony of the pilots. Mulloney testified that the newsmen parked
their white bronco about two miles from Mount Carmel as they waited for
the helicopters they expected would warn them the raid was imminent.
When Mulloney saw the helicopters, he checked his watch. It was 9:30
a.m. During the next 10 to 15 minutes the helicopters "flew behind the
compound and made three big loops around the compound." Between the
second and third loops they drove their vehicle closer to Mount Carmel.
When they were a quarter mile away, Mulloney videotaped the helicopters
making their third loop as they came in for the raid. Defense attorneys
called John McLemore who repeated the exact same story.30/
In an interview for Arts and Entertainment television's
American Justice series, McLemore and Mulloney complained bitterly that
their allegation about the helicopters circling Mount Carmel is
"something that BATF and the FBI categorically deny. They tell us we
are lying."31/ However, the Treasury report does repeat KWTX-TV
cameraman Peeler's statement he also saw the helicopters between 9:15
and 9:30 a.m. from about a mile east of Mount Carmel. And it notes that
according to Waco Tribune-Herald cellular phone records, at 9:26 a.m.
photojournalist Robert Sanchez called his superior to advise him that
the helicopters were leaving the staging area.32/ Obviously the
helicopters had plenty of time to move to Mount Carmel and circle it
several times before the 9:48 a.m. beginning of the raid.
McLemore and Mulloney have no reason to lie about seeing the
helicopter make the three big loops. However, National Guardsmen might
have lied as part of the coverup of their witnessing illegal and deadly
firing from their helicopters. Their lies also cast doubt on their
assertions it was Davidians who fired the bullets found in their
aircraft.
Did
Helicopter Pilots Lie About Overflying Mount Carmel?
National Guard pilots testified that they approached Mount
Carmel flying southwest at approximately 500 feet. However, when they
got within 350 to 400 feet, Davidians shot at them so they immediately
broke off in a northeast direction. While one pilot admitted the
helicopters were as low as 50 feet off the ground, all stated they never
overflew the building.33/
KWTX-TV video clearly shows the helicopters low on the horizon
west of Mount Carmel several minutes into the raid, after agents are in
place behind parked vehicles. In later KWTX-TV footage the cameraman or
reporter clearly can be heard to say, "Two of them right over our
heads," evidently a reference to aircraft which can be heard noisily
flying above them.34/
At trial cameraman Mulloney stated that after the shooting
started, the helicopters were at approximately the same height as Mount
Carmel. He then lost sight of them. While defense attorneys did not
specifically question him about the statement "two of them right over
our heads," they did question him about the engine noises evident on the
video tape. Mulloney stated that there was a single-engined aircraft
overhead.35/ The Treasury report reveals that the surveillance aircraft
started at 2,500 feet and then circled at 1,500 feet in order to "spot
shooters."36/ It is possible that on February 28th military spy
satellites were taking photographs which could reveal just how many
times helicopters circled and whether or not they overflew Mount Carmel.
Did
Helicopter Pilots Lie about Shooting from Helicopters?
Defense attorneys questioned all three helicopter pilots about
whether National Guardsmen or BATF agents in the helicopters were armed,
whether the doors or windows were open, and whether there was any firing
from the helicopters. Pilots Dickens and Stone in the two small
helicopters (one of which held BATF raid commander Philip Chojnacki),
both asserted that the doors to their crafts were closed, no one held a
loaded weapon or was armed, and that no one fired from the
helicopters.37/
Defense attorneys concentrated their questions on Jerry
Seagraves who was the pilot of the Blackhawk helicopter which carried
eight BATF agents, including the belligerent Royster and Aguilera.
Seagraves recited the rules--"you cannot have any chambered rounds in
the weapon while in the aircraft and no weapon will be discharged from
the aircraft." However, he disclosed that the agents on board were
armed.38/
Seagraves asserted the cargo doors were closed during the
whole flight but revealed that the "door gunners window" was opened
because a BATF agent was shooting video out of it. (He said the purpose
of that window was to carry an M-60 machinegun but there was no such
machinegun.) Pilot Dickens testified that he saw one agent's head and
shoulders hanging out of the window as he shot his video camera.39/
Seagraves insisted he knew no one fired from the helicopter
because he had been in helicopters overseas in Vietnam and would have
recognized the sound of such gunfire. He asserted that no helmet,
radios or other gear would have stifled the sound. One defense
attorney, in an attempt to suggest a reason Seagraves might lie about
whether there was firing from the helicopters, made Seagraves confess
that his national guard pilot job was one of several odd jobs on which
he survived. As a former serviceman, Seagraves also may have put
loyalty to the national guard and his comrades above the Constitutional
rights of those living in what pilot Stone called the "target."40/
No Real
Investigation of Firing from Helicopters
The investigation of the helicopters' actions after the raid
was cursory and concerned with gathering evidence that Davidians fired
at and damaged the helicopters, and not the other way round. Captain
Bryan Dickens, the leader of the helicopter squad, debriefed Stone and
Seagraves and wrote the only report on the helicopters' activities. He
did not forward his report to the U.S. Attorney or the Texas Rangers.
The March, 1993 Texas Rangers' interview of Seagraves and June, 1993
Treasury agent interview of Stone certainly revealed no new
evidence.41/ At trial defense attorneys could not question BATF agents
who had been in the helicopters about whether there was firing from the
aircraft because Judge Smith effectively prevented the defense from
calling Chojnacki, Royster, Aguilera and other agents from the
helicopters as witnesses.
If these BATF agents finally are put under oath and admit
their crimes, it will be important that they not be allowed to seek
protection by claiming self-defense. For their justifiable fear of
prosecution is a primary motivation for the vicious treatment of the
Davidians by federal agents during the 51 days that followed.
DAVIDIANS
CLAIM HELICOPTER FIRE KILLED FOUR
If
indiscriminate fire from helicopters, which easily could have escaped a
dangerous situation, did kill four people, as Davidians claim, some BATF
agents surely would have been prosecuted. During the siege Davidians,
perhaps fearful that it would prompt the kind of assault the FBI
eventually launched, refused to tell the FBI how the following
Davidians died.
Peter Hipsman
Kathryn Schroeder and Jaime Castillo reveal Peter Hipsman,
28, was shot on the fourth floor. He may have been shot from a
helicopter, since the medical examiner revealed that the shots traveled
from left to right.42/ The Treasury report states Hipsman received two
allegedly non-fatal wounds from "more than four feet," one to the chest
and one through an arm. It claims he was "later killed by a cult member
who shot him at close range in the back of his skull--an apparent mercy
killing."43/ Kathryn Schroeder claimed that she overheard Neal Vaega
say it took "two shots to finish him off."44/ Like Perry Jones, Hipsman
probably chose to be killed by friends, rather than by "the beast."
Winston Blake
Davidians claim Englishman Winston Blake, 28, was sitting on
his bed, eating French toast, when a shot from a helicopter came through
the north wall and hit him in the head, killing him instantly.45/ As
stated previously, Clive Doyle alleges that the bullet passed through a
water storage tank outside the room. (The government claims these water
tanks were destroyed by the fire.) Jaime Castillo saw Blake's body in
the room just minutes after the shooting began.46/
Prosecutors alleged Davidians killed Blake because he would
not fight. However, at trial Kathryn Schroeder, who claimed Jones and
Hipsman were put out of their misery by Neal Vaega, did not claim Blake
was similarly shot.47/
The Treasury report alleges Blake died of "craniocerebral
trauma," and was shot from a distance of "two to three feet" by a "cult
member" using a ".223" bullet. The Tarrant County Medical Examiners'
official autopsy report on Winston Blake describes powder burns around
the wound, as if Blake had been shot from a few feet away. However, an
English pathologist conducted a second autopsy on Blake and concluded
that Blake had died from a long-range, high-velocity gunshot wound and
that the bullet had penetrated a wall before hitting him. This
disturbing finding led to a full fledged, if inconclusive, investigation
by Manchester, England, police in 1994 and 1995.48/
Peter Gent
Davidians assert an unarmed Peter Gent, 24, was cleaning the
inside of the water tower, heard the commotion, stuck his head out to
see what was going on, and was shot through the heart by an agent in a
helicopter.49/ The Treasury report states he died from a "distant"
9-millimeter hydroshock "perforation of aorta gunshot to upper lf.
chest."50/ The government denies he was shot from a helicopter.51/
At trial agent Lowell Sprague said he saw two men armed with
long rifles on the water tower and shot at them. Agent Roger Gutherie,
stationed northwest of Mount Carmel, near the hay barn, claimed he
actually did shoot an armed man on the water tower.52/ However, the
government has never alleged Davidians retrieved Gent's weapon when they
buried his body. And Texas Rangers found only a pistol in the tower and
"rifle arms for AR-15 or M-16" near the concrete room.53/
Jaydean
Wendell
Davidians claim Jaydean Wendell, 34, had just finished nursing
her baby and was asleep when a bullet shot from a helicopter came
through the ceiling and penetrated her skull, killing her.54/ At trial
attorney Jack Zimmermann, who visited Mount Carmel during the siege,
said he saw bullet holes by the "upper bunk wall" going in the direction
of a pool of blood on the bed. This suggests Wendell was shot from
above as she lie in bed.55/ The Treasury report offers no explanation
for Jaydean Wendell's death from "craniocerebral trauma" caused by a
"distant" shot from a 9-millimeter hydroshock bullet.56/
At trial Davidian prosecution witness Victorine Hollingsworth
testified she saw Wendell come out from her room looking for a gun and
return to it with one. Kathryn Schroeder asserted she saw Wendell's
body on the bunk and held her bloody gun.57/ Given the government's
desperate efforts to prove that agents were not firing from helicopters,
we must wonder if they pressured the women to give this testimony.
The bodies of Perry Jones, Jaydean Wendell, Winston Blake and
Peter Hipsman were buried in the tornado shelter. The FBI waited a week
before they allowed Davidians to bury Peter Gent's body in the yard.
Davidians were furious that FBI tanks ran back and forth over the grave
for the next five weeks.58/
NO EVIDENCE
BRANCH DAVIDIANS AMBUSHED BATF
BATF
has alleged all along that dozens of Davidians "ambushed" agents on
February 28, 1993. In June, 1993 BATF Intelligence Chief David Troy
told Congress: "This issue was unprecedented in the history of American
law enforcement, when you had 40 or more persons open fire
indiscriminately with automatic weapons at law enforcement, be they
state, or local, or federal. It never happened before."59/ Such BATF
ambush allegations repeatedly were disproved at trial. There is ample
evidence Davidians did not ambush BATF.
Koresh Warned
Undercover Agent "They're Coming"
By definition, the Davidians could not have ambushed BATF
because BATF commanders and agents knew the Davidians were expecting
them. Both undercover BATF agent Robert Rodriguez, at trial, and
Davidian Graeme Craddock, before the grand jury, testified about what
happened on Sunday morning, February 28, 1993. During a Bible study
with Rodriguez, Koresh was called away from the room, supposedly to take
a long distance phone call from England. When he returned, he was
visibly shaken. He told Rodriquez that he knew law enforcement was
coming. Graeme Craddock recalls Koresh saying, "Robert, they're
coming. Whether BATF or FBI or whatever, they're coming." Craddock
believes Koresh was trying to warn Rodriguez that some kind of raid was
imminent.60/
At trial Rodriguez said Koresh "told me the ATF and National
Guard were coming. 'They got me once. They'll never get me again!"
(Since neither BATF or the national guard had ever arrested or "gotten"
Koresh before, Craddock believes this comment was another warning.
Rodriguez grew alarmed as five of six Davidians joined the three already
in the room. Convinced they were going to take him hostage, he
considered diving through the window or even taking David Koresh
hostage. However, Davidians made no threatening moves. When Rodriguez
left, Koresh shook his hand as he bid him farewell.61/
Cautious
Koresh Warned Few Davidians
Agent Ballesteros testified that BATF was ambushed because the
Davidians did not shoot at them until they were close to the
building.62/ Doubtless, David Koresh prudently waited to discover if
approaching agents really intended to engage in a shootout or if their
intentions were peaceful. Ballesteros admitted that an unarmed David
Koresh came to the front door.63/ This is something no one planning an
ambush would attempt.
Graeme Craddock told the grand jury that he was one of just a
few who were given secret information that there might be a raid.
Koresh told Craddock not to fire unless Koresh told him to. Koresh
never did, and Craddock never fired.64/ At trial Kathryn Schroeder
testified that before the raid Koresh told women in the chapel to "get
back to your rooms and watch," something he would not have told them if
he expected shooting from building windows. She was dressing her
children when the shots began.65/ Sheila Martin argues she would not
have left her disabled son near a window if she was expecting a gun
battle.66/
At trial prosecutors mocked the Davidians for not using
non-violent action when they heard BATF was coming. They suggested they
could have called "9-1-1," gone out in the yard and sung peace songs,
quoted the Bible, waved protest signs, or lay down in front of the front
gate.67/ Prosecutors did not note the irony of their lecturing citizens
on the necessity of using non-violence to defend themselves against
brutal government attacks.
Davidians claim that Paul Fatta had taken many of their guns
to a gun show and that most of the rest were boxed to retain their
value.68/ Survivors contend few Davidians even were armed at first to
return BATF's gunfire. One who confessed some Davidians returned fire,
said: "People were running around everywhere, asking if anybody had any
guns. Nobody had any handy. Most of what we had was new, still in the
box."69/
After the trial one juror, reacting to the testimony, stated:
"They had 45 minutes to get their people positioned, to get the guns all
passed out. It seems to be quite apparent that there was no such plan
because of the hustle bustle to get the guns, even after the ATF drove
up."70/
Photographs
and Video Show Little Fire From Davidians
Waco Tribune-Herald photographs, which reporter Marc Masferrer
testified were all taken within the first 20 to 30 seconds of the raid,
show windows intact with screens still in place, and no one in the
windows, even as the agents are firing at the home. During the trial
one defense attorney asked if it would not have made sense for persons
planning an ambush to remove screens. Agent Ballesteros acknowledged
the photographs showed agents firing at the building, but no people or
guns visible in the windows. Reporter John McLemore said he never saw
any Davidians in the windows firing back. And agent Barbara Maxwell
testified she saw Davidian gunfire coming from only two second floor
windows during the whole shootout.71/
One Waco Tribune-Herald photograph shows two agents only a
dozen feet from Mount Carmel's front door kneeling and firing. These
agents are not hiding behind cars or fences, as one would expect were
they taking heavy gunfire. Agent Dan Curtis conceded at trial that he
could not explain why, if these agents were under such intense gunfire
from Davidians, they were not injured or killed.72/ Similarly, KWTX-TV
video of agents firing at the front of the building shows no evidence of
Davidian gunfire ripping up the ground or striking vehicles.
Two Agents
Killed Later in Raid
BATF Chief of Intelligence David Troy told the press that "in
the first two minutes, 16 agents were injured and four were killed,"
which allegedly supported BATF's contention agents were ambushed.73/
The Treasury report agrees: "Special Agents Steven D. Willis and Robert
J. Williams were killed during the ambush."74/
However, at trial BATF agent Dan Curtis stated Willis ran to
the porch area, then retreated behind a green and white Chevy Van and
participated in firing at the building for 15 to 20 minutes before being
shot. Agent Sprague confirms this account.75/
Robert Williams was shot while firing at the building from
behind an outside safe on the east side of the building. Agent Kevin
Richardson at trial claimed he was shot from the arms room. However,
KWTX-TV video shows no evidence Davidians are firing from the arms' room
in the first minute or so as agents climb the ladder--something agent
Buford was forced to concede under cross-examination. And it is
unlikely Davidians gained complete control of that area, and the ability
to fire out of its windows, until agents had left it several minutes
into the raid. This indicates Williams, who a defense attorney claimed
was firing at Mount Carmel, also was shot later in the raid.76/
Davidians Did
Not Use "Tactical Advantage"
Perched as they were in a large building on a hill with a
superior view of all oncoming vehicles, the Davidians had an excellent
opportunity to shoot at oncoming vehicles and kill dozens of agents, had
they chosen to do so. They did not.
Justice Department outside expert Alan A. Stone, M.D.
commented: "The BATF investigation reports that the so-called `dynamic
entry' turned into what is described as being `ambushed'. As I tried to
get a sense of the state of mind and behavior of the people in the
compound the idea that the Davidians' actions were considered an
`ambush' troubled me. If they were militants determined to ambush and
kill as many ATF agents as possible, it seemed to me that given their
firepower, the devastation would have been even worse. . .The ATF agents
brought to the compound in cattle cars could have been cattle going to
slaughter if the Davidians had taken full advantage of their tactical
superiority."77/
During the trial Kathryn Schroeder testified that none of the
exterior walls had been fortified with hay or barricaded until after the
initial ATF attack. Davidians then did so because everyone was
frightened.78/
Davidians
Called 9-1-1
One minute after BATF agents charged out of their cattle
trucks Davidian Wayne Martin, a Harvard-educated attorney, did what most
Americans do when they are under criminal attack--he called 9-1-1. His
desperate cries become etched in the minds of those who hear them:
"There are about 75 men around our building shooting at us in Mount
Carmel. Tell them there are children and women in here and to call if
off! Call it off!"
McLennan County Sheriff's Lieutenant Lynch, who BATF had
assigned to the "minor" role of fielding any calls about the raid that
might come from neighbors or motorists, ended up playing a critical
role. However, because his only contact, Sheriff's Lieutenant Barber,
had turned off his radio, it took Lynch nearly 40 minutes to establish
even indirect contact between the Davidians and BATF.79/
On the 9-1-1 tapes Martin and other Davidians plead with
Lieutenant Lynch to stop BATF's shooting, even as Lynch desperately
tries to contact BATF. BATF continues shooting even after contact is
established, Martin skillfully arranges a cease-fire and Davidians have
passed the word on cease-fire. Played for the jury, an hour of the
9-1-1 tape was the most compelling evidence that the Davidians had not
ambushed BATF agents but were fighting back in self-defense.
DAVIDIANS HAD
LEGAL RIGHT TO SELF-DEFENSE
A few
Davidians fought back against what they considered to be a murderous
assault by unknown attackers. David Koresh told his attorney Dick
DeGuerin in their March 28th audio taped telephone conversation: "I
don't care who they are, nobody is going to come to my home, with my
babies around, shaking guns around, without a gun back in their face.
That's just the American way."80/
Davidian Stan Sylvia, who was in California the day of the
raid, expressed his feelings on national television: "These people were
on their own property. That didn't give the government right to come in
shooting. . .For once in people's lives they stood up for God and what
they believed."81/
BATF's excessive force in attempting to deliver search and
arrest warrants--warrants they did not even have with them--gave
Davidians the right to use armed force in self-defense, even if it
resulted in the deaths of some attacking agents. The Firearm Owners
Protection Act of 1986 recognizes the Common Law rule of self-defense,
which is that the defender must have reasonable belief that the
circumstances of immediate danger warrant self-defense. And Section
9.31 of the Texas Penal Codes states: "The use of force to resist an
arrest or search is justified: (1) If, before the actor offers any
resistance, the peace officer (or persons acting at his direction) uses
or attempts to use greater force than necessary to make the arrest or
search; and (2) When and to the degree the actor reasonably believes the
force is immediately necessary to protect himself against the peace
officer's (or other person's) use or attempted use of greater force than
necessary."82/
Dick DeGuerin, who believed he would have obtained an
acquittal of David Koresh had he lived, explained, "if a warrant is
being unlawfully executed by the use of excessive force, you or I or
anybody else has a right to resist that unlawful force. If someone's
trying to kill you, even under the excuse that they have a warrant, you
have a right to defend yourself with deadly force, and to kill that
person."83/
One of the Justice Department's handpicked outside experts,
Dr. Robert Cancro, suggested Davidians were within their rights to
defend themselves. "Certainly an armed assault by 100 agents had to be
seen as an attack independent of who fired the first shot. If an armed
individual enters your home by force and you have reason to believe that
person represents a mortal threat, you are allowed to fire a weapon in
self-defense in most states. The law does not usually allow the
potential attacker to fire first before a response can be called
self-defense."84/
Davidian survivor Clive Doyle, who as acquitted at trial, told
an interviewer: "I believe there were a few people who grabbed some
weapons. I believe they retaliated because Perry and David had both
been shot at the front door without being armed. I guess some people
took the stand that they were defending the women, the children, and
their teacher. You might say it was in self-defense, or a reaction to
seeing people gunned down for no reason."85/
Imprisoned Davidian Livingstone Fagan has written: "Our use of
these guns were with restraint and strictly defensive. It is tragic
that people were harmed, but were our intentions anything but defensive,
the death toll would have been much higher."86/
QUESTIONABLE
EVIDENCE DAVIDIANS USED MACHINEGUNS OR GRENADES
The
Treasury report alleges "unrelenting automatic and semi-automatic
weapons fire" from the Branch Davidians.87/ At trial agents Dan Curtis,
Kris Mayfield, Robert Champion, Lowell Sprague, Clay Alexander, Larry
Shriver, Gerald Petrilli, Samuel Cohen and Bill Buford all testified
they heard machinegun fire coming from the Davidians.88/ However,
BATF's MP-5s, which fire two shots per trigger pull, also are, and sound
like, machineguns.
FBI weapons expert James Cadigan acknowledged there was no way
to tell if the few bullet holes found in cars facing Mount Carmel were
made with automatic or regular weapons.89/ A defense attorney pointed
out that if 50 Davidians used fully automatic weapons "we wouldn't have
four [agents] dead, we'd have 75 dead."90/ Another attorney said that
if the Davidians had ambushed BATF, "Those trailers would have looked
like Bonnie and Clyde's car, but they didn't."91/
After the raid BATF spokespeople continually claimed there was
.50 caliber machinegun fire--it was their primary excuse for keeping the
press far from Mount Carmel. However, while agents Dan Curtis, Kris
Mayfield, Kevin Richardson, Gerald Petrilli and Timothy Gabourie all
alleged they heard .50 caliber gunfire, only agents Curtis and Petrilli
alleged they heard .50 caliber machinegun fire. After the fire Texas
Rangers found two legal .50 caliber rifles. At trial FBI weapons expert
James Cadigan was forced to admit that he did not find any .50 caliber
cartridge cases with firing pin impressions, indicating that no .50
caliber was fired during the 51 days.92/
In early March, 1993 BATF officials alleged that "two of the
wounded agents were hit by fragments of hand grenades lobbed from the
compound."93/ Only one of those agents, Gerald Petrilli, testified.
But he was unsure what had hit him, describing it as, "a shotgun round,
explosive device or something."94/
EVIDENCE
FRIENDLY FIRE INJURED OR KILLED SOME AGENTS
It is
obvious that frightened, excited and angry agents were firing wildly
from the undercover house, from behind vehicles and structures
surrounding the building and, very probably, from helicopters. With all
that gunfire, it is inevitable that BATF agents injured, and even
killed, some of their own. In fact, the April 5, 1993 Newsweek reported
that a "federal source" in Waco stated "there is evidence that supports
the theory of friendly fire," and that during the assault "there was a
huge amount of crossfire."95/ Another highly placed federal source told
James Pate, "about half of ATF casualties in the raid apparently
resulted from `friendly fire'."96/ After these statements were made to
the press, BATF placed a gag order on its agents.
BATF Agents
Admitted Friendly Fire On Roof
There is one known case--and several suspected ones--of
friendly fire on agents who climbed to the second story roof over the
chapel and tried to enter what had been, months before, Koresh's second
floor living quarters--a bedroom on the west side and an arms' room on
the east side. The Treasury report and trial versions of two agents
killed on the roof, near the bedroom is substantially different from the
version BATF originally released, which held that three agents were
killed in the arms room.97/ The Treasury report concedes, "Contrary to
some publicly disseminated reports, none of the agents that entered the
armory were killed."98/ Some are convinced that the original BATF
report is true and the government is trying to coverup extensive
friendly fire on the roof. The fact that both BATF helicopter and
KWTX-TV video seems to have been cut at crucial moments only reinforces
this suspicion.
At trial agent Kenneth King testified that on the west side of
the roof, away from the KWTX-TV camera, agent Conway LeBleu's gunfire
"covered" himself, David Millen and Todd McKeehan as they tried to break
into what they thought was David Koresh's bedroom on the west side of
the roof. However, as soon as the agents--who never yelled "police" or
"search warrant"--broke the window, someone in the back of the room shot
at them. They did not even get a chance to throw their flash-bang in
the room to disorient the shooter. King was shot, McKeehan and LeBleu
were killed.99/ The government claims all were shot by Davidians;
others speculate some could have been shot by BATF wildfire, including
that from helicopters.
Agents Bill Buford, Glen Jordan and Keith Constantino threw a
flash-bang into and entered the old arms' room on the east side. They
admitted great confusion in the room as they and one or more Davidians
exchanged gunfire. They claim to have shot two Davidians inside.
Buford estimated he fired a total of 40 to 50 shots and that Constantino
fired 20-30.100/ (Davidian David Thibodeau confirmed deceased Davidian
Scott Sonobe participated in an exchange of gunfire with agents. Jaime
Castillo heard that David Koresh was the second Davidian shot
there.101/)
Constantino testified that he had heard that a portion of the
bullet removed from Agent Jordan was a 9-millimeter hydroshock bullet
like his own and acknowledged "it's possible" he may have shot
Jordan.102/ (F.B.I. agent Cadigan confirmed that the Q-87 bullet found
in Jordan came from a Sig-Saur, the gun carried by Constantino.) Under
cross-examination Constantino at first asserted that Jordan did not go
into his line of fire and might have been hit by a richochet. Later he
conceded that he had been behind Jordan at one point so he could have
shot him directly.103/
There is some evidence of coverup in this incident, as in so
many others. Prosecutors never called Jordan, the man most likely to
know whether agents or Davidians shot him, to the stand. And
Constantino revealed that he shared a room with Buford for several days
before Texas Rangers interviewed them, giving them a chance to compare
notes and alter their stories.104/
Video evidence of apparent friendly fire on the roof comes
from KWTX-TV video of agent Millen on the roof. After the three agents
in his team were shot, Millen ran back to the east side of the roof, to
the arms room window where Buford, Constantino and Jordan had entered.
The Treasury report merely notes that he "stood guard."105/ However,
video clearly shows Millen pull back the curtain of the armory and
either try to, or actually shoot into, the room. (Both "Waco, the Big
Lie" videos claim Millen threw something into the room; however, that
does not appear to be true and neither Davidians nor Jack Zimmermann
claimed to have seen evidence of a second grenade. Similarly, many
doubt the agent climbing the ladder shot himself in the leg, as the
video claims.) After Millen raises the curtain, there is a barrage of
return gunfire through the wall out toward him. At trial defense
attorneys asked Buford whether Constantino had shot at Millen, but he
denied it.106/
It was right after Millen shot in the window that bullets
began to fly down into the roof of the second story arms' room--bullets
possibly fired by BATF agents in helicopters. Millen rolled onto the
roof and then slid down the ladder.
If Millen did shoot into the room, he might have injured the
other agents. And if it were agents shooting back at him, he barely may
have escaped being a victim of friendly fire. The Treasury report's
list of injured agents did not include Millen.
Deaths of
BATF Agents
Official autopsy reports on the two agents who died on the
roof show that most of the bullets that killed them passed through their
bodies, mostly from above and in a downward direction. Conway LeBleu,
who two agents testified had been firing at Davidians in the tower, had
four entry wounds, including one to the head. Medical examiner Nizaam
Peerwani, M.D., testified that LeBleu also might have shot himself in
the face while falling. Found in his body were "a flattened fragment of
projective jacket with adherent core material" and "a distorted small
caliber full jacketed projectile."107/ Todd McKeehan, who was helping
King smash into Koresh's old bedroom, had one bullet wound to the chest
in which Peerwani found "a deformed fully jacketed bullet. .
.(consistent with a .223)."108/
At trial defense attorneys inferred that the two agents on the
ground who were killed could have been shot by friendly fire.109/ As we
have seen, there is definitive evidence that agent Steven Willis was
killed approximately 20 minutes into the raid, after firing numerous
shots at Mount Carmel. At trial Nizaam Peerwani, M.D., identified the
bullet that hit Willis' left temple as a 7.62 round.
Robert Williams, who was shooting from behind a safe on the
east side of the building, died from a gunshot wound to the head. Marc
A. Krouse's autopsy reported no bullets or fragments found in Williams'
body. Had he been killed by friendly fire, it is possible medical
examiners would have turned the incriminating bullets over to BATF
agents before the Texas Rangers were assigned to lead the investigation.
No Attempt to
Determine Source of Bullets
BATF formed a "shooting review team" to get details of agents
actions on February 28th but the U.S. Attorneys office ordered them to
shut it down because it was duplicating their investigations.110/
However, at trial agents claimed that this job really was given to the
Texas Rangers because they were more independent.111/ Nevertheless, FBI
weapons expert James J. Cadigan acknowledged that all Texas Rangers
evidence actually was turned over to FBI laboratories.
The FBI could not compare bullets and fragments from injured
and dead BATF agents to bullets fired from Davidian guns, which were
burned in the fire. FBI agent Cadigan's testimony suggests the FBI did
not bother to test BATF guns to compare them to bullets which wounded
agents, though pathologists noted in their autopsy reports that bullets
and fragments had been forwarded to the crime laboratory.112/ The
Treasury report notes that besides the four agents killed by gunshot, 20
agents were wounded, 7 by shrapnel and 13 by gunshot.113/ Therefore
there should have been a number of bullets available for testing by the
FBI.
BATF SNIPERS
KILLED RETURNING MICHAEL SCHROEDER
Woodrow Kendrick, Norman Allison and Michael Schroeder were at the
Davidians' rented garage, the Mag Bag, three miles from Mount Carmel
Center, when they heard about the raid. Around 5:00 p.m. the three
approached Mount Carmel on foot from the northwest in an effort to
re-enter the property and check on their families and friends. They
came upon BATF agents moving away from the hay barn and towards the
evacuation point. According to the Treasury report, "When the agents
identified themselves as federal agents, the cult members opened fire.
After a prolonged exchange of gunfire, one of the three cult members
surrendered."114/ (The Justice Department report claims the three
"ambushed" BATF agents and were attempting to "shoot their way into the
compound."115/
However, at trial agents alleged that only Schroeder had shot
at them. It was revealed that while Norman Allison was carrying a gun
zipped inside his clothes, he never took it out or fired it. And sniper
Roger Gutherie testified that while he had Woodrow Kendrick in his gun
sight, he did not fire because he could not see if Kendrick had a
gun.116/
BATF agents testified that after Schroeder fired at the 14
agents, they returned fire. The Treasury report notes Schroeder died of
six gunshot wounds, two of them to the head and three to the back.117/
Allison surrendered and Kendrick left the area. BATF agents did not
pursue him but did label him an escapee.
Neither Allison nor Kendrick, who were acquitted at trial,
have been outspoken about the day's events. Yet troubling evidence
suggests that angry BATF agents may have shot an unarmed Schroeder,
assassinated the wounded man, planted a gun and shells around his body,
and impeded the Texas Rangers' investigation in order to cover up their
crime.
Did BATF
Agents Shoot First?
At trial BATF agent Wayne Appelt disclosed that after the
morning gun battle, the agents in the barn area, most of whom were out
of sight of Mount Carmel, had heard radio traffic about wounded agents,
seen the wounded being removed, and discussed what had happened among
themselves.118/ Agent Guthrie, who claimed to have shot Davidian Peter
Gent already, stated that when agents left the barn they were looking
for "hostiles."119/
After the shooting, agents were so convinced that Schroeder,
Allison and Kendrick were perpetrators trying to leave Mount Carmel that
they refused to believe Allison's assertion the Davidians were trying to
enter the property.120/ BATF even released the story that Davidians
were trying to shoot their way out of Mount Carmel.121/)
Given their certainty that they had perpetrators in sight, it
is quite possible that after yelling "police" at the three men--who were
over 40 yards away and might not have been able to hear them
clearly--they began shooting. BATF agent Wayne Appelt claimed he saw a
man--Michael Schroeder--in the ravine shooting at them; agent Jimmy
Brigance admitted that he could not tell if Schroeder had a
gun--nevertheless he asserted Schroeder shot several shots; agent
Jeffrey Pearce testified he heard shots coming from Schroeder's
direction.122/ At trial defense attorneys brought out that these agents
had from three to ten days between the incident and their interviews by
Texas Rangers to concoct such a story.123/
Did Agents
Assassinate the Wounded Schroeder?
Neither the Treasury report nor agents at trial mentioned any
attempt to see if Schroeder was injured, dying, or dead, immediately
after the shooting. It is possible that after most agents left the area
with their captive, Norman Allison, two or three agents did in fact find
Schroeder--and kill the wounded man.
Four agents--Wayne Appelt, Jeffrey Pearce, Charles Myers and
Roger Gutherie--testified they heard gunshots in the distance as they
left the area; two mentioned hearing two gunshots. Prosecutors tried to
blame the gunfire on the fleeing Woodrow Kendrick--a slow-moving old man
with a heart condition.124/
Defense attorney questioning pointed to the theory that agents
approached the wounded Schroeder, shot him twice in the head, and then
removed his blue stocking cap, which would have contained powder burns
had he been shot at close range. Schroeder's autopsy report shows two
close-spaced bullet wounds at and above the right ear. A photograph of
Mike Schroeder's body at the site of his death showed him wearing what
looked like the blue stocking cap which agents Appelt and Pearce
described. However, the medical examiner revealed he always looks for
powder marks in shooting cases. He testified that he never received the
blue cap, and that had Schroeder been shot at close range wearing the
cap, it could have absorbed the evidence of such powder marks.125/
Did Schroeder
Have a Gun?
On March 3, 1993 the FBI sent a helicopter to find Michael
Schroeder's body. BATF agent Roger Guthrie testified that he went with
them to find the body "left there." Gutherie claims the helicopter set
down by Schroeder's body, he jumped out, grabbed a Glock 17
semi-automatic pistol and magazine laying next to the body, and then
flew off in the helicopter.126/ Prosecutors proved that Schroeder had
bought two Glock 17s, but did not establish that either was the gun
allegedly found near Schroeder's body.127/
While the Justice Department report claims that Schroeder's
body was "retrieved" that day, March 3rd, David Byrnes, head of the
Texas Rangers investigation team testified that it was not until March
5th or 6th (he could not remember the date) that the FBI could arrange
transport in a Bradley vehicle to actually retrieve the body. (The
autopsy was conducted a March 5, 1993.)128/ Ranger Thomas Almond
testified that when he got to the body he found a stun gun next to it.
Almond did not explain why a man supposedly carrying a pistol also would
be armed with, and evidently holding, a stun gun.
Almond also testified that on the hillside where the agents
were shooting he found 72 shell casings, one live shotgun shell and two
shotgun casings. He found only four projectiles between the body and
agents, and he did not know if these were from agents or Schroeder.129/
Evidently the FBI did not test these bullets, either.
Why did FBI
Impede Texas Rangers' Investigation?
According to the Justice report, for ten days after Michael
Schroeder's body was recovered, FBI siege commander SAC Jeff Jamar
refused to allow the Texas Rangers to finish investigating the area
where Schroeder was killed, something which greatly angered Texas
Rangers.130/ This permitted wind and weather to eliminate footprints
which might indicate whether Schroeder had turned toward or fired in the
direction of BATF agents, or whether several agents had approached
Schroeder as he lay wounded.
The lies that BATF and the Treasury Department have told
about Schroeder's death, retrieval of a gun by BATF agents who left the
body at the scene, the missing stocking cap, and the FBI's interfering
with the investigation, all suggest that BATF and the FBI are covering
up the intentional homicide of Michael Schroeder. The fact that the
government prosecuted Allison and Kendrick, both of whom were acquitted,
on such little evidence, suggests the two men were charged as part of
the coverup of the crime.
DESTRUCTION
OF THE "MAG BAG"
On
March 3, 1993 BATF agents served a search warrant on the Mag Bag. In
heavy-handed fashion, BATF used Bradley fighting vehicles. Agent Danny
Dwight testified that vehicles "gently" nudged open the Mag Bag's
doors. However, defense attorneys confronted Dwight with photos showing
crumpled metal and gaping holes and he confessed that the vehicles
"pushed in the front of the building."
During the search the building owner, who was not a Davidian,
pleaded with BATF agents to use the key and not to damage the
structure. He was later arrested for creating a disturbance.131/ After
BATF broke into the garage, thousands of dollars in specialty tools and
three $600 air compressors disappeared, possibly looted by BATF
agents.132/
FOOTNOTES
1.
Trial transcript. pgs. 144-45.
2. Jaime Castillo, private communication, January, 1994.
3. Judy Schneider, March 8, 1993 "home movie"; Treasury
Department report, p. 104.
4. Trial transcript, p. 511.
5. Treasury Department report, p. 95.
6. Trial transcript, pgs. 3170, 3228, 3277.
7. David Thibodeau, private communication, December, 1994;
Cause Foundation lawsuit (February 24, 19c94), p. 26; Clark lawsuit
(February 25, 1995), p. 28; Caddell & Conwell lawsuit (July 26, 1994),
p. 19.
8. Kirk Lyons, Cause Foundation, private communication, June,
1994.
9. "Mitchells in the Morning" show, National Empowerment
Television, May 31, 1995.
10. Marjorie Thomas testimony, November 17-18, 1993, pgs.
27-29, 144, 181, 197, 200; trial transcript, p. 3292.
11. Gary Null, April, 1994, p. 33; Jaime Castillo, private
communication, May, 1995.
12. J. Michael Kennedy and Louis Sahagun, March 30, 1993, A17.
13. "Koresh defends actions in tape of interview," Dallas
Morning News, May 28, 1993, 36A.
14. Dr. Philip Arnold, private communication, June, 1995.
15. Sue Anne Pressley, May 5, 1993, A17.
16. Trial transcript, p. 4616, 4618.
17. June 16, 1994 trial transcript, p. 147.
18. Ibid. pgs. 137-38; David Thibodeau, private communication,
July, 1995.
19. Jack DeVault, transcript of 9-1-1 tape, p. 223.
20. Trial transcript, pgs. 6481-82, 6504.
21. Trial transcript, pgs. 2545, 2727.
22. Ibid. pgs. 3327-28.
23. New York Times, April 5, 1993, A10.
24. "Defense Rests Without Calling Cultists," New York Times,
February 18, 1994.
25. Trial transcript, pgs. 6646, 6795-96.
26. Ibid. pgs. 3230, 3255.
27. Clifford L. Linedecker, p. 27; Kirk Lyons, private
communication, June, 1994; James L. Pate, June, 1994, p. 33; trial
transcript, p. 3192.
28. Trial transcript, pgs. 3162, 3230, 3284.
29. Ibid. pgs. 3231, 3212, 3256.
30. Ibid. pgs. 3314-3317, 6547-54.
31. "American Justice" program, "Attack at Waco," August 3,
1994.
32. Treasury report, p. 92.
33. Trial transcript, pgs. 3162, 3178, 3184, 3202-03, 3226,
3256, 3297.
34. The first video shot can be seen in "Waco, the Big Lie."
It is referred to in the trial transcript, p. 3179. The second is in
"Waco, the Big Lie Continues."
35. Trial transcript, pgs. 3322, 3334, 3346.
36. Treasury report, p. 172.
37. Trial transcript, pgs. 3225, 3266, 3275.
38. Ibid. pgs. 3161, 3185.
39. Ibid. pgs. 3164-65, 3295.
40. Ibid. pgs. 3164-65, 3209, 3231.
41. Ibid. pgs. 3199, 3234, 3246, 3281-82.
42. Trial transcript, pgs. 4477, 5992; Jaime Castillo, private
communication, March, 1994.
43. Treasury Department report, p. 101.
44. New York Times, February 6, 1994.
45. David Thibodeau, private communication, January, 1995.
46. Trial transcript, pgs. 3058-59.
47. Ibid. p. 7312.
48. Treasury Department report, p. 104; "British Police Slam
Davidian Siege," The Balance, newsletter of the Cause Foundation,
March-April, 1995, p. 2.
49. Ron Cole, Sinister Twilight, (Portland, OR: Augie Enriquez,
1993), p. 48.
50. Treasury Department report, p. 104.
51. Brad Bailey and Bob Darden, pgs. 172-73.
52. Trial transcript, pgs. 2212-13, 3828.
53. Ibid. pgs. 6053, 6057.
54. James L. Pate, "What the Feds Don't Want you to Know about
Waco," Soldier of Fortune, October, 1993, pgs. 101-02; New York Times,
April 5, 1993, A10.
55. Trial transcript, p. 6603.
56. Treasury Department report, p. 104.
57. Trial transcript, pgs. 4093-94, 4490.
58. David Thibodeau, private communication, July, 1994.
59. House Appropriations subcommittee hearing, June 9, 1993, p.
173.
60. Trial transcript, p. 6384.
61. Ibid. pgs. 3394-95, 3407-10; Graeme Craddock, private
communication, July, 1995.
62. Ibid. p. 1382.
63. Ibid. pgs. 1377, 1381.
64. Ibid. pgs. 6386-90.
65. Ibid. pgs. 4459-62.
66. "Day 51" video; Dan McGraw, "One True Believer's Trials and
Tribulations," U.S. News & World Report, January 17, 1994.
67. Trial transcript, pgs. 7074, 7313, 7345; June 16-17, 1995
trial transcript, p. 191.
68. Ron Cole, Sinister Twilight, (Portland, Or: Augie
Enriquez), p. 32.
69. James L. Pate, October, 1993, p. 102.
70. Teresa Talerico, March 3, 1994.
71. Trial transcript, pgs. 1929, 1480-88, 1850-51, 1858, 6554,
2270.
72. Trial transcript, pgs. 1850-51, 1858.
73. Roy Bragg, "Ill-fated ATF raid: the beginning of the end,"
Houston Chronicle, April 20, 1993, 17A.
74. Treasury Department report, p. 100.
75. Trial transcript, pgs. 2069, 2216-17.
76. Ibid. pgs. 2006, 2242, 2691, 2728, 7165, 2704.
77. Alan A. Stone, M.D. report to Justice Department in Report
and Recommendations Concerning the Handling of Incidents Such As the
Branch Davidian Standoff in Waco, Texas, November 8, 1993, pgs. 18-19.
78. Ken Fawcett, p. 26.
79. Treasury Department report, p. 105.
80. Houston Chronicle, May 28, 1993.
81. Maury Povich television show, November 8, 1993.
82. Larry Pratt report, p. 6.
83. Houston Press, July 22, 1993.
84. Robert Cancro report to the Justice Department, 1993, p. 3.
85. Gary Null, April, 1994, p. 33.
86. Livingstone Fagan paper, August, 1994, p. 15.
87. Treasury Department report, p. 101.
88. Trial transcript, pgs. 1744, 1957, 1966, 2064-67, 2077,
2091, 2142, 2222, 2331, 2405, 2523, 2689, 2706.
89. Ibid. p. 1223.
90. Ibid. p. 7269.
91. Teresa Talerico, "Attonreys give closing arguments," Waco
Tribune-Herald, February 21, 1994, 10A.
92. Trial transcript, pgs. 1251, 1558, 1744-46, 2000, 2331,
2463.
93. Mary Jordan and Sue Anne Pressley, "Cult Leader Wants to
Die a Martyr in `All-Out Firefight,'" Washington Post, March 9, 1993.
94. Trial transcript, p. 2363.
95. "Was It Friendly Fire?", Newsweek, April 5, 1993, p. 50.
96. James L. Pate, July, 1993, p. 53.
97. Jennifer Nagorka, "Agents seen on roof in video were among
ATF casualties," Dallas Morning News, March 3, 1993; Newsweek, March 15,
1993, p. 54.
98. Treasury Department report, p. 100.
99. Trial transcript, pgs. 2545-2550.
100. Ibid. pgs. 2840-50.
101. David Thibodeau on "A Current Affair" television program,
May 3, 1993; Jaime Castillo, private communication, January and
February, 1995.
102. Trial transcript, pgs. 2582-83.
103. Ibid. pgs. 2852-3, 2874-5, 6125.
104. Ibid. pgs. 2854-5.
105. Treasury Department report, p. 98; trial transcript, p.
2737.
106. Trial transcript, p. 2740.
107. Ibid. pgs. 2545, 3154, 5998, 6002-37; Marc A. Krouse, M.D.
autopsy report.
108. Trial transcript, p. 5998; Nizaam Peerwani, M.D. autopsy
report.
109. New York Times, January 17, 1994; trial transcript, pgs.
116-22.
110. Treasury report, p. 197.
111. Trial transcript, pgs. 2384-6, 3658.
112. Ibid. pgs. 1247, 1257-58.
113. Treasury Department report, p. 102.
114. Ibid. p. 111.
115. Justice Department report, p. 25.
116. Trial transcript, p. 3842; "Ranger Says FBI Moved Evidence
at Davidian Site," San Antonio Express-News, January 13, 1994.
117. Treasury Department report, p. 104; trial transcript, p.
3835.
118. Trial transcript, pgs. 3524-25.
119. Ibid. p. 3844.
120. Ibid. pgs. 3631, 3729.
121. Ibid. p. 3631; "The Seven Week Siege," Washington Post,
April 20, 1993, A8.
122. Trial transcript, pgs. 3620, 3666, 3699, 3746.
123. Ibid. pgs. 685, 698.
124. Ibid. pgs. 3623, 3666, 3795, 3833, 3795.
125. Ibid. pgs. 3618, 3668, 6011-13, 6047; Nizaam Peerwani,
M.D., autopsy report.
126. Ibid. 3822-23.
127. Ibid. pgs. 1105, 4037.
128. Justice Department report, p. 38; trial transcript, p.
642.
129. Trial transcript, pgs. 3863-64.
130. Justice Department report, p. 229.
131. Scott W. Wright, "Agent Says Armored Vehicles Used on Shop
to Ensure `Safety'," Austin American Statesman, February 1, 1994.
132. James L. Pate, July, 1994, p. 49. |